News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by robg on Saturday July 05, 2008 @06:33AM (#236847)
Pantheists do find God in a lump of coal. So too do coal miners and energy conglomerates. :)

Aquinas called God "Pure substance through pure act". It's very hard not to see a definition of matter and energy there and given by a "Saint".

Dawkins here is insisting on a definition for which his professional training gives no special insight. So why should he be recognized as some "expert"?

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by dfranke on Saturday July 05, 2008 @07:01AM (#236857)
So why should he be recognized as some "expert"?

He doesn't have to be. The argument stands on its own: you can define "God" to be whatever you want, but the definition that you advance approaches tautology.

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by robg on Saturday July 05, 2008 @07:14AM (#236864)
And who stands outside time and space to define the tautology? Dawkins is substituting one definition for all definitions. Problem is, his definition is neither necessary nor sufficient. Furthermore, the traditional problem with organized religion is the same: specific, and sometimes powerful, people failing to see that outcome with their own definitions.

Sure, "God" could be whatever you want it to be. But that's exactly the point. It's a personal relationship (or lack thereof) defined by you. And no amount of science can take that away. If anything, the failures of modern physics (and soon neuroscience too) deepens my appreciation for the religious perspective.

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by 0x44 on Saturday July 05, 2008 @10:19AM (#236941)

  And who stands outside time and space to define the tautology? 
That statement has no meaning.

There is no fundamental understanding regarding the concept of "outside time and space", because our knowledge of them both derives from experience. To have some understanding of 'outside', you would have to have received that information a priori. That would mean that everyone had received that information, however.

Since, we can readily determine that the difference between believers and non-believers is a matter of experience. The difference between the two has nothing to do with "outside" either time and space, because that "outside" is not experiencable (at this point in time).

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by robg on Saturday July 05, 2008 @09:38PM (#237479)
You missed my point. The problem with a definition for God is that it would take God to check that proof. That's where dfranke said it "approaches tautology" and I agree. We just can't ever be sure that what we come up with is correct or circular. That's faith and humility rolled into one. And it's where I most disagree with Dawkins. His definition doesn't speak for me, and his training gives him no special insight into the problem.
Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by astine on Saturday July 05, 2008 @12:06PM (#237014)
"To have some understanding of 'outside', you would have to have received that information a priori. That would mean that everyone had received that information, however."

No it wouldn't. Perhaps I'm just special.

a priori knowledge is knowledge gained without experience. There is no reason it has to be universal.

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by 0x44 on Saturday July 05, 2008 @12:23PM (#237033)
All a priori knowledge we have discovered so far, is universal at least to the locality that we can see.
Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by astine on Saturday July 05, 2008 @01:32PM (#237090)
That doesn't matter.
Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by 0x44 on Saturday July 05, 2008 @07:28PM (#237404)
Perhaps not. How would you presume that a "mundane" person tell the difference between genuine a priori knowledge held by a "special" person, and the rantings of a supposed prophet?

edit:

This should not be taken that I'm implying that believers are ranting prophets. Just a query as to how you propose to tell the difference.

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by astine on Saturday July 05, 2008 @11:26PM (#237556)
I wouldn't. If is knowledge is truly a priori, and you truly didn't have it, there would be no way that you could know.

My advice would be to look at the person. If the man seems rational and honest, then maybe there is something to it. Then again, maybe not. It's really up to you.

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by 0x44 on Sunday July 06, 2008 @08:20AM (#237783)
Can a person seem rational and honest while discussing special knowledge they have that is neither experiencable or verifiable?
Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by astine on Sunday July 06, 2008 @02:00PM (#237910)
What seems rational and honest is based more on your prejudices than anything else. Ultimately, who and what you choose to believe is up to you. If you choose to restrict yourself to only what can verified without assumptions, you will end up with solipsism. If you choose to believe everything that comes your way, you will end up very confused. If you find some arbitrary 'halfway' heuristic, then you'll probably be better off. Just never forget that it is a heuristic that you are using as a criterion, or else your belief will be just as arbitrary as those who wait for alien spaceships to take them to bliss.

Really, its arbitrary. Just make up your mind.

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by gruseom on Saturday July 05, 2008 @11:28AM (#236976)
the failures of modern physics (and soon neuroscience too)

Since I understand you're a neuroscientist by training, what do you mean by "and soon neuroscience too"?

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by robg on Saturday July 05, 2008 @09:44PM (#237483)
I'd say we are already there but the pretty pictures are still very alluring. One example: Consciousness appears to be within grasp with the massive datasets already collected. The problem comes down to explaining, or reducing, consciousness in terms of that data. We might be able to show you what happens in the brain when you see beauty or feel pain, but that explains the experience of neither. The questions remain even as the science is the best it's ever been. I think this reality is much more glaring in modern physics.
Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by gruseom on Saturday July 05, 2008 @10:31PM (#237509)
Yes, I thought that might be what you had in mind. It always struck me as a silly non sequitur to observe biochemical or neurological changes in the brain of a person experiencing X (the classic example being mourning the loss of a loved one) and conclude that X has biochemical or neurological causes or can be reduced into those terms. Of course, that's the way the pendulum has swung in psychiatry for 40 years now too.

It's not obvious to me that consciousness can explain itself.

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by IsaacSchlueter on Sunday July 06, 2008 @12:44AM (#237594)
Dawkins here is insisting on a definition for which his professional training gives no special insight. So why should he be recognized as some "expert"?

To paraphrase Dawkins' speech to the University of Kentucky,

The thing about being an atheist is that you don't think that "theology" is a subject at all. You're not an expert in fairies, but I'll bet you have no problem not believing in those.

Actually, since Dawkins is an expert in Ethology, the evolution of animal behavior, he is in fact uniquely qualified to talk about religion, as that is among the most odd, fascinating, paradoxical, and complex behaviors that evolution has yet produced. In The God Delusion, he outlines many of the factors of the human animal that make us particularly susceptible to religion.

Theologists are the ones not qualified to analyze religion.

Re:Why are geeks often atheist? by robg on Sunday July 06, 2008 @02:04AM (#237648)
"In The God Delusion, he outlines many of the factors of the human animal that make us particularly susceptible to religion."

And yet none are testable hypotheses. In other words, he's no longer doing science unless he can propose some experiments with predictions. They're just so stories that give the illusion of understanding without verification. Hmmm, seems an awful lot like faith creeping in...

Now, that's not to knock evolutionary theory. It's just a massive reach, without an empirical net, to try to apply it toward explaining away religion.