News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by acd on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:49AM (#23613150)
Plastics is an example when market economy fails. Plastics is to cheap to buy and manufacture so it’s found everywhere. Ie plastics is an example of tradegedy of the commons where to purchaser of plastics benefits but everyone else sees a loss of the environment.

Trying to explain we need to develop an economic model better than market economy or else earth will become a big waste dump. Ie we need to prize the waste.

Tragedy of the commons https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_common

Environmental economics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_economics

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by jaekash on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:25AM (#23613598)
No, this is not an example of the tragedy of the commons. It is simply a negative externality: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality#Negative

And I guess it is an example of market failure in the technical sense but I don't think I would phrase that as "when a market economy fails" as it is not clear whether you are talking colloquially or technically.

EDIT: Just to clarify why it is critical to be specific, positive externalities are also market failures. Caring about a technical market failures is a bit abstract, I would not lose sleep over it, they happen.

Caring about a negative externalities and advocating for them to be internalized is a lot more concrete and actionable and not something I think anybody really disagrees with on paper.

You will have more practical disagreements though because it is unlikely that microplastics being used in say Denmark has the same environmental impact as microplastics being used in say Asia or Africa: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/06/90-of-plastic-polluti... and applying a tax to people in Denmark won't result in the externality being internalized in Nigeria.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by nicoburns on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @10:03AM (#23614024)
> Caring about a negative externalities and advocating for them to be internalized is a lot more concrete and actionable and not something I think anybody really disagrees with on paper.

Nobody would let you write it down on paper. But a lot of corporations put a lot of money and effort into preventing this from happening. I believe almost all of our economic woes could be fixed with an economic approach that treated negative externalities as an expected and common case in a free market and actively pursued policies to mitigate them (as opposed to idolising the free part of "free markets" and treating regulation to fix externalities as a last resort).

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by IanCal on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @03:26PM (#23618971)
> Nobody would let you write it down on paper.

I'm not sure what you mean by this, it's a regularly advocated for position at all levels.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by nicoburns on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @06:44PM (#23621323)
> it's a regularly advocated for position at all levels.

The position that we shouldn't internalise negative externalities? Who is openly advocating for this?

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by IanCal on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @03:41AM (#23625204)
Oh I see, sorry, I interpreted the exact opposite.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by nicoburns on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @05:24AM (#23625876)
I thought that might be the case. No worries!
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by lm28469 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @10:08AM (#23614077)
> it is unlikely that microplastics being used in say Denmark has the same environmental impact as microplastics being used in say Asia or Africa

Did you ever wonder why Asia and Africa are responsible for so much pollution ? I'm asking that because any amount of research will show you that first world countries are sending hundreds of tons of appliances, computers, smartphones, &c. per day over there for them to be "recycled", and by "recycled" I meant burned/melted in open air dumps. (And also because they're manufacturing all our shitty ultra short lived gadgets, cloths, &c.)

It's literally like throwing your shit on the neighbours lawn and blaming them. Actually it's even worse now that China told us to fuck off with our trash.

> Until recently, half of the collected plastic – especially low-grade plastic – was exported to China, but China has completely stopped its [used plastic] imports. Therefore the majority of plastic will likely end up burnt while just 15 percent will be recycled”

Are we talking about the future of Humanity or about "it's not my problem it didn't happen in the country I was born in" .... we're doomed. The world is a closed eco system so of fucking course the European plastic and the African plastic will eventually end up in your plate (especially if the Europen plastic is sent to Africa for "recycling")

https://www.thelocal.dk/20180910/danes-are-sorting-more-plas...

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by Nasrudith on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @11:25AM (#23615149)
Well Asia and Africia also often lack proper garbage infastructures in many areas (they are kind of big continents) in addition to being poor enough to wind up regularly taking external trash.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by vbezhenar on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @06:14PM (#23621030)
That's because humans act on a country-scale. We need planetary scale to act reasonably on matters like that. Until then it's always cheaper to exploit poor countries rather than building proper waste recycling. And for some strange reason world government is not happening.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by chiefalchemist on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @02:50PM (#23618451)
> Did you ever wonder why Asia and Africa are responsible for so much pollution

I hate to parse words but the nuance is important. They are not responsible. Yes, they generate it. But the responsibility belongs to the source (i.e., countries up the economic / development food chain.)

