News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Acquires North by DiabloD3 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:55AM (#23691349)
Sigh, all I can think is yet another promising startup vanishes into the depths of Google, never to be seen again.

Google, please stop buying companies, please learn to support your products and build a loyal customer base. You are not a startup anymore, you need to make the transformation that companies like Microsoft did, and quit moving fast and breaking things.

People don't want an agile foundation, they want a hundred year foundation.

Re:Google Acquires North by peeters on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:16PM (#23691614)
I'm not sure "promising startup" describes North (previously Thalmic Labs) that well. Everything I've heard around the Waterloo tech scene is that it was mostly smoke and mirrors from the founders who were able to maintain their own lifestyles using grants from the Canadian government. Tales from past employees are not flattering. Being bought by Google is likely the best thing that could happen to both the founders and the employees, if Google acquires the latter.

https://www.reddit.com/r/kitchener/comments/hg11tl/a_vision_...

Re:Google Acquires North by macNchz on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:18PM (#23692393)
I lived across the street from their Brooklyn store from when it opened in 2018 to when it closed last winter (in anticipation of "relaunching" for the new glasses they were planning this year).

They rented an expensive glassy corner storefront ($50k/month I heard at the time) and built it out to a very high standard, but there was never anyone inside shopping. The store employees just stood around looking at their phones all day looking super bored.

I also found it bizarre that they didn't seem to be making any effort to use the space as a marketing tool beyond it's mere presence...I anticipated when they opened that there would be VIP/media/influencer events on a regular basis, but they seemingly just opened in the mornings and closed at night. Having been involved in opening some retail stores, "if you build it they will come" was certainly never part of our strategy.

There never seemed to be any attempt to attract customers or make the store more inviting at all...they didn't even have a listing on Google Maps for months after they opened. Seeing this stagnant shop every single day I spent a lot of time thinking about what must be going on inside this outwardly "promising startup" to make such an investment only to let it languish. Seems like my suspicions weren't misplaced!

Re:Google Acquires North by trhaynes on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:32PM (#23692559)
I walked by it every day and can confirm. They didn't even have an inviting sign, or anything about what they were selling. The glass was a little reflective so you could barely see some mirrors and glasses on walls/pedestals. I'll bet most people walking by thought it was a typical optical store (but with only one boring frame option!).
Re:Google Acquires North by jwilliamson on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @07:10PM (#23695875)
There was an article in the Globe and Mail a few days ago saying each store was averaging about 10 sales/week, which certainly meshes with the store always being empty.
Re:Google Acquires North by misiti3780 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:05PM (#23692917)
where was it in BK?
Re:Google Acquires North by jmkb on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:17PM (#23693043)
Cobble Hill, corner of Court Street and Congress, https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6414917575

edit -- I guess I should close it on OSM ;)

Re:Google Acquires North by ornornor on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:42PM (#23691936)
> mostly smoke and mirrors from the founders who were able to maintain their own lifestyles using grants from the Canadian government

This describes a surprisingly high number of companies I’ve worked at in Canada. These SRED credits keep afloat so many companies that should have otherwise perished and that won’t ever go anywhere.

You can even hire SRED consultants that will help you milk those credits as much as possible (for a fee of course). You can then apply for more credits to pay off these SRED consultants fees, as I understand it... While producing little to no commercial value, and coast on these for years.

Re:Google Acquires North by ttarabula on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:37PM (#23692623)
I’ve noticed the same thing. Have you found any good writing on this topic and how the American approach differs from the Canadian approach? I’ve been fascinated by this dynamic after spending most of my working life in the USA then returning to Canada, and just feeling like something is “off” whenever I talk to Canadian startups, and it feels like a lot of the time it comes down to the way the flow of investment differs here (especially in the R&D space).
Re:Google Acquires North by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:02PM (#23692890)
imho it's not just the flow of investment. It's the smallness of the community. Many of the founders in the Toronto tech scene all know each other. From private school etc. At least when I was working for one 10 years ago, it all felt very incestuous and small.

Also in the US there's a real sense of having to hunt and compete for talent, but at least then in the Toronto startup scene you were to feel blessed for not having to work for a bank or insurance company, so put up the with the bullshit and dysfunction please...

