- Is calling the investment "crazy" really offensive to the entrepreneurs? It is more a compliment to them than anything else. The investment may be crazy, but the entrepreneurs managed to get people to shell out $41M. That takes serious talent.
- Getting $41M for color is insulting to a lot of other entrepreneurs that have dedicated their lives to products like color and received nothing. Give half of that $41M in $250,000 chunks to 80 other startups and Color would still have $20M to play with.
If you know how these large investments work, $41M in Color may seem very sane, but to a large percentage of the population, it does appear crazy, particularly in light of the dot com bubble.
Perhaps you could point us to a good article showing why this is a sound investment?
For the same amount as this investment you could probably set up seed funds in 10 cities and cover all of the overheads involved. I know which option I would pick.
Neither Merril Lynch nor Lehman Brother knew what they were doing.
"Investors are less interested in where you are today, compared to where you are going"
Yes the future is important, but there's the risk-reward trade-off. If a company looks badly risky today, a rational investor will steer away from it.
"If nothing else, posts like this are terribly offensive to the entrepreneurs that dedicate their lives to products like Color."
And for your first point, a well functioning entrepreneurs ecosystem require both dedicated entrepreneurs AND rational investors. This is not to demean the entrepreneur.
"Rebecca Black signed onto the same record label as Miley Cyrus, I think the label knows what they are doing" ... "We all though Lehman Bros knew what they were doing, dude"
Anyway, I like people that stray from the field and do contrarian things that other people think are crazy, if nothing else in 10 years it'll be exceedingly satisfying for these kinds of investors to point at all the haters (and if they fail, well, everyone was right blah blah serves them right for taking risks)
Also, being a contrarian investor means you sell in a bubble (when everyone is buying) and buy in a crash (when everyone is selling).
So its a little like sympathetic magic - if we get guys who were close to that other success, maybe some of the halo is still stuck to them and voila! investment rationalization.
Some of us have seen dozens of sure-fire new companies, staffed with experienced professionals, fall on their faces. Younger, perhaps naieve investors still have some lessons to learn.
Admittedly, the article pointed to 6 indicators of a bubble which are probably not quite right; then defended only 1 of them, and waved their hands about the others. That is what I found a little offensive, but to my logical sensibility and not as an entrepreneur. Entrepreneurs have to weather a lot more than link-bait, and need to grow a much thicker skin.
I'd prefer to see evidence of success before assuming it will happen.
They've given a long runway to Color, and if the airplane takes off those investors reap far more rewards then they would have if Color is wildly successful and other investors were able to participate in subsequent rounds of investment.
I cannot emphasize enough that this is a strong team (investors and owners). There are almost certainly specific targets and objectives this team needs to meet before they collectively decide to spend the entire 41 million.
Which means this thing could crash and burn after spending 3 million, and they unwind from there.
A long runway? Sorry, but I had to chuckle on that.
That would be one hell of a runway. More akin to a wormhole.
Did anyone consider that maybe Sequoia, who have invested in companies that make up over 10% of the NASDAQ know what they are doing?
Companies like Color, AdKeeper and Flipboard have "crazy" valuations based on the founders having ridiculous resumes. They have all created billions of dollars of value for their investors, hell, why wouldn't you invest in that potential again?
Rationalising this metaphorical bubble to domain prices is absurd, since domains have always been traded for eyebrow raising prices. You think that the domain color.com or path.com will be worth $10 in 5 years time? Seriously?
Color almost certainly didn't require $41M to get to the product you see today, did people ever consider the company is - gasp - launching early and has the capital to iterate and scale for the next few years? I can think of lots of startups that raised $10M - $20M at company formation and has then spent the next few years (or more) iterating.
Investors are less interested in where you are today, compared to where you are going