News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple and Facebook by alexashka on Monday June 29, 2020 @01:01PM (#23679413)
It's sad to see somewhat bright minds, spending their life analyzing what companies are doing to maximize profit.

Why is that interesting and at what point do you notice that every move these companies make, is anti-human?

Take Apple: their entire business model is reliant upon the government never waking up to enforcing open standards and protocols to ensure consumers get hardware-agnostic, operating system-agnostic, service-provider agnostic, company-agnostic tools and services, which is what everyone would agree we want, except the sociopaths who value profit over humanity and run these corporations.

That's what got everyone excited about Bitcoin for a hot second. That it finally escapes the walled gardens all technology is living under. Instead of fixing the walled gardens, these delusional fools think they can technology their way out of corporations owning all key infrastructure. Jesus Christ.

Back to Apple.

Apple's entire business strategy is creating a walled garden because it benefits them, at the expense of everyone else. They give consumers crumbs and call it 'the biggest release ever'.

Facebook's entire business strategy is being a surveillance network, which is again, entirely reliant upon the government never waking up to how creepy, immoral and counter-productive it is on so many levels! There are enough sociopaths in government who think oh good, a surveillance tool, we can make use of it! Good luck having Facebook regulated when we live in a corporatocracy folks!

Everything these big companies do is against the interests of human beings. People are just too dumb to see it because if you drip-feed them 'new emojis' and 'you can have a weather widget on your screen in 2020', they don't realize they are getting fucked!

Sorry, carry on with your 'analysis' of what these sociopaths are up to and pretending you have valuable insight, when the only sane insight to be had is 'these fuckers are out of control'.

Re:Apple and Facebook by WoodenChair on Monday June 29, 2020 @01:08PM (#23679509)
> Why is that interesting and at what point do you notice that every move these companies make, is anti-human?

Hyperbole if I've ever read it. "every move"? Is investing in clean energy to power all of their data centers anti-human as Apple has done? Is creating a $100,000,000 education fund for under-represented app developers anti-human? Is encrypting devices by default to protect privacy anti-human?

Now, as you can see I'm a bit of an Apple apologist and of course all of these are good PR moves. But every corporation is by definition just a "group of humans working together for profit." They will do good things for profit and they will do bad things for profit. But a group of humans working together for profit does not make every move they do "anti-human."

Re:Apple and Facebook by bonestormii_ on Monday June 29, 2020 @01:33PM (#23679901)
There are certainly shades of gray, but if I can speak on behalf of the post you are responding to, it seems their argument would be that it is a net negative, and that the "Good PR humanity" is relatively shallow in the end.

Consider a $100,000,000 education fund for app developers. Certainly, app development can be a gateway for some people, but once they develop apps, where do they go if not a market place that Apple tightly controls? They are a machine funding the creation of new cogs in this scenario.

If your overlords buy you an opulent dinner and provide you with a warm bed, it doesn't mean you are free.

Freedom can be a vague and high-minded ideal that obviously needs to be balanced with communal concerns, but I agree with the parent poster's overall disgust. It feels that a company like Apple is so big that they are beyond any societal control or regulation, and that is unacceptable. To hear their minions rush to their defense as if their interests are somehow aligned (they're not) is too much to handle sometimes. It's tiring.

Re:Apple and Facebook by WoodenChair on Monday June 29, 2020 @01:44PM (#23680033)
You are free from entities that don't have coercive control over you. If there were no alternatives to the Apple ecosystem to get your work/social life/business done, then you would be correct, we are not free. However, iOS has <20% global marketshare[0].

Don't get me wrong, I agree with you that the App Store needs reform. Perhaps there should be some regulation, that's above my pay grade. Your level of disgust also to me feels like hyperbole.

0: https://www.statista.com/statistics/236031/market-share-of-i...

Re:Apple and Facebook by bonestormii_ on Monday June 29, 2020 @02:07PM (#23680360)
Oh yes, the fabled <20% marketshare.

So where should I go from Apple if not into the waiting arms of Google/Android? Is that better?

This isn't actually a conversation specifically about Apple if you recall. It is a conversation about all such companies. And yes, your defense of Apple is a little cringe-y. Why do you need to defend such a behemoth in a conversation that is decidedly not dedicated to them? Per the parent comment--Why does HN obsess over the actions of these companies that are categorically not for anyone's benefit other than their own? That was the original question.

I honestly am asking you to reflect on it. Why do you care? What's it to you?

Re:Apple and Facebook by WoodenChair on Monday June 29, 2020 @02:30PM (#23680698)
> I honestly am asking you to reflect on it. Why do you care? What's it to you?

I care because I think there is a lot of misdirected energy and anger. In a world with racial injustice, starvation, poverty, etc. you choose this topic to be outraged about?

