News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by damnyou on Sunday June 28, 2020 @07:54PM (#23673010)
Correct. Apple's overall strategy with its short 7-year lifecycles is to use planned obsolescence in order to continue extracting money from its consumers.

An 8 year old desktop running Windows 10 or Ubuntu 20.04 is perfectly functional today, and will continue to be kept up to date for many more years in the future. An 8 year old Mac Mini runs either of those OSes pretty well. Now that Boot Camp will no longer be supported, an Apple Silicon Mac Mini bought in 2020 would have to be thrown away in 2028 since it will no longer receive security patches.

This is... not good.

Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by kt103099 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @09:00PM (#23673359)
What drives most of the limited backward compatibility is the amount of testing required. If you want to officially support new features on an older harder platform, you should test that they work. And fix any bugs found. And maybe some of those older machines don't have hardware for a new feature, so you have to devise a way to fail gracefully. At some point you just need to cut off the older platforms and move on. Similar reasons many web developer complained in the past about having to support old versions of Internet Explorer. No one accused anyone of 'planned obsolecense'.

BTW, the author of this article is not ignorant in these affairs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_Sinofsky

Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by damnyou on Sunday June 28, 2020 @09:43PM (#23673604)
Apple makes far too much money for this to be a legitimate excuse.
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by mthoms on Sunday June 28, 2020 @10:04PM (#23673705)
I thought the article illustrated very well why "money" should not be the prime consideration for supporting something (in the short to medium term). They're playing the long game.
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by damnyou on Sunday June 28, 2020 @10:39PM (#23673870)
Tell that to all the game developers whose games can no longer be played on Catalina.
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by wpm on Monday June 29, 2020 @12:41AM (#23674405)
You act like dropping 32-bit was a surprise.

They had two years to get ready for 64-bit only, though the writing was on the wall for more than 5. They didn't. Either they didn't care, didn't find it worthwhile, or they didn't even exist anymore.

Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by mthoms on Monday June 29, 2020 @12:21AM (#23674300)
Tell them what? Those developers already know that Apple is known for removing support for aging technologies way ahead of the curve. They also know that being willing to move fast and break backwards compatibility is what makes Apple, Apple. It's a major point of the article:

>There’s a whole book to be written about the “deal” a company makes to [...] promise compatibility. The reward of success is extremely high, but it is almost a Faustian bargain because you will absolutely cede the right to innovate

No one said that there weren't downsides to Apple's approach. The downsides are well known. And, as a user I'm slightly annoyed about the loss of 32-bit support. But if 32 bit support and backward compatibility is important, there's plenty of options including Windows, Linux or dual-booting MacOS versions [0].

Personally, I'm willing to suffer the short term pain of lost backward compatibility because I'm excited about the future of computing. As a user and developer I've already lived through 16->32->64 bit transitions (and similar disruptions). They suck at the time, but they're ultimately worth it. You can't stop progress.

[0] https://www.macworld.co.uk/how-to/mac-software/dual-boot-mac...

Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by LeoPanthera on Sunday June 28, 2020 @09:15PM (#23673450)
I think you are confusing "won't run the latest macOS" with "doesn't get security updates", which simply isn't true. Apple is still providing security updates for Macs well over a decade old.
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by damnyou on Sunday June 28, 2020 @09:43PM (#23673599)
Ahh, last I checked Apple would only do 1 more year of security updates. Glad to see they've changed their stance.

10 is better than 7 but not as good as the 15+ years Windows and Linux offer.

Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by andrewnicolalde on Sunday June 28, 2020 @10:20PM (#23673790)
When on earth did you check??
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by tpetry on Monday June 29, 2020 @01:30AM (#23674633)
They are not absolutely wrong. Old macOS versions do get security updates sometimes. Almost all the time when something really critical has bern found, but the most current macOS is receiving much more security updates. And i dont believe that these more security bugs are only in the newest version. Maybe they are hard to fix in old versions because they can‘t be backported?
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by valuearb on Monday June 29, 2020 @01:47AM (#23674733)
Apple has by far the highest customer satisfaction in the business. An 8 year old Mini is still going to run fine for years to come.

Apple should put its efforts into creating the future fir those willing to pay for it, not grumps with 8 year old computers too cheap to upgrade to far better hardware.

Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by robertoandred on Sunday June 28, 2020 @08:55PM (#23673326)
Ten- and eleven-year-old Macs are getting security updates now. Why do you think that will change with Apple silicon?
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by FireBeyond on Sunday June 28, 2020 @10:53PM (#23673922)
Which ones are those? Not the 2009 iMacs that can run, at most 10.11 El Capitan, which stopped receiving security updates two years ago.
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by kalleboo on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:16AM (#23687140)
macOS High Sierra runs on the following Macintosh computers:[5]

* iMac: Late 2009 or later

* MacBook: Late 2009 or later

* MacBook Pro: Mid 2010 or later

* MacBook Air: Late 2010 or later

* Mac Mini: Mid 2010 or later

* Mac Pro: Mid 2010 or later

Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by cercatrova on Sunday June 28, 2020 @09:44PM (#23673611)
And I mean, if you're a company that does planned obsolescence and your users will continue to buy your latest products without caring about repairing them, why wouldn't you continue to use planned obsolescence?
Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by cafed00d on Sunday June 28, 2020 @11:07PM (#23673994)
it depends on how much "consumer effort" repairing costs.

Most people seem to replace their phones on a regular 2-3 year cadence. Much less so on laptops -- and surely Macs tend to get supported for long period of time; I can run Big Sur on a 6 year old Mac.

Same with iPhones -- iPhone 6S is going to run iOS 14.

As a consumer, if I were to buy an alternative to the iPhone -- which is practically _only_ Android -- then I'm looking at software obsolescence much earlier;

I mean, look at Android 11 & iOS 14. iPhones released in 2015 are still supported but Android 11 goes only as far back as Pixel 2, a phone from 2017.

So it doesn't seem like Apple is a company that is using "planned obsolescence" from a purely functionality perspective.

Sure, hardware degrades in quality overtime -- but that's a function of physical constraints -- not business strategy to get people to buy new stuff; well, at least for the _most_ (some?) part.

Re:Apple’s Relentless Strategy, Execution, and Point of View by arvinsim on Sunday June 28, 2020 @11:50PM (#23674177)
Last time I heard, Apple was an environment conscious company.