Re:Google Acquires North by Wagthesam on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:28PM (#23693165)
This was one of the main reasons I left for the Bay area. I had a big network in Toronto but I felt like 5 years here I would be more talk than execution
Re:Google Acquires North by robhunter on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:19PM (#23693067)
Moved back two years ago and can echo this sentiment. We raised our most recently round exclusively in the US. Will be interesting to see how COVID-19 impacts all of this given how much more remote work will be available.
Re:Google Acquires North by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:37PM (#23693253)
Before Google acquihired my team I ended up jumping ship to a NY based company from the Toronto startup I was at. Difference in culture was night and day.

With the increase in remote work availability I'd probably hunt for work from US companies at this point rather than beg for crumbs from Canadian startups.

Re:Google Acquires North by amscanne on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:36PM (#23692604)
> You can then apply for more credits to pay off these SRED consultants fees

Even better, many SRED consultants work on a contingent basis, i.e. they just get a fraction of your SRED refund!

Re:Google Acquires North by Scoundreller on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:05PM (#23692211)
Supposedly SRED accountants are some of the best paid in Canada, next to transfer pricing accountants.
Re:Google Acquires North by 908B64B197 on Friday July 03, 2020 @02:36PM (#23726328)
SRED is a cargo cult thing mostly.

The American approach is to finance fundamental research that's just beyond what's currently possible and viable (take a look at the Apollo Program and the semiconductor industry or any modern DARPA challenge) while the Canadian one seems to be a kind of cargo culting of Silicon Valley where some non-technical civil servant looks for keywords in a form to grant money or not.

Re:Google Acquires North by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:00PM (#23692858)
When I worked in a startup, just feeding the SRED consultant with info ended up eating hours and hours of time. The intent of the credit is for real foundational engineering research but the reality seems to be is that it ends up getting eaten by companies that are just applying existing tech in mostly non-novel ways, and consultants get to try to spin it otherwise.

It needs to be replaced.

Re:Google Acquires North by kentt on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @07:30PM (#23696021)
Yes. Each company I worked for has spent many man hours and consulting wages on SRED. The claims were 100% BS.
Re:Google Acquires North by KKKKkkkk1 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:48PM (#23691997)
My experience with the startup scene in another country agrees with your description. When tech is funded by government incubators, it tends to become a fake imitation of the VC funded industry that we know from Silicon Valley. Which often is itself a fake imitation of actual innovation, so (fake imitation)^2.
Re:Google Acquires North by burkaman on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:40PM (#23692647)
> When tech is funded by government incubators, it tends to become a fake imitation of the VC funded industry that we know from Silicon Valley.

Seems a little strong?

https://www.iqt.org/portfolio/ (Cockroach Labs, GitLab, DataRobot, databricks, Cloudera, mongoDB (I know), probably more you've heard of)

https://www.energy.gov/lpo/portfolio/portfolio-projects (Tesla)

https://www.sbir.gov/news/success-stories (Qualcomm, iRobot, 23andMe, Orbital ATK, countless others)

https://sbir.nih.gov/statistics/success-stories

https://sbir.nasa.gov/success-stories

https://sbir.<any agency here>.gov/

https://www.darpa.mil/Timeline/index.html (the internet, voice recognition, virtual reality, GPS, onion routing, the computer mouse, touchscreens, etc.)

Also, the many startups that were spun out of public universities and government-funded research.

Re:Google Acquires North by snowwrestler on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:55PM (#23692814)
Sure there have been hits, but there have been a lot of failures too.

The problem with "government VC" is not the low hit rate--private VC has a low hit rate too.

The problem is also not that government funds get gamed--private VC gets gamed too. See WeWork for an absolutely enormous example.

The problem is really with the different cultural expectations for government vs private capital.

If a private VC firm loses 95% of their investments to failure and fraud, but has huge hits with the remaining 5%, well, that's just how VC works. The only thing that really matters is their net. If they end up with a big return, they are geniuses.

But if the government loses 95% of their investments, that's a ton of wasted taxpayer money. That's a lot of fodder for press, politicians, and activists to make hay out of. And if the remaining 5% are hits, well, the government does not exist to turn a profit. So the credit does not work out the same, even if the hit rate is similar.

Re:Google Acquires North by burkaman on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:09PM (#23692955)
I agree there is an issue with credit and public anger over "wasted" money, but clearly innovation is still happening, that was my point. The occasional Solyndra media frenzy hasn't stopped the government from investing in startups.

And one point in favor of government VC: it often isn't primarily profit-driven. Look for example at the energy.gov portfolio. While they obviously want their money back, they aren't trying to pick unicorns; they're trying to improving Americans' lives by improving the environment and the economy.