Well you have a right to your outrage. It’s good some people are outraged because it keeps them on their toes. But at the same time I have a right to say I think your dialogue and vitriol is out-of-line with the reality of the situation, and hyperbolic at best. I am a counter-balance to your outrage and that’s why I care.

Re:Apple and Facebook by bonestormii_ on Monday June 29, 2020 @02:44PM (#23680904)
That's a well-reasoned response which I can appreciate. But honestly, read my original post to which you replied. I said I shared the parent's disgust, but I don't think I'm really reveling in outrage or speaking in such extreme terms as you characterize.

I'll quote it...

> "There are certainly shades of gray, but if I can speak on behalf of the post you are responding to, it seems their argument would be that it is a net negative, and that the "Good PR humanity" is relatively shallow in the end. Consider a $100,000,000 education fund for app developers. Certainly, app development can be a gateway for some people, but once they develop apps, where do they go if not a market place that Apple tightly controls? They are a machine funding the creation of new cogs in this scenario.If your overlords buy you an opulent dinner and provide you with a warm bed, it doesn't mean you are free.Freedom can be a vague and high-minded ideal that obviously needs to be balanced with communal concerns, but I agree with the parent poster's overall disgust. It feels that a company like Apple is so big that they are beyond any societal control or regulation, and that is unacceptable. To hear their minions rush to their defense as if their interests are somehow aligned (they're not) is too much to handle sometimes. It's tiring."

Honestly, I use so much language to balance and mitigate my argument that it's overly verbose.

> "There are shades of gray", "relatively shallow", "Certainly, app development can be a gateway for some people...", Freedom can be high-minded and needs to be balanced,".

Is it possible to make this point passively enough to satisfy your requirements?

I'll also admit that the parent comment was a bit more extreme in it's tone. And I'll admit there are many injustices in the world that go beyond tech. But I think the underlying issue of acquiring and maintaining freedom of all kinds is valid.

It's like saying, "With racial inequality being what it is, how can you spend your time belaboring a point about campaign finance reform?" The answer is simple: Because one form of freedom (in this case, governmental representation) facilitates those adjacent freedoms (racial equality). The importance of one doesn't invalidate the importance of the other.

I'm like, not that outraged. But I am like, casually disgusted by people who seem to have allowed huge corporations to become so apart of themselves that they lose the ability to see some obvious flaws.

I love my iPhone. Apple is far from the worst of it. But there are some very disturbing trends in tech and the world that warrant our skepticism and yes, our disgust. That it is treated as normal is part of the problem.

Re:Apple and Facebook by WoodenChair on Monday June 29, 2020 @02:53PM (#23681031)
> Apple is far from the worst of it. But there are some very disturbing trends in tech and the world that warrant our skepticism

Well we can agree on that. I am basically speaking against the reductive argument “big corporation = bad.“

Apple does good things and Apple does bad things. On balance I think they do more good than bad. We can have a debate about that. But we can’t debate if the opposition just thinks big corporation = bad and no freedom. I chose Apple because that is the company that started this discussion.

Re:Apple and Facebook by alexashka on Monday June 29, 2020 @03:24PM (#23681456)
> Take Apple: their entire business model is reliant upon the government never waking up to enforcing open standards and protocols to ensure consumers get hardware-agnostic, operating system-agnostic, service-provider agnostic, company-agnostic tools and services, which is what everyone would agree we want, except the sociopaths who value profit over humanity and run these corporations.

Did you read this and the only conclusion you came away with, is big corporation = bad?

Feel free to address what's actually been said, rather presenting a straw man.

--

Let me clarify why big corporation = bad is a straw man because I suspect some uneducated people may take your position seriously.

Big corporation = bad is in fact a truism, if the government that's supposed to regulate corporations, is not doing their job. This is political science 101.

There are people far more educated and likely smarter than you and I who don't consider USA a functioning democracy. Noam Chomsky considers USA a plutocracy. Have you studied this matter and have rebuttals to numerous arguments that he has presented to support his case?

Re:Apple and Facebook by WoodenChair on Monday June 29, 2020 @03:40PM (#23681671)
> Let me clarify why big corporation = bad is a straw man because I'm suspect some uneducated people may take your position seriously.

> There are people far more educated and likely smarter than you and I who don't consider USA a functioning democracy.

You may have some good points, but your level of vitriol and overall tone really detracts from them. From the beginning where I pointed out your hyperbole, to your most recent comment where you're effectively calling people dumb and uneducated. If I need political science 101, then you need debate 101.

Re:Apple and Facebook by askafriend on Monday June 29, 2020 @02:14PM (#23680443)
> I honestly am asking you to reflect on it. Why do you care? What's it to you?

