As a society we’ve decided that some standards are important enough to be codified into law. It doesn’t matter to us if you’re violating it by engraving cuneiform into clay tablets or using electrons in a distributed platform. Everyone must follow the same laws, no special pass for you because you get to make money from the violation.
We should, of course, try to improve the Internet; there's plenty wrong with it. We certainly don't want to stay where we are now. But we are a better world because we are more connected. Getting rid of the Internet because "other systems don't get a pass" would be cutting off our own nose to spite our face. As a society, we have a vested interest in a democratizing platform that allows ordinary people to publish information and coordinate on an unprecedented scale.
So if a set of standards don't allow the globalized democratizing communication platform to exist, then the standards are wrong.
If a scientist can't guarantee that their scientific experiments comply with the safety standards we demand of them they can't do them.
Not to mention of course that internet platforms do exist that handle individual content reliably, they're just smaller and don't collect the economic rents that Facebook does.
I'm not talking about whether they can or not. The case that makes them unable to exist is when one single item slips past their moderation net. If they're liable, that's the end of them.
Sure I want them held to a higher standard as well, but they will not be able to exist at all if they were liable for user content. None of them. The ones that are moderating successfully and the ones that aren't. User content sites will have too much liability to be able to run. That's the end of social media - for everyone.
If lots of people feel like you can't they just have their own network without blackjack or hookers.
Call it the ckeanernet and allow selective content like Wikipedia from the broader internet.
Internet platforms cannot exist if they're liable for individual things that users put on their platforms.