News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by dragonwriter on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:21AM (#23667234)
You don't present an argument for an upper limit on how advanced past civilizations can have been without detection but for an excluded middle, because, sure, a civilization at our level would be easily detectable, but one that developed to where it could operate without environmental pollution and which could clean up the pollution that it made on the way to it's advanced state would not be so detectable.
Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by thaumaturgy on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:53AM (#23667346)
This is a line of thinking that wanders away from intellectual curiosity and into intellectual madness. You're describing a process that would somehow "undo" micro- and macro-scopic effects and chemistry in rock and ice records around the world -- including those on the ocean floor -- without, itself, leaving any trace. It would be like peeling the skin off an onion, running that layer through a food processor, and then delicately gluing it all back on, and not being able to tell the difference under a microscope.

That's wizard wand technology, not fusion.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by dragonwriter on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:04AM (#23667383)
> This is a line of thinking that wanders away from intellectual curiosity and into intellectual madness.

When we’re talking about the prospects of a more advanced human civilization in a time from which we have artifacts (but, obviously, not ones that are more obviously advanced than standing stones into which people read improbable histories), if you aren't going to lean hard into intellectual madness, what's the point?

> That's wizard wand technology

I prefer “sufficiently advanced” to “wizard wand”, but the former is, as they say, indistinguishable from the latter.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by thaumaturgy on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:20AM (#23667439)
Heh. I tend to pretty rapidly lose interest in subjects when they go from "huh, that's kinda neat" to young-adult fantasy storytime. It's a mental self-defense against the kinds of ideas that sneak up on clever people and trick them into believing dumb things.
Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by partyboat1586 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @06:20AM (#23667844)
You can consider the ideas without accepting them as true. You don't need a self defence. Feed your imagination and it feeds creativity.
Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by dmix on Sunday June 28, 2020 @05:05AM (#23667596)
This sort of historical fantasy is surprisingly rampant. From History channel pushing 'ancient astronauts' to the founder of the 1619 NYTimes project writing an article claiming African people were helping mesoamerican Aztecs build pyramids and the Olmec stone heads - predating the arrival of Columbus and the Europeans [1].

I'm always skeptical of any sort of hidden ancient advanced culture claims. The capabilities of bored humans over an extended hundreds/thousand year timescales is always underrated. Even without modern technology trading and just the night sky to be inspired by.

Same the complex earthworks and manipulations of the environment created by indigenous Americans which is the thesis of 1491 book [2]. Or even in the complex large scale network of Eel farming in by natives in South Australia which surprised the European explorers [3]. Or even how Convergent evolution works in nature.

[1] https://www.scribd.com/document/466921269/NYT-s-1619-Project...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1491:_New_Revelations_of_the_A...

[3] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/may/23/budj-bim...

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by mc32 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @11:09AM (#23669230)
It sounds like children’s magic wand thinking.

Convert all trash into its pure elements. Take chemical elements and transform into magic city, etc.

It’s fantastic but not based on reality.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by Broken_Hippo on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:27AM (#23667464)
Let me ask you: If the earth had some major event tomorrow and basically everything quit working, do you think we'd forget about things such as the internet, phones, indoor plumbing, vehicles, or electricity?

No, probably not. We'd rebuild, though some areas of the world would rebuild better or more equally than others. I don't know why folks think the past was any different. This is the main reason I highly doubt the past was some weirdly advanced paradise. I mean, why the heck would we need to invent, say, the chimney if the past was so advanced? Sure, folks in the past were smarter than we give credit for and sure, we've eshewed some things in the past - but the major things have stuck around.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by thaumaturgy on Sunday June 28, 2020 @05:01AM (#23667580)
Ehhhh. It might be because so many recent events have given me cause to be disappointed in people, but I don't think a massive loss of cultural memory is all that implausible. We have great numbers of people now who either don't believe vaccines are safe, or don't believe the Earth is round, or don't believe in evolution, or don't believe in anthropogenic climate change. Even as little attention as this thread is likely to get, probably someone's going to read this comment and not believe at least one of those things. The irony of not believing one of those things while reading the comment on a device built by science, over a vast technological network of other devices built by science, likely won't occur to them.