This is why it persists: out of sight, out of mind. Nearly all the consumers in the source countries are oblivious to their contributions. Enlightening them would throttle the consumption-based economy. That's not good for profits.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by primroot on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @06:26PM (#23621151)
>> ... over there for them to be "recycled", and by "recycled" I meant burned/melted in open air dumps.

I thought the Basel convention covered this in some way. Larry Summers had (has?) a rather infamous opinion on this [0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Summers_memo

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by dragonwriter on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @10:12AM (#23614125)
> Caring about a negative externalities and advocating for them to be internalized is a lot more concrete and actionable

It's less concrete and actionable than you'd think, because measuring (and therefore identifying and internalizing) externalities requires utility assessments, and experienced utility is subjective and immeasurable and it's very, very easy for ones preferred outcome to influence one’s choice of utility estimator. (And even easier for it to lead you to find an excuse to dismiss someone else’s.)

> and not something I think anybody really disagrees with on paper.

I think the general opinion of both the Chicago and Austrian schools is that efforts to internalize externalities are generally a bad idea, and in the Austrian case specifically wrong on principal.

Public figures adhering to those viewpoints are likely to couch them in circumlocution outside of addresses to selected audiences because they are very large groups with which they are dealbreaker positions, but they aren't exactly obscure positions.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by ajuc on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @04:27PM (#23619784)
> I think the general opinion of both the Chicago and Austrian schools is that efforts to internalize externalities are generally a bad idea, and in the Austrian case specifically wrong on principal.

Why?

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by mac01021 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @03:47PM (#23619292)
Why is it not a tragedy of the commons?

"The tragedy of the commons is a situation in a shared-resource system where individual users, acting independently according to their own self-interest, behave contrary to the common good of all users by depleting or spoiling the shared resource through their collective action."

In this case, given that everyone else is going to use plastics, it is in my interest to use them too. But I would be better off (maybe) if noone used them. Does that not fit the definition?

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by edjrage on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @06:24PM (#23621136)
The important bit is "by depleting or spoiling the shared resource".

Plastic is not a "shared resource". It's not at risk of depletion or "spoilage". It's obviously the opposite problem.

I think the example with the sheep makes it perfectly clear what the concept is and isn't.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by mac01021 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @06:32PM (#23621209)
Soil and oceans are shared resources, which we're (probably) spoiling by permeating them with countless minuscule bits of plastic.

Or maybe I don't properly understand what "spoil" means.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by acd on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @06:03AM (#23626140)
The spoil is by polluting shared natural resources that we depend on for quality of life. Such as clean water, clean air an functional eco system that provides enough oxygen, stable earth temperature.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by graeme on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @11:12AM (#23614942)
What is the distinction between negative externality and tragedy of the commons. I had always figured the latter was an example of the former.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by Nasrudith on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @11:27AM (#23615184)
Tragedy of the commons is exhaustion of a shared renewable resource as everyone has the incentive to take now when they can and none to steward its growth. Negative externalities are a cost bared by people external to the activity. A common example would be pollution of air or water.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by graeme on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @01:05PM (#23616825)
In that view, the air and water are on their way to exhaustion, but not exhausted. So perhaps tragedy of the commons could be viewed as an endpoint on the same process. It’s certainly caused by externalities. (Grazing has costs to others, who lose the ability to graze)
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by andy_ppp on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:54PM (#23622601)
“The tragedy of the commons is a situation in a shared-resource system where individual users, acting independently according to their own self-interest, behave contrary to the common good of all users by depleting or spoiling the shared resource through their collective action.” It is definitely a Tragedy of the Commons at least according to the Wikipedia definition...
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by emiliobumachar on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:09AM (#23627413)
Seconded. Both concepts apply, as is very common.

Attempting to generalize: A tragedy of the commons is when everyone would be better off if everyone avoided an action which produces more negative externalities than captured value, but each one is individually better off if they take that action, so most do take it.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by user234683 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @01:39PM (#23617383)
> applying a tax to people in Denmark won't result in the externality being internalized in Nigeria

What if Denmark imposes a tariff equal to the tax on imported plastic goods from any countries not implementing such a tax?

