Re:Apple replaces Samba for Windows networking services
by tptacek on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @06:31PM
(#2361764)
GPL is moderately less free than BSD/MIT.
GPL is significantly more free than closed-source commercial.
Two groups of people are negatively impacted by the GPL.
First, people who want to ship closed-source versions of code they didn't write in exchange for money, against the will of the package author. Hard to feel sorry for these people.
Second, people with BSD/MIT/Apache licensed open source project who want to make it possible for other people to ship closed-source versions of their code for money. A valid concern, but a pragmatic one, not an ideological one. BSD gives away "too much"; GPL holds back "too much". There's no happy medium.
Let's take the ideological cast off this ("freedom", "commercial", "semantic games"). The issue here is simple and practical.
GPL is significantly more free than closed-source commercial.
Two groups of people are negatively impacted by the GPL.
First, people who want to ship closed-source versions of code they didn't write in exchange for money, against the will of the package author. Hard to feel sorry for these people.
Second, people with BSD/MIT/Apache licensed open source project who want to make it possible for other people to ship closed-source versions of their code for money. A valid concern, but a pragmatic one, not an ideological one. BSD gives away "too much"; GPL holds back "too much". There's no happy medium.
Let's take the ideological cast off this ("freedom", "commercial", "semantic games"). The issue here is simple and practical.