News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by crispyporkbites on Sunday June 28, 2020 @02:52AM (#23667153)
That’s a silly argument, we could build pyramids 100 times bigger than the Egyptian ones if we wanted to today, and we can build engines that are far more efficient and powerful than the Apollo ones.

Just because the specific methodology became obsolete doesn’t mean we lost anything along the way

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by jedberg on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:38AM (#23667291)
> and we can build engines that are far more efficient and powerful than the Apollo ones

The F-1 (the engine in the Saturn V, used in the Apollo missions) remains the most powerful rocket engine ever built. [0]

So no, we can't build them bigger, or even as well as, we used to.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_orbital_rocket_e...

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by throwaway_pdp09 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:32AM (#23667480)
"because that was the biggest, we therefore we can't make them bigger" doesn't follow.
Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by jedberg on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:35AM (#23667491)
See my sibling comment. We’ve been trying to make a bigger engine for decades, and have yet to succeed.
Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by throwaway_pdp09 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:49AM (#23667540)
Your sibling comment (I presume https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23667336) says nothing of the sort.

It doesn't say nasa has been trying to make a bigger one for decades.

> They still haven't figured it out.

...is not what the article said. They lost the plans, they're recreating them.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by jedberg on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:53AM (#23667556)
> They lost the plans, they're recreating them.

Which is exactly the point I made at first. That we've lost the knowledge to make the engine.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by throwaway_pdp09 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @05:04AM (#23667595)
They lost the plans. For this particular engine type. That's not the same as losing fundamental knowledge of how the engines work, or the ability to recreate one larger.

And you have not acknowledged you misrepresented what the article said.

What is it with you types that have to feel we're failing, going backwards? I had an argument once with a guy that insisted there were compiler optimisation that aren't used any more because they are now lost - there are literally books on those opts, web articles accessible in a few clicks, probably youtube vids (in fact, see godbolt's stuff) - why are you types so set on failure and ignorance? What exactly are you thinking when you post this inaccurate and negative stuff?

Aren't there enough problems in the world without making up nonexistent ones?

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by hunta2097 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @07:03AM (#23667996)
I find a more extreme version of this thinking in anti-science subjects like flat earth and homeopathy.

Those guys are always referencing ancient texts.

Many parts of humanity stagnated for millennia - see cave systems in France and Eastern Europe which were occupied for thousands of years without any progress.

I find it incredible that you could take a baby from that era, send them to school and they could be indiscernible from the rest of us.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by guerrilla on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:42AM (#23667309)
> That’s a silly argument, we could build pyramids 100 times bigger than the Egyptian ones if we wanted to today, and we can build engines that are far more efficient and powerful than the Apollo ones.

You seemed to have missed a couple of points there. Of course we can build the pyramids, but can we do it with the same level of technology that we think they had? Of course we can build better engines than the Apollo ones but can we recreate exactly those? These were the questions post to highlight that we have lost knowledge before.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by crispyporkbites on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:46AM (#23667323)
Can you recreate the exact breakfast I just made? Can you crack an egg the same way twice? Entropy always increases.

It's knowledge that we don't necessarily need, if we really needed to made pyramids in the same way, we'd figure it out.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by guerrilla on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:55AM (#23667355)
> Can you recreate the exact breakfast I just made? Can you crack an egg the same way twice? Entropy always increases.

This is a false equivalency because you're confounding a uncontrollable natural process with things that could easily come with an instruction manual and be as replicate as a cake or science experiment. Identity is not the goal but sufficient similarity to meet specific requirements.

> It's knowledge that we don't necessarily need, if we really needed to made pyramids in the same way, we'd figure it out.

This moves the goal post and changes the subject because the original point was whether or not we lose knowledge, not whether or not that is acceptable.

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by jedberg on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:50AM (#23667336)
> if we really needed to made pyramids in the same way, we'd figure it out.

We've been trying to figure it out for a century and still haven't. Why do you think we could now?

Same with the engines. We've been trying to make an F-1 for over a decade. In 2013 they even tore one down to figure out how it was made [0]. They still haven't figured it out.

[0] https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/146829-nasa-resurrects-i...

Re:Stonehenge: Neolithic monument found near sacred site by 082349872349872 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @07:31AM (#23668105)
"Wally" Wallington, retired construction worker, proposes a very Archimedean, but not very labour intensive, henge technique: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vHHhmJBY0k