News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by tptacek on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @04:53PM (#2361411)
It is free to be used commercially, if you write it, pay for it, or keep its derived works open source. The only thing GPLv3 keeps you from doing is closed-source commercialization against the wishes of the author.

This seems eminently reasonable to me. If you want to allow people to do closed-source commercial projects with your code, BSD license it.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by chc on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:08PM (#2361472)
It feels kind of like a semantic game to call free software "commercial." Do you really believe that, in general, consumer software that you essentially have to surrender the copyright to is commercially viable? Are many people actually going to pay for something that's available for free with literally no added benefit?

(I am, of course, ignoring support here, because support is really a separate product that could even be provided by a third party.)

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by tptacek on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:28PM (#2361756)
GPL does nothing to prevent you from selling software. Look what Sleepycat did. Just GPL your code, and put an enterprise-grade price tag on a non-GPL commercial license.

The only people affected by the GPL are people who want to sell software they didn't write. It's hard for me to get worked up about that: the overwhelming majority of all commercial software is more restrictive.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by chc on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:28PM (#2361977)
I don't think it's fair to call a program that links against a library for some subset of its functionality "selling software they didn't write." I believe Firefox uses zlib and libpng, but I don't think most people would call Firefox a version of zlib or libpng.

Anyway, I'm not saying that people shouldn't be able to license their software under the GPL. If you don't want me using your code, that's your right. But if they do GPL it, from my POV as a potential user of the code, it might as well be closed-source. Thus I object to the statement "It is free to be used commercially," when it is actually free for any other use but impractical for commercial use. (Even in your Sleepycat example, it was the non-GPL version that they used in their commercial pursuits.)

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by tptacek on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:59PM (#2362085)
Help me understand what you're saying. If I write a library, you are free not to use it. My code, my terms, right? That's how commercial licensing works. How does GPL harm that dynamic? Or, should the party with more source code lines dictate terms to the party with fewer?
Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by chc on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:39PM (#2362215)
I think I must be saying this very clumsily. I'll try to sum it up explicitly.

I'm OK with the existence of GPL software. I like it when people use a more permissive license, but your code is yours to do with what you will. What bothers me is what people say about the GPL, because I think it's misleading.

There is this common idea in the free software community that it is not hostile to commercial software. That's what I don't like. If people came out and said, "Yeah, my GPL source code has very severe restrictions that make it unsuitable for integration in commercial software," I would agree and wish them happy coding. But they don't say that. They use the misleading banner of "free," and even try to deny that it's incompatible with commercial software.

Based on all the evidence I've seen, I believe commercial software pretty much has to be offered under a proprietary license in 99% of cases. The GPL says I can't do that if I use so much as one line of GPL code written by somebody else. That means that using GPL code in my software renders it unsaleable.

So, when you said, "It is free to be used commercially … if you keep its derived works open source," I objected to that. If you can only release your software under the GPL, you're probably not going to make a lot of money selling it — it strains the definition of "commercial." You can't even use the Sleepycat model, where there's a GPL version and a commercial one.

It's your right to put your software under that license. But I think it's important for people to understand that it completely shuts out commercial use, even if the commercial use is largely original. We shouldn't downplay that.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 24, 2011 @03:38AM (#2363227)
The GPL is clearly designed to be hostile to a certain type of software deployment strategy.

But not because that software is being sold, or because it is profitable, or corporate, or big-business, or commercial or any of those things. It is hostile because it is "proprietary" and that (in the FSF's opinion) tilts the power balance too far towards the vendor, allowing all sorts of abuses.

Where I think you are getting confused is that some of those abuses are highly profitable and so those are the most visible successes to you.

But people like to sum this complicated area up as the GPL being "anti-business" or not "business-friendly", which is highly misleading. You'll note that quite a lot of non-software businesses are quite happy to use GPL code since a) they are not in the business of selling proprietary code and b) proprietary code gives too much power to the vendor. There's plenty of room for businesses to supply GPL software to these companies.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by chc on Thursday March 24, 2011 @04:31AM (#2363303)
I think that you are misrepresenting what I've said. Businesses using GPL software are irrelevant to what I was talking about. My comments have been about selling software for a living, and only about that. (Just to clarify, I am also not talking about providing support for software or making customizations to software. Those are separate kinds of businesses from software products.)

On that topic: Whether or not the GPL was designed to be hostile to commercial software, it is hostile to commercial software in the real world. I don't know of a single piece of GPL software that makes decent revenue on its own.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 24, 2011 @05:28AM (#2363389)
I think the core of it is your very narrow definition of "commercial" to mean selling shrinkwrapped, off-the-shelf software to large numbers of anonymous clients. I have no real problem with small, or one man development shops trying to do that just like I have no problem with musicians trying to make a living from their home studio. I just think reality, and making a living, might dictate that they go out and build relationships with customers rather than cling to a business model that only made sense for a shockingly short period of time. I can see why they might dislike the GPL or P2P software and the many changes they bring but if their only argument is "but I'd prefer to make lots of money, and not change the way I work, why do I have to choose?" then I'm not sure I've got the sympathy to spare, particularly if the changes mean more, better, and cheaper stuff for me and everyone else.

It's unfortunate if you happen to be the mythical lone inventor that all the laws that patent trolls thrive on was supposed to benefit. They were the collateral damage caused by something that was supposed to benefit society through you, and as patent laws get reformed you'll be the collateral damage caused by something intended to benefit society by curtailing them.