> LPO can provide first-of-a-kind projects and other high-impact energy-related ventures with access to debt capital that private lenders cannot or will not provide.

This is true of a lot of government investment. It's a good thing, on balance, that the people choosing government investments are not paid based on how much profit they generate or how many users they amass.

Re:Google Acquires North by baldajan on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:18PM (#23693056)
"able to maintain their own lifestyles using grants from the Canadian government" - that's absolutely false. North/Thalmic was flush with cash for a long time, and though their Myo didn't sell "well" - it still brought in millions.

Not denying the founders had lavish lifestyles, but they were running a company that raised 15M series A, and 120M series B - so that's honestly "expected". The grant I assume you're referencing was a 34M loan, which was to be paid out over time, and was recalled once North announced layoffs last year.

I won't defend their business decisions or argue they were a "promising startup" - I think they deserve the criticism. But I'd rather not throwout some false stories or accusations.

Re:Google Acquires North by modeless on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:28PM (#23693166)
It's "expected" that founders extract millions from a failing company while employees working for years at below market salaries get nothing? I don't disagree but it's just sad.

The startup lottery just doesn't make sense for employees, even early ones. Founder is the only position worth holding. Early employees need to start demanding more from their founders.

Re:Google Acquires North by 8ytecoder on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:37PM (#23693260)
My personal experience strongly says so as well. Been a very employee at two different companies - at least one made an “exit” - only the founder made any money at all. I took a deep pay cut for two years.
Re:Google Acquires North by antoniuschan99 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @04:21PM (#23694338)
The startups my dev colleagues worked in Toronto, the ones that got acquired none got any equity. I think it’s common in Toronto for employees at startups to not get equity. Ive also read canadian founders often sell below their companies worth
Re:Google Acquires North by blahbhthrow3748 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @07:56PM (#23696217)
That's not correct, it sounds like they got rolled.
Re:Google Acquires North by 908B64B197 on Friday July 03, 2020 @02:40PM (#23726363)
I'll put it differently, they raised almost as much as what Google was willing to pay for the Intel Vaunt patents.

They got to milk government grants for a few years and managed to sell the company (really the patents) at a premium before it went bankrupt.

Had they been able to sell more units and make a viable product they would probably have been able to raise more.

Re:Google Acquires North by gt2 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @04:04PM (#23694199)
Is it just common knowledge the founders have lavish lifestyles or was there talk in articles about the company/product?
Re:Google Acquires North by baldajan on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @05:20PM (#23694922)
I know them.

Maybe lavish is a bit of hyperbole. And after their 15M series A, I can assume they had competitive salaries given their life decisions (modest homes and cars).

Re:Google Acquires North by corobo on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:27PM (#23691763)
> mostly smoke and mirrors

In fairness isn't that how this tech works

Re:Google Acquires North by justinclift on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:58PM (#23692127)
The smoke bit is only for development, when accidentally plugging things in the wrong way around. ;)
Re:Google Acquires North by 908B64B197 on Friday July 03, 2020 @02:30PM (#23726289)
The public announcement really make it sound like an acquihire, but in practice it sounds like an acquihire without the hire. Really what Google is after are the patents that North bought from Intel[0].

From what I've been told the current employees won't even be offered to interview at Google, much less hired. They might keep some of the folks around until the support for their existing products end, but if they do it will be from their offshoring development center in Canada. Only the patents and the tech is really going to Mountain View. That paints a pretty dark picture of the business; it seems they didn't improve a lot on the tech that they got from Intel. Google is paying a premium to make sure the patents don't end up at Apple.

No words on the founders either, that typically means they won't be part of the AR team at Google. Else it would have been announced.

[0] https://techcrunch.com/2018/04/19/intel-abandons-vaunt-smart...

Re:Google Acquires North by vikramkr on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:44PM (#23691956)
North was not doing so hot - they've been looking for an acquirer for a while now and were facing running out of money. So, not exactly a promising startup at the current moment unfortunately. Based on the announcement that second gen focals are cancelled as a part of this acquisition, it doesn't even seem like they're pretending it's to continue the product line etc - it seems pretty clearly for the tech/patents/etc

https://9to5google.com/2020/06/25/alphabet-north-focals/

Re:Google Acquires North by 908B64B197 on Friday July 03, 2020 @02:48PM (#23726433)
They barely produced 1'000 units. It would be pretty hard to support these.
Re:Google Acquires North by mike_d on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @06:04PM (#23695315)
> all I can think is yet another promising startup vanishes into the depths of Google, never to be seen again.

