Unless you were a truly stingy person in life, your affluence will have already have had huge positive impacts on those near and dear to you. Once you're dead, why should they be any more important than any other person?
Most governments enforce a person’s will after they die. People generally elect to distribute their property to particular people, specifically to avoid it ending up in the hands of “we, as a society”.
It really just sounds like you think we are all children under one global nation.
I personally will never agree to that, and want my offspring to do better than the rest so we will be at odds at some point.
>disdain of wealthy people
>advocate theft.
>none of your business
>vilifying people for wanting to pass down their hard-earned money
In the context of the comment you're replying to, none of this is reasonable, and some of it isn't even relevant. You should consider that you're forming an emotional, hostile argument.
> We, as a society, are free to decide with what's left of you and your belongings
No adjective adequately describes this belief other than "absurd".
This adds nothing to the discussion.
> Your belongings and wealth belong to your estate and as the owner of it you decide how it should be distributed.
Well, that's literally the question at hand. You don't get to just say that it is so. A dead person's wealth belonged to them, but they are dead. They can't vote, they can't apply for loans, and, the parent is arguing, they can't arbitrarily pass their money to whoever they choose. They could have, while alive, but now they are dead.
> Because it's none of your business. Why on earth are you vilifying people for wanting to pass down their hard-earned money to their children?
This is just some weird non-sequitur. No one's doing any vilifying, and Parent is arguing that it is societies business (and incidentally, given that an estate tax exists, society currently agrees with the parent poster)
Why favor your family, friends, or countrymen over any other person during your lifetime either? Everyone behaves this way. For example, why does government sponsored health care in western countries only cover their own citizens? Do the lives of people in less affluent countries not matter? Do they have less intrinsic value?
Adam Smith: "There is no point more difficult to account for than the right we conceive men to have to dispose of their goods after death."
This is taxation for policy reasons, not income.
Economic mobility should be solely predicated on the expression of competence/ability in the pursuit of providing value to others in your society. It's not even that hard[1]. Get an education and a job, avoid the big economic sinks.
> This means that 40 percent of why some Americans are extraordinarily well off has nothing to do with smarts, hard work, frugality, lucky gambles or entrepreneurial ingenuity. It is simply because they were born to rich parents.
We should not fear the money landing in undeserving hands, it will rapidly be drained away if that is the case. Many(most?) very wealthy families employ wealth managers that ensure that money is profitably engaged with the society anyways, so in reality the money is not really in the heir's hands anyways, but is tied up in companies that are serving the country and employing others.
[1]: https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/three-simple-rules-poor-t...
The inheritance tax is not a Pigovian tax, but its purpose can also be primarily non-budgetary.
Post-tax dollars aren't magical things that mean you never pay taxes again. They're just an accounting tool that makes dealing with some tax-exempt activities easier.
Given that, is there anyone who could possibly need their money less than the dead?
There is plenty more you can read on the topic. The general idea is that it helps create a meritocratic society.
"Some will argue that this example ignores any income and payroll tax the wealthy parents paid when they originally earned the $50 million. But if the couple paid their personal chef’s wages out of after-tax income, we wouldn’t think their personal chef should get credit for the taxes they paid. Similarly, we should ignore any income or payroll tax the couple paid when considering how much their son should contribute to the costs of government."
Why don't I have a downvote button for this?
I could go on. Art collection, old cars, even immaterial rights or stocks that are massively undervalued right now for one reason or another (for instance because the founder just died suddenly).
Inheritance taxation is inherently unjust because it cannot distinguish between goods that are easily traded for and the ones that cannot easily be sold.