The other elephant in the room is web apps, which the GPL has no power over. There are plenty of people selling that software for a living while building on GPL code. If you're trying to sell desktop apps then you're now more and more competing with them. Again, the GPL has changed the environment you compete in whether you wanted it to or not, and this time it's worse competition because it's more profitable.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by tptacek on Thursday March 24, 2011 @04:13PM (#2365717)
SourceFire IPO'd on GPL software. There are other examples. I feel like this has more to do with ideology than truth-seeking for you.
Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by chc on Thursday March 24, 2011 @05:41PM (#2366133)
For me, this question is mainly practical. If indie developers could put out GPL software and make good money from it without requiring the support infrastructure of a megacorp, I would think that was the bee's knees and I would promote that business model like crazy. I just don't think it's generally possible. I'm not familiar with SourceFire's story, but a look at their site seems to suggest the "Enterprise tech support company" model. I'll have to look closer.
Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by tptacek on Thursday March 24, 2011 @08:35PM (#2366637)
How could it possibly benefit indie developers to give up more of their rights? The rights held back by the GPL --- for the developer --- are almost exactly those those required by companies to commercialize software. I'm vociferous about the GPL entirely because it enables developers to profit from their labor. The GPL is anathema to megacorps. That's why you dual-license, and charge out the wazoo for the corp-friendly license.

You really, really, really need re-evaluate your take on this. GPL is the most indie-friendly of the licenses. There's a valid gripe against it: it fractures the open source community into "people who can use GPL code" and "people who can't use GPL code". But that has nothing to do with commercialization. Once you BSD license something, it is extraordinarily difficult to commercialize the code itself.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by wiredfool on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @11:41PM (#2362742)
Not really.

Way back when, I wanted to hack sleepycat db support into a closed source third party platform that had an extension API. It would have taken a bit of code, and a dll load.

Not my application, I didn't have source for it, and I was willing to release my extension as GPL. Sleepycat didn't see it my way and wanted something like 10k/year and a maintenance agreement for the right to do the code and release it a GPL.

So, to sum up, the GPL prevented me from writing and releasing GPLd code.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by cookiecaper on Thursday March 24, 2011 @12:17AM (#2362831)
I disagree. Some people want to sell to consumers, not corporations. Corporations will buy non-GPL licenses so they can redistribute on their own terms, but consumers won't because they don't intend to redistribute in the first place. It's hard to sell GPL software to consumers because as soon as someone sees it's going well, they'll rush in to sell cheaper versions of the same product, and soon it will devolve into something that's not really worth the time. I would love to see a GPL-like license that kept the code accessible and modifiable, but restricted distribution to a subset of persons approved by the copyright owner (i.e., licensed). This would actually make it viable to sell OSS to consumers. While the real GPL may be better and freer, I think that such a license would be a net benefit as it could result in much wider availability of code for programs that people run, which would be a win even if the distribution conditions were more stringent.
Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by oihujyfgthyjuik on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:33PM (#2361562)
Depend s- is your app commercially viable if you have to re-implement all the GPL stuff I wrote for you yourself?

If you are using my GPL contributions for free then you can't turn around and stop your customers using those contributions.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by chc on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:53PM (#2361638)
Yes, but I can do that if I'm using your BSD-licensed contributions. That's why we're saying that, from the perspective of a commercial software vendor, BSD ensures more freedom.
Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by tptacek on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:31PM (#2361764)
GPL is moderately less free than BSD/MIT.

GPL is significantly more free than closed-source commercial.

Two groups of people are negatively impacted by the GPL.

First, people who want to ship closed-source versions of code they didn't write in exchange for money, against the will of the package author. Hard to feel sorry for these people.

Second, people with BSD/MIT/Apache licensed open source project who want to make it possible for other people to ship closed-source versions of their code for money. A valid concern, but a pragmatic one, not an ideological one. BSD gives away "too much"; GPL holds back "too much". There's no happy medium.

Let's take the ideological cast off this ("freedom", "commercial", "semantic games"). The issue here is simple and practical.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by oihujyfgthyjuik on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:15PM (#2361929)
It also ensures you can take my work for free, keep it to yourself and not pass on my contribution to other people.

I can also come around and clean out your gutters for free.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by chc on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @07:34PM (#2362006)
I'm not asking you to clean my gutters for free. I'm asking you to stop saying you'll clean my gutters for free, but sticking in the fine print "$5000 fee required for access to free gutter service."

To drop the metaphor: I'm not saying that you can't license your code under GPL. If you don't want me using your software, that's your right. By placing the code under GPL, you are communicating that I am not free to use the software as I please. That is, again, your right — all I ask is that you be honest about the fact that use of the code is very much restricted.

If anybody using your code is effectively barred from commercial endeavors, then for people who make money off their software, it does not grant them any more freedom than closed-source code does. To say a license grants freedom because you're free not to use the code is just weird.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by tptacek on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:19PM (#2362149)
Are you looking for someone to say "never use the BSD license" so you can argue with them? Because nobody's saying that. GPL is an option when you care if people commercialize your work. BSD is an option when you don't.
Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by prodigal_erik on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:57PM (#2361650)
There's only one business model the GPL interferes with, namely selling copies of software nobody paid you to write.
Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by chc on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @09:30PM (#2362387)
That's really oversimplifying. For example, if I write a full Photoshop clone that links to a third-party library to support some obscure graphics format, you'd have to be out of your mind to say the whole program is a derivative of that library — but that's how the GPL sees it. In GPL World, all of our programs are forks of libc.

This problem is so significant that no major Linux distro puts its system libraries under the GPL. It is clear that they believe the GPL would interfere with more than just the freeloading business model.

Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services by thaumaturgy on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @05:44PM (#2361606)
It's like free speech in a sense. You can focus on the freedoms of the user, or you can focus on the freedoms of the developer, and the two aren't 100% congruent.

I agree with you, for what it's worth. I much prefer the BSDL exactly for reasons like this.