Now also think about how much of modern stuff we take for granted rests on technological principles that are totally unknown to the average person. I have no idea how a toilet works. It would probably take me years to build a working one from scratch. I read about the principle of the plumbing in a toilet, once, but I can't recall it right this minute. Toilets are among the inventions that have had the greatest positive impact on human societies, and I could do no better right this minute than dig a hole somewhere and put some dirt on top of it.

Given a strand of copper and some magnets, I could make a crude motor or generator. But I have no idea how to extrude fine copper wire, how to identify copper ore, mine it, or refine it. I know enough to make a crappy magnet out of some iron, but it would take me a hundred years to manufacture a motor and a lead-acid battery, and without modern medicine, I could hope for maybe 20 years.

I think there are plausible scenarios where something like a sufficiently destructive solar flare could do enough damage to reset the last thousand years of technological development, and in those scenarios, people would within just a generation or two stop believing that things like an internet ever existed.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday June 28, 2020 @05:43AM (#23667700)
It literally took a millennium for Europe to rediscover the lost knowledge of the Romans and Greeks and to reorganise itself to a comparable level of political and economic sophistication. And the ancient world wasn't operating at anything like the level we have today.

Technical knowledge is incredibly fragile. It requires a global network of raw materials, energy sources, processing systems of various kinds, and logistics - all maintained by overlapping knowledge concentrated in a relatively small number of individuals and institutions, none of whom have a complete picture.

So even if the knowledge survived in book form, it would still be useless at a local level if the supply chains that feed it were broken.

The absolute best you could hope for is some kind of partial memory in a few local pockets, and maybe the odd genius would turn up every century or two to make another attempt at deciphering the ancient wisdom.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by Broken_Hippo on Sunday June 28, 2020 @08:06AM (#23668214)
Do you not think that society, after living in the digital age with internet and communication, wouldn't immediately work to fix these things?

I don't know about the 'rediscover lost knowledge of the Romans and Greeks" bit. We aren't clamoring to get the 'sophistication' of the Victorian time period, in part because so many of the ideas aren't valued, and much of the same attitude probably was the same for the 'lost' information. We view the ancients in a romantic way, but... they also didn't have chimneys. Folks through history often didn't have the literacy rates we do.

And no one in history had a really good overview either, honestly. A complete supply overview isn't necessary at a local level: We all know these exist. It won't take long before we communicate easily again and we'll have electricity before long. Once you have these things, lots of other things will fall into place.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by akiselev on Sunday June 28, 2020 @06:33AM (#23667892)
The global literacy rate two hundred years ago, at the dawn of the industrial revolution, is estimated to be under 20% [1]. Today it's over 80% because the contributions of a small number of inventors raised the tide for everyone, increasing access to education. Half the world couldn't even read until the mid-1960s.

Knowledge has always been unevenly distributed and most people who succeed do so because they were born into a supportive environment. It's unreasonable to expect that from seven billion people when a significant fraction of them grew up with illiterate elders.

[1] https://read.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/how-was-life_978926...

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by Broken_Hippo on Sunday June 28, 2020 @08:00AM (#23668199)
It isn't that we all know how to build this stuff - but more that we know the stuff exists. We all have these ideas. It is online, it is written in books. The chances of all of our information being lost is slim. We have a pretty good literacy rate now as well. You don't need to know everything: Other folks know a lot about mining, making wire, and so on. Some folks know a great deal about making medicine, fixing bones, and so on.

This is why I say it won't be lost: We have the information, both digital and in hard copy form. We know it all exists: We'd rebuild. It isn't going to need YOU, specifically, to remember it all, but simply to know this stuff exists and understand that folks are peppered through the earth that know about the technologies you don't - and know what these things are used for. We wouldn't lose toilets - a well documented technology - we'd rebuild them. A solar flare wiping out some of the communication routes wouldn't be enough. That would simply be a setback - a major one, but not enough to destroy things.

This is all despite folks not believing in a round earth or vaccines and all of that stuff.