Someone still has to work to produce the food that UBI wastrels consume. Please, explain to me why we should feed everyone for free? What gives them the right to commandeer someone else's labour while they languish?
All of these schemes to shift taxes here and burdens there ultimately just have the effect of making it so that the people who do work and do produce value are shouldering the burden for everyone else. You can print money, but you cannot print calories.
Maybe you should ask instead, if there are a lot of people living only on UBI, how will we generate enough demand to keep the whole economy going? If it's a $1000 a month, someone living on that isn't going to be eating out or going on vacation. As we're learning this year, people settling for the essentials (housing and groceries) is not enough. Agriculture and related industry only requires 11% of the workforce in the US.
But anyone with ambition is going to want more in life than just the basics, and so they will keep working, earn more money, and spend more. That doesn't change.
Also, I think you may have missed this: any UBI can be entirely undone by taxing people exactly the same amount. That would be silly, but it shows that a UBI scheme could be an ambitious redistribution, or just a formality, depending on how taxes are set.
Thank you for the thought experiment.
So if we are to have such institutions as private property and similar rights to exclusivity, those excluded should be justly compensated for being excluded.
Edit: To clarify. Take John Locke, he argues that when you mix your labor with nature you should have right to the result of that labor, but that you can only take from nature what is not needed by anyone else.
One could also extend from that argument that one should not have the right to destroy that which is needed either (think pollution). So be it land value taxes or carbon taxes, you can argue that some compensations is just.
Right now, tens of millions of people in the US alone are unemployed through no fault of their own. To characterise them as "languishing" is ridiculous (and most unemployment rates only take into account people who are actively looking for work, as a measure to make a government's numbers look better). It is simply a fact that capitalism as a system cannot function with 0% unemployment because there would be no job market. Thus, there will always be people who are willing to work but don't have a job.
To me, it is fundamentally unethical to have an underclass of people who cannot afford food or shelter while their "fellow citizens" have an excess of resources. We are not an island, we live in a society and rising unemployment and homelessness hurts us all. But even if it had no impact on you or me, we should still help people who need it.
Not to mention that the actual producers of foods and products are still being paid with money, so I don't get why you think any aspect of this is related to the "right to commandeer someone else's labour" (in most countries the government actually does have that power, but that's a different topic).
> All of these schemes to shift taxes here and burdens there ultimately just have the effect of making it so that the people who do work and do produce value are shouldering the burden for everyone else. You can print money, but you cannot print calories.
Any economic system has at least some people who generally do not produce things -- babies and the elderly. In capitalism, you also have the unemployed. One of the goals of economic systems is to determine how value created by those who work is distributed to those who don't. Placing a value judgement on the need for this redistribution makes no sense. It's like saying a boulder is lazy because it only chooses to go downhill.
There is a big difference between people who are incapable of producing things (perhaps because of circumstances beyond their control) and people who choose to not produce things. This is one weakness of the UBI concept that I haven't seen addressed in a forthright way.
However, there are two points to be made:
* Most UBI progrms are designed to fulfill the base requirements to live in society (food and shelter), so if you want to have a better quality of life than the bare minimum you'll need to get a job as you do today. Most people want to improve their life in some way, but being in poverty robs you of opportunities to do so. So the same incentives to work would exist under UBI, it's just that the bottom of the income ladder isn't marked "$0".
* Not fearing unemployment may enable more people in lower-end jobs to leave their jobs to become better-educated and perhaps find better work in the future (perhaps even starting their own businesses). Again, being poor robs you of the freedom to pursue activities which require an up-front time (and thus money) commitment like higher education or other forms of skill development.
These apply to people who would "choose" to not work, there are other arguments for those who cannot work (but I guess we're in agreement on why that would be a good idea).
I want to point out that I'm not really a proponent of UBI. There are many possible ways to solve existing problems of wealth inequality, and UBI is possibly the most "obvious" one, but I personally think job guarantee programs are a better solution. They solve the same issues of unemployment and wealth, but they also (if implemented correctly) can act as trade schools and as national infrastructure programs (they are also a better application of MMT, because you are actually purchasing resources -- physical labour and materials). But you'd still need a strong safety net for people who cannot work.
From my reading, economists consider a 100% employment rate bad as it means there's no elasticity in the labour supply. If there's no elasticity in the labour supply, wages go up and the rich can't effectively extract surplus value. We will always have the unemployed, as it's a feature of the economic system we participate in.
If you want to fix the "problem" you need to abandon capitalism. I'm not sure anyone here wants to do that, myself included.
If we are just talking about giving cash as charitable donations, smaller-scale experiments about giving people cash tell us what we need to know about the effects. But at large scale, yes, we will have to also consider the effect of whatever taxes are used to counter the increase in the money supply. This isn't an immediate concern considering very low inflation, zero interest rates, and a depressed economy, but might eventually become an issue, someday.
The thing is, you could combine UBI with any tax, so that means there are a huge number of possible policies. My favorites are a carbon tax along with making income tax more progressive, but there are others.
If much of the benefit of UBI is earlier in life and the taxes are paid somewhat later (at higher income), then this has similar effects to a loan. If the benefits happen after peak income (in retirement) then it's more like forced savings.
It's also similar to an insurance scheme. On net, some people may never benefit due to always having a good income and paying more in taxes than they get back, but it still reduces your risk if you somehow lose your income.