I'm sure most people understand that it's a transactional relationship, I.e. you get to live in the country while you work and that's it, but if you live in a city for several years and settle in, form friendships, hobbies, and maybe relationships, it's very difficult to put all of that at risk for any reason.
I agree the terms are not good, but isn’t it 60 days?
https://cilawgroup.com/news/2017/02/24/uscis-creates-60-day-...
I suddenly find myself wondering if the path to reform for H1B could be short duration combine with some kind of fast-track naturalization. Does it even make sense for the transactional H1B to be so long term?
If the H1B led to rapid naturalization, it would naturally curtail use of H1B over time, as the US population of individuals suited for the job would be growing ipso facto.
Do we really want to bring skilled workers to the US, give them work experience and training that raises their skill level even higher, and then kick them out of the country?
That seems like an unimaginably stupid idea. We should be seeking to retain highly skilled immigrants, not flushing them out of the country.
I agree, but I think you mean permanent residency. Naturalization is the step after that.
The H1B should really be a kind of temporary defined-term green card that can be used with any employer (or none), with a quick path to a green card for anyone who can prove consistent employability.
I think an initial sponsorship is fine, but tying the visa to the sponsorship is really only beneficial to the employer. If they have a true need to sponsor an immigrant, they shouldn't have any problem keeping their offer attractive enough that retention shouldn't be a problem.
I wonder sometimes if the hiring manager was incompetent or was just using me as justification that no Americans could do the job
They're underpaid for their positions, tremendously overworked, and when they don't win the H1B lottery for their renewal, they're simply swapped out with people who did. Tying one's ability to legally reside in a country to their employment is cruel at best, and damaging to the broader economy at worst. This doesn't benefit ANY workers - if these workers had some basic rights, or an actual decent pathway to legal residency (not tied to their employer), they'd be better able to demand market wages, and wouldn't depress the wages of their American peers.
The only people benefiting from this nonsensical immigration scheme are the shareholders of the companies who exploit it.
I have noticed that people of Indian heritage are encouraged to get a master's degree. Most of the Indians I've met have one.
Anyone else care to share their understanding on the Indian H1B US Master's degree route to coming to the US, am I missing something here?
But that is not the only reason they go for a master's degree. Many do not need it for immigration purposes yet they obtain one regardless.
Using statistics from the general population is not relevant here.
I see this throughout industry. Even if the qualified candidates are 75% Indian, and a team of 10 is 100% Indian, what’s the probability that’s a coincidence?
Why is this flagged? because I supposedly misinterpreted a "fake job interview"?
I have a friends who work for Qualcomm, and it's widely acknowledged both inside and outside the company that they rely on a steady stream of underpaid H1B engineers.
The only ones who are interested in a visa like this would be foreign-born skilled workers looking to immigrate, and they are going to lose the fight over who gets the visas with people who have no specific skills but family in country since that family can vote.
There is no constituency for such a visa, so it is never going to happen.
Why should they hire someone who can walk to a competitor at the drop of a hat when they can hire someone that will probably be deported if they step out of line or demand market-rate compensation?
(Also, many of my friends have/had H-1B’s...)
Because free markets are better ? or so has been the message by US towards other countries
I’m not sure it’s that simple: lots of workers know they’re competing at their current employer with H1-B’s who are underpaid and mistreated. If they’re paid more that dynamic softens a lot and there’s still a cap on the total number.
Mine was slower but still faster than a lot of immigrant experiences to the US, and I did it from outside Canada and without an employer involved at all.
The skilled worker visas don't need family in country, though it can be a minor help in the points systems they use. My CS degree and work experience mattered far more.
As to why it's hard in the US, I'd attribute that more to attitudes among the population and media than to the inherent nature of having to make policy that appeals to voters: Canada is (at least) as much of a democracy as the US, and even the Conservative Party of Canada isn't proposing to eliminate fast skilled worker processing - they're in fact the party that introduced the quick program I alluded to above. Certainly the other two major national parties are even more friendly to immigration. There are xenophobes in Canada, but firmly in the minority when examined at the national level.
Canada also has fast sponsorship programs for spouses and kids.
63% of Green Cards are awarded based on family connection [0] not employment based sponsorship vs 26% in Canada [1].
The US is an outlier in this regard. Not many countries allow you to sponsor a sibling for Permanent Residency.
[0] https://www.boundless.com/blog/dhs-data-2018/
[1] https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/co...
You're right about the relative percentages between the countries, but that's simply because the US makes even skilled economic immigration far more difficult than Canada. All common kinds of immigration are easier in Canada, though neither country makes it truly easy as was true more than a century ago.