Like what? Android, YouTube, DoubleClick, ReCAPTCHA, Waze, VirusTotal, Nest, DeepMind?

Aside from search every major Google product is built on an acquisition. Maps was Keyhole and Where2. AdWords was Applied Semantics. Google Docs is Writely, and Tonic. Google Voice is GrandCentral. Google Analytics is Urchin. Google Shopping is BeatThatQuote. Google Flight is ATA. etc. etc. etc.

Whatever startup you're bitter about probably wasn't going to make it outside Google anyway and it was an aquihire, or Google gave them the runway to prove it out and it didn't work.

Re:Google Acquires North by chimerasaurus on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:07PM (#23691498)
Disclaimer - I’m a Googler.

As a counterpoint, Cloud has acquired several companies that haven’t disappeared; rather, are fairly foundational in the portfolio:

- Cask (now Cloud Data Fusion as a product, CDAP as an OSS project)

- Looker

- Stackdriver

Re:Google Acquires North by macNchz on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:52PM (#23692042)
Stackdriver did not disappear, but having used it daily for the past 4 years and witnessed its painfully slow and buggy migration into the GCP admin, I can't say it's a product that has visibly gotten much love. We kept using it for some things out of inertia, but I can't say it ever impressed me.
Re:Google Acquires North by three_seagrass on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:18PM (#23692391)
How so? I've only ever used it on GC, not pre-acquisition.
Re:Google Acquires North by troutwine on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:41PM (#23692655)
Prior to the acquisition Stackdriver was never best of breed among its peer group but it was acceptable. Post-acquisition the feature set appears as an end user to have more or less frozen and their UIs feel haphazard: dashboarding is a mess, the trace UI is very complex without really giving me greater query power over alternatives and the options for converting one kind of data stream into another (logs to metrics, traces to logs to metrics etc) just aren't there. Google tightly integrates Stackdriver into its other products -- I assume that's where most of the labor for the Stackdriver team has gone -- but it feels cheap and like they've had to intentionally limit options to force buy-in. For what it is, Stackdriver is surprisingly expensive and their SDKs are quite complicated for what they end up accomplishing. Why should the end-user need to internalize Stackdriver Metrics' API to be able to produce metrics about their application? (I am sympathetic to the notion that this SDK is low-level and meant to be consumed by higher-level APIs like OpenTelemetry et al).

Nowadays the Stackdriver suite just feels left behind. There's plenty of other options in this space that have a nice internal integration and are reasonably inexpensive to purchase, or run yourself. If Stackdriver weren't so tightly integrated with Google's other cloud products I have to imagine it would get even less use than it does now.

Re:Google Acquires North by macNchz on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:01PM (#23692869)
Most of the things that bothered me were fairly minor, but taken together they just didn't give me the impression that there was a lot of effort going into the product. Lots of janky UI (filtering/browsing logs being particularly cumbersome), and a bunch of things that seem promising at first but are very much "lite" versions of more powerful products like Pingdom/Sentry/DataDog. Also I always felt like the monitoring metrics were not as well integrated into the GCP system as they should have been, given that they're under the same roof...we spun up a Prometheus cluster to do it by hand instead.

Also, until recently the admin lived outside of the main GCP admin and logging into it required some kind of redirect-bouncing oauth handshake that was consistently buggy for me. Something to do with browser defaults/3rd party cookies along the chain of redirects that would cause an infinite loop. I managed to work around it on my work computer, but it was broken for at least a year...not awesome for a tool you'll be logging into in emergencies, often from other devices.

Re:Google Acquires North by ciguy on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:30PM (#23692540)
Using Stackdriver as an example here shows how out of touch people at Google are with their customers. Stackdriver has been terrible for years and has visibly become worse over time rather than better.
Re:Google Acquires North by sidcool on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:07PM (#23691503)
Firebase?
Re:Google Acquires North by lowdose on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:22PM (#23691696)
Isn't Looker a talent acquisition for Data Studio?
Re:Google Acquires North by chimerasaurus on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:17PM (#23693044)
No, they are quite separate.
Re:Google Acquires North by outside1234 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:18PM (#23691648)
This was a talent acquisition from the looks of it.

North had failed and this was an exit that was better than bankrupcy.

