News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by gvjddbnvdrbv on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:20AM (#23625047)
How does this reconcile with the actual data we have on total infection rate in e.g. Spain where a representative poll was done?
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by jjjensen90 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:30AM (#23625129)
Because it's possible that there are many, many infected who don't seroconvert or ever manifest symptoms, and therefore would not have been tested with a PCR test, and would have a negative antibody test. We can see this in effect in studies of household attack rates and seroconversion. See this recent preprint and interesting thread (/r/covid19 is a strict science sub, not to be confused with /r/coronavirus) https://www.reddit.com/r/COVID19/comments/hdxwf5/intrafamili...
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by arrrg on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:53AM (#23625286)
But does this get us a lot?

In Brooklyn and Queens between 0.2 and 0.25 percent of the total population (!) died.

So this sort of puts a floor on the IFR and 0.2 is not that far off from the IFR determined through serological testing – maybe a half or a third of that.

So yeah, maybe there is an effect – but can it really be a drastic effect? I don’t think there are orders of magnitude of difference in there, maybe a difference of a few percent (e.g. an IFR of 0.45 instead of 0.5 percent)?

My working hypothesis has been an IFR of around 0.5% for a pretty long time, which seems pretty realistic to me.

Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by grey-area on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @05:34AM (#23625938)
But looking at NYC now, after peaking in April, infections and deaths are way down and stabilised, in spite of rising infections in surrounding areas and very few travel restrictions. So something is going on that we don't understand, and it could have a significant impact.

If we have a higher immune population than we think, NYC might have passed the worst, if not millions will die in a second wave (though there are no signs of that yet). So this does matter.

Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by arrrg on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @08:43AM (#23627202)
New York obviously “benefits” from an intensive first wave. Every additional infection makes spread harder for the virus.

As many European countries show (including Germany, where the infected population is very low, much lower than the European average, much much lower than Italy or Spain) it’s very possible to keep the epidemic at a low, simmering level without extremely drastic lockdowns.

Given a probably pretty low K value it’s also often sufficient to not be super-efficient about prevention. Some efficiency goes a long way.

Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by grey-area on Thursday June 25, 2020 @01:50AM (#23637309)
it’s very possible to keep the epidemic at a low, simmering level without extremely drastic lockdowns.

It's very hard to know the cause of the dramatic decline in nations that were hit hard, so I don't think we can attribute it as simply as that. It could be immunity we're unable to test (T-cell), weather meaning more are outdoors, awareness and measures like distancing and masks, or a mix of many things. We just don't know at this stage.

I'd note that Germany is still seeing outbreaks, and they were hit less hard in the initial wave in Europe. Italy in contrast, which has relaxed restrictions, is seeing very low levels of deaths and cases.

Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by jakeogh on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:34AM (#23625167)
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by jmull on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @06:44AM (#23626392)
Well, this study estimates covid 19 by looking at survey data on influenza-like-illnesses. That means they were counting people who had flu-like symptoms.

Any potential people with covid19 but no symptoms would be above and beyond what’s being raised here.

Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by gvjddbnvdrbv on Thursday June 25, 2020 @01:16PM (#23642975)
Most of the people with flu like symtoms won't have had covid though.
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by christkv on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:24AM (#23625089)
We now know a significant amount of people have no symptoms or very light symptoms and no antibody response. An anecdote. My friend and his wife got tested when giving birth. She was positive for antibodies he was not. It is quite possible that for ever person who had antibodies there is some unknown x of people who got it and never developed antibodies.
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by cube2222 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:33AM (#23625155)
IANAD, but you can have similar antibodies (which test positive) from previous infections with similar coronaviruses, not this one specifically.

So somebody who had no exposure to COVID-19 could test positive.

Afaik that's the main drawback of the antibody test.

Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by koheripbal on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:59AM (#23627934)
The antibody test specifically tests for a protein that only exists on covid-19.

A positive test result is much more reliable than a negative result.

Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by the-rc on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @07:50AM (#23626792)
Another anecdote from NY. I had mild symptoms in mid March that didn't exactly match what was being described in the press. Spending hours at the hospital trying to get tested seemed riskier, so I was never diagnosed. In late April I got tested at Mount Sinai hospital for antibodies as part of their study and I was positive, with a high titer. A friend of mine was, too, with a low titer. In a second test two weeks ago I still had the same titer, while she was negative. As an additional anecdote, without mention of other variables, the nurse taking the second sample told me that males had a higher titer on average. I think we also have higher mortality rates, though.
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by jonathanstrange on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @07:22AM (#23626616)
How would we know that if they don't even have an antibody response? You're resorting to anecdotal evidence but there is no way to confirm this hypothesis empirically on a large scale.

I guess it depends on what you mean by "significant amount", though.

Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by baddox on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:39AM (#23625193)
What is the actual effect on the world if that’s true? I’m assuming that people who were infected but never developed symptoms or antibodies were still able to infect other people who might develop symptoms and antibodies.
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by peteretep on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @04:02AM (#23625364)
How would you end up without antibodies? The virus just failed to replicate in your system and died out of its own accord? Or are we suggesting the people with no symptoms are still asymptomic carriers?
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by carey on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @06:07AM (#23626162)
You will only get detectable antibodies if the virus activated the adaptive immune system. This could be the case if the infection was successfully and quickly controlled by the innate immune system.
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by koheripbal on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @10:00AM (#23627946)
It doesnt mean thee are no antibodies It means the antibody test doesnt test the right protein.
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by cm2187 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:29AM (#23625122)
I have seen Dr Raoult in France suggesting there was likely significant cross immunity from other coronaviruses. If it is the case, would the person develop covid19-specific antibodies after getting it?
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by legulere on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @06:30AM (#23626307)
People without symptoms are also much less likely to spread. So likely your friend really didn’t get infected.
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by osullip on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:22AM (#23625066)
Or Australia where about 10% of the population has been tested. https://www.health.gov.au/news/health-alerts/novel-coronavir...
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by planetmechanic on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:28AM (#23625113)
It works well: from the article, "In New York, for example, the researchers’ model suggested that at least 9% of the state’s entire population was infected by the end of March. After the state conducted antibody testing on 3,000 residents, they found a 13.9% infection rate, or 2.7 million New Yorkers."
Re:Initial Covid-19 infection rate may be 80 times greater t... by Hermel on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:33AM (#23625158)
The usual tests (including the anti-body tests) only detect the more severe cases.