You're right that there are only very narrow cases where Canada allows sponsoring siblings, unlike the US. But those kinds of differences go both ways: for example, Canada allows common-law partner sponsorship after 1 year of cohabitation without requiring marriage, whereas the US doesn't. (I am not referring to what the US calls "common-law marriage" but to a type of relationship that continues not to be treated the same as marriage under Canadian law, except where specifically indicated.)
I usually lean hard left, and I know I'd personally support a proposal that cut back on granting 1 unskilled visa per year, in exchange for fast-tracking 3 skilled visa-holders to getting their green card, and I have conservative-leaning friends who would support such a deal as well.
What's the right ratio, though? They've been trying to strike a major immigration reform deal since the 90s, but neither side has been willing to make concessions, so we've just been just stuck with a broken system and its ill effects.
The only point is to make life more difficult for people that need a J1, H1-B, or anything else to continue their career plans now.
It's also to make it seem like these positions are taking jobs away from current US residents, and stoke anti-immigrant sentiment.
There are undoubtedly flaws with the H1-B process, but this move makes it less likely for reform to happen, not more.
It’s not quite as easy as it seems, believe me software companies have been trying to pull this off for decades. I’ve been around situations where a US team was offshored and returned again because the results were so dreadful.
What people forget is that the folks who actually make it here are the absolute cream of the crop. There are not a billion Indians just like the super talented one you’ve worked with at your office. And that’s not even getting into timezone and communication problems.
>What people forget is that the folks who actually make it here are the absolute cream of the crop.
You know a good way to reverse this trend, though? Force all those people to take all the skills they've learned back to their home countries.
I work at a Big-N and there are many teams that are majority non-citiens. If they're forced to leave the US, do you think the company will try to replace them with Americans, or just move the team?
Americans couldn't comprehend the perfect English spoken in these countries?
(Sorry - couldn't resist!)
Edit: In case people don't get it, it used to be a common joke that Americans had poorer English than well educated foreigners. Definitely for written, but even occasionally spoken English. I've worked with at least 3 people who were either from Singapore or from Malaysia but educated in Singapore. All had great English, and with 2 of them you'd never know you weren't speaking to a native English speaker - you'd think you were speaking to a British person.
I wonder why more companies don’t outsource to Canada and South America (or the Midwest, for that matter.)
Disagree with this, agree with the rest.
I've hired (and fired) folks for teams and this is not true at all. The wages in SV are very competitive. At one point we were desperate to get ANYONE who could pass the interview, including dropping the bar for the interview. H1B employees are technically more expensive for us, because the overhead for H1B fees/lawyers etc.
edit: I forgot to mention that H1Bs routinely negotiate their pay to be higher, since they get multiple offers as well.
In my case the context was my firm had done a true search for filling the position, where the H1B holder was found as the best available applicant. But then we had to do another fake job search for that already-filled position for the purposes of getting our employee a green card.
The hallmarks of a fake job posting, from that experience: (1) there will be only basic advertising of the role, with a strict "no recruiters" rule (2) there will be only one round of phone interview, focusing on a checklist of specific knowledge and experience points and acceptable salary levels
I'm sure I could wait a year and finally find an American born candidate who will pass the interview, but that would mean my projects and timelines are hosed.
We've tried to go the intern route and hire American undergrads as interns and then convert them to full time by offering them, the conversion rate isn't as good as you think, and they have a LOT of options in the valley.
Let me assure you, the biggest problem faced by any company, startup or otherwise is talent, it's extremely hard to find good talent, We could tweak our tech-stacks to be most open to a wide range of people and bring the bar down. But the bottleneck is still talent.
This affects everyone who works with H1B employees. As others have noted it puts them in a very unfair side of the negotiations on employment (as in you don't get a voice).
If your residency is hinged on your job, then it's you vs everyone else there. This drives unnatural competition between teams and coworkers under the same manager. It's bad for work relations. It leads people to be bad actors and make immoral judgements.
H1B needs serious reform to give people an actual voice at the table.
If it needs to be temporary response to a shortage, it should be tied to a job category in which the shortage is certified to exist, not an employer. There should be no special restriction within the category within which the shortage is certified to exist, so long as it exists, since employer restrictions within that category will obviously exacerbate a real shortage, though they benefit the particular employer.
But H-1B doesn't exist to deal with real shortages, it exists to leverage the pretext of contrived shortages to mitigate wage pressure in highly skilled industries via captive labor.
They also fake looking for Americans- in practice, many of the jobs are earmarked for a specific person, and you are wasting your time applying for it.
Losing your job as an h1b requires you to leave almost immediately, which isn't great for anyone.
Hopefully they'll reform the process to focus on bringing talent into the country without chaining it to a specific company