Re:Google Acquires North by 908B64B197 on Friday July 03, 2020 @02:47PM (#23726417)
There's no talent to acquire. Google is in for the patents.

Employment is explicitly not guaranteed at Google, and if so it'll be from their satellite office. And no words on the founders coming onboard at Google which is a sign that they really aren't interested by the company itself.

North shipped about 1'000 units in its lifetime, barely different than the Intel Vaunt, and their V2 was still exclusively CGI rendering on their website with no launch data in sight.

Re:Google Acquires North by bserge on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:26PM (#23691748)
Yeah, I remember when they acquired that impressive autocorrect startup (they had something about context awareness and closest letter misspells)... Android's gboard autocorrect still sucks :/
Re:Google Acquires North by frandroid on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:08PM (#23692248)
Swype. I really miss my swype keyboard. I kept it installed for the longest time after it got acquihired, until they shut down one of the remote servers or something, and then it would crash. Why could they not move that code over to Gboard? It was so good.
Re:Google Acquires North by andybak on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:05PM (#23692911)
I'm still using swipe keyboards out of pure muscle memory but they suck compared to how Swype used to be. I swear I'd be better off learning to type conventionally now but it's been too long.
Re:Google Acquires North by frandroid on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:23PM (#23693094)
Especially when it comes to dual-language support... Swype was excellent at determining which language you meant to use.
Re:Google Acquires North by wvenable on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:18PM (#23691642)
Given that this is the first mention of North I've heard in a long time it was probably necessary for them to be acquired.
Re:Google Acquires North by kartayyar on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:03PM (#23692901)
"Promising" could not be a more incorrect choice of words. It almost sounds like Google did them a favor.

This looks like a distressed fire sale rather than a good exit, considering the product failed.

Re:Google Acquires North by rvz on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:15PM (#23691601)
> Google, please stop buying companies, please learn to support your products and build a loyal customer base. You are not a startup anymore, you need to make the transformation that companies like Microsoft did, and quit moving fast and breaking things.

It's actually not Google's fault. It's the founders of these startups who can't resist their offer nor can they do anything to control the company once they have taken lots of venture capital and are driven for an exit.

Snap resisted acquisition from Facebook and Google. Dropbox resisted Apple buying them, so the fault isn't with the acquirers. It's all the founders fault for accepting it.

Re:Google Acquires North by leadingthenet on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:37PM (#23691882)
Are Snap and Dropbox really examples of what companies should do??
Re:Google Acquires North by rvz on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:01PM (#23692880)
For resisting to selling your company because of another competitor wanting to buy you out? Yes, that is the example I'm talking about, not what they actually do which you seem to have insinuated. You would have asked the exact same question 24 years ago when Apple was months away from bankruptcy at the time even when it was in legal battle with Microsoft and Intel.

It's also not limited to those companies I mentioned, but 15 years ago, Microsoft, Google, Viacom, Myspace, Yahoo, AOL all wanted to buy Facebook pre-IPO and FB resisted all attempts and they have now become highly profitable themselves as such that they have owned the social media market. Even Netflix was approached an offer of $50 million by Blockbuster and resisted a buyout.

Given the hindsight of the growth of those companies, including Apple and Facebook, had you'd been the CEO of either of them, you'd think that selling wouldn't have been a good idea.

Re:Google Acquires North by leadingthenet on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:41AM (#23700358)
Right, but my point was that both Snap and Dropbox would’ve been better off being bought out, imo.

Netflix and Facebook, sure, but you didn’t quite use a convincing example to support the argument.

Not that I disagree with the spirit of what was said...

Re:Google Acquires North by narrator on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:58PM (#23692847)
This trend will continue forever because, the way modern corporate capitalism is set up, publicly traded companies have a VASTLY lower cost of capital than private companies. Thus, private companies who are profitable at a much higher cost of capital can be bought almost risk free by public companies and run poorly and still be worth it because the public companies get money so cheaply.
Re:Google Acquires North by sidcool on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @12:07PM (#23691501)
I agree with your sentiment but I also feel that a hundred year foundation starts with nimbleness and agility in mind.
Re:Google Acquires North by Frost1x on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:08PM (#23692259)
If corporate personhood is an accepted philosophy (corporations, businesses, etc. gain many legal abilities as real people in our society)...

Is an acquisition of a startup akin to slavery (buying another person to do work for you), adoption (raising an orphaned kid), cannibalism (consuming the entity to be apart of yourself to feed some entity life-force need), or something else?