What a phenomenal way to shut down conversation.

"Why do you care?" is such a spineless response. It could be used in any conversation regarding any topic for an easy out.

Either engage with the conversation or don't.

Re:Apple and Facebook by bonestormii_ on Monday June 29, 2020 @02:17PM (#23680495)
I'm not trying to shut down the conversation.

In this case it is the conversation. "Why do we defend and obsess over 3rd party business interests of corporate giants?" is the topic we are discussing. Keep up.

Re:Apple and Facebook by newbie578 on Monday June 29, 2020 @02:08PM (#23680371)
Quite convenient how you look the iOS marketshare at the global scale :) Is there an organization regarding antitrust cases that works on a global scale like UN? Last I checked the U.S. antitrust commitee looks at the U.S. economy, not how many iOS users are there in Kenya, India, etc.

It is only fair that you look at the iOS U.S. marketshare, and what would you know, they have over 50% ;)

https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/north-amer...

Re:Apple and Facebook by WoodenChair on Monday June 29, 2020 @02:35PM (#23680758)
50% is not a monopoly last I checked. It’s an oligopoly but at least a highly competitive one with two very different value propositions (privacy/closed ecosystem vs openness/lower prices). Basically every computing landscape ends in oligopoly due to network effects - personal computers 1990s (Windows vs Mac), video game consoles (Nintendo vs Sony vs Microsoft), mainframes 1970s (IBM vs 7 dwarves), etc. Argument is almost as strong at 50% IMHO. At 90% not so much (Google Search, Microsoft Windows, Android almost globally)
Re:Apple and Facebook by newbie578 on Monday June 29, 2020 @05:29PM (#23683354)
In some industries a monopoly can even be with a marketshare about 25%, but nevermind, 50% is widely regarded as the average threshold, as you can see on justice.gov :(

"Some courts have stated that it is possible for a defendant to possess monopoly power with a market share of less than fifty percent.(29) These courts provide for the possibility of establishing monopoly power through non-market-share evidence, such as direct evidence of an ability profitably to raise price or exclude competitors. The Department is not aware, however, of any court that has found that a defendant possessed monopoly power when its market share was less than fifty percent.(30) Thus, as a practical matter, a market share of greater than fifty percent has been necessary for courts to find the existence of monopoly power.(31)"

https://www.justice.gov/atr/competition-and-monopoly-single-...

Re:Apple and Facebook by askafriend on Monday June 29, 2020 @01:18PM (#23679652)
As a consumer, I pay more to buy Apple devices because Apple is a walled garden that exercises tight control over its ecosystem. I like the walled garden and it results in a ton of benefits to me as a consumer (the fact that you couldn't even list one benefit just shows that you haven't meaningfully explored your own questions or opposing viewpoints).

You used a lot of words to basically say nothing meaningful and show that you actually don't understand these companies or their customers.

Re:Apple and Facebook by jmull on Monday June 29, 2020 @03:20PM (#23681410)
> Take Apple: their entire business model is reliant upon the government never waking up to enforcing open standards and protocols

If the government mandates protocol X, then protocol X is no longer open.

The body directing the development of protocol X becomes an extended part of the government (or simply a direct part), and is subject to an entirely different level of political influence.

> People are just too dumb to see it...

I honestly don't believe you can share, understand, or speak for the interests of people you hold in contempt. The thing is, they aren't dumb, no more so than you, I or anyone else. You may not understand their perspective, but they have one whether you can see it or not.

Re:Apple and Facebook by bonestormii_ on Monday June 29, 2020 @01:20PM (#23679677)
I couldn't agree more with this. "Drip feeding 'new emojis'" sent chills down my spine.

The problem always seems to be the question, "How do you get a decentralized system to a reach critical mass of mainstream usage?"

Consider the concept of a labor union. The word "union" implies a unification, formalization, and to some extent a centralization of workers around an administrative structure that is not the business that employs them. I think many people would agree that such a union is a necessary counter force if you want to achieve progressive workplace reforms.

Technology to free us from the walled garden always pursues decentralization as a means to evade control. But there must be some unified, centralized force promoting it early on.

The downside to this is that it creates a large attack surface vulnerable to legal threat and infiltration of competing interests. However, we can't replace the global internet with enmeshed home networks. We can't replace fiber with dreams, or iphones with raspberry pis.

It would be great if the governments represented the people, and did not act like some self-interested third party so much of the time. Perhaps, the government--our government--would be an appropriate body to administer a formative revolution. But since we know that they like to spy, control, and arbitrarily regulate, it forces the question of how to form a dedicated central entity powerful enough to promote the changes we want to see, but resistant to the trappings of other corporations and government.

It's a deep question that arises when you pursue freedom of any kind.