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by fennecfoxen on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @01:45PM (#23617491)
Nigeria doesn't export much plastic to Denmark, or to anywhere, really, so it has very little impact either way.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by throwaway2048 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:49AM (#23613883)
Nigeria can easily make the same argument for Denmark then nothing ever changes.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by jaekash on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:55AM (#23613954)
Well I mean they could but they would have to provide actual data (similar to what I cited) to back it up. Just because people can make absurd claims is not a good reason to entertain them.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by amarte on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @10:16AM (#23614173)
The world's first synthetic plastic was invented in 1907, and the field has since expanded to include a wide range of variant materials that have permeated nearly every aspect of our lives. I think it's hard to understand the net quality of life benefits that plastics in general have brought to humanity because most of us alive today were born into a world where these great technical achievements have already suffused daily life, so it's easy to take them for granted, while we are only now beginning to discover some of their negative consequences. For example, single use plastics: largely unnecessary in most cases, although not all -- think medical applications. Non-renewable sourcing: the production of many of these materials is contributing to a carbon debt that we're only now beginning to understand the magnitude of. Etc etc... But don't "throw the baby out with the bathwater." I don't think the market economy failed with plastics. The scale of their production and myriad applications was and continues to be an incredible success with both positive and negative externalities. The market needs to adjust given society's new understanding that we've gone too far in some areas, and not far enough in others. As people become aware of the environmental persistence of materials like polystyrene (tradename Styrofoam) for example, and are offered biodegradable, price-competitive offsets, they'll stop buying polystyrene. Closed-loop recycling, carbon capture, renewable sourcing etc are all examples of course corrections that will hopefully gain steam in the market and point us in the right direction.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by stx on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @10:50AM (#23614624)
I wish we would use less plastic and packaging in general. Its depressing when you buy a product and it has layers and layers of packaging. When I visited a poor part of Mexico in 2000 they still had a system where you purchased a soda in a glass bottle and then returned it for a small refund from the place you purchased it. If a poor city in Mexico does this why cant we do so in the USA? Please do understand that in almost all other ways though this city in Mexico had garbage ever-where.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by svrtknst on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @12:02PM (#23615739)
Glass bottles are being removed more and more in Sweden, and it would be interesting to see the microplastic waste created by recycled plastics, and the comparative energy requirements to produce and ship a glass bottle vs. a plastic bottle - Esp. plastic made from plants or sugar cane.

All soda/beer bottles and cans sold give you a small refund, and pretty much all waste is recycleable in some way. Slightly dependent on infrastructure in your vicinity, but most municipalities ought to be able to recycle food waste, cardboard, plastic, glass, and metal easily.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by wahern on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:58PM (#23622633)
Bottles aren't a substantial source of microplastics, partly because they're easily recycled. In developed countries synthetic fibers like polyester and abrasion from tires are two of the largest contributors to environmental microplastics; there's no capturing system in place whatsoever, yet they're ubiquitous in modern life. See https://portals.iucn.org/library/sites/library/files/documen...
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by basicplus2 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @05:30PM (#23620566)
"the net quality of life benefits that plastics in general have brought to humanity"

The plastics production before the late 60's had virtually no impact compared to what followed. Quality of life when i was a child was just fine.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @05:36PM (#23620639)
> Quality of life when i was a child was just fine.

I bet you grew up in the West or Japan. Otherwise across Africa, China, India, quality of life for the average person is massively better now than in the 60’s.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by basicplus2 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @06:54PM (#23621404)
Yes but their improvment of quality of life as absolutely nothing to do with them using plastic, which is what the subject of the conversation is about.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @09:24PM (#23622828)
Cheap, disposable plastic contributed a lot to globalization. It is easier to preserve food in plastic wrap. In addition, it is much lighter and/or cheaper than metal and thus easier to transport long distances. Global trade was probably the biggest driver for the improvement of the quality of life in the places mentioned.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by peterwwillis on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @10:33AM (#23614388)
Whenever there is a faulty complex system (economic, civic government, other) people insist we need an entirely new system. But if you design a car with faulty brakes, you don't invent a brand new car. You fix the brakes.

It doesn't seem immediately obvious how we could change a market economy to resist negative externalities, but I think it's the best solution (especially when the system is well studied).

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by edjrage on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @06:31PM (#23621199)
> if you design a car with faulty brakes, you don't invent a brand new car. You fix the brakes.

Funny, this immediately came to mind:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/motoring/car-manufacturers/volks...

> “The Kombi was designed 60 years ago so it would not be possible now to put an airbag and ABS into the car. That’s why we now have to stop production,” said Jochen Funk, director of sales for VW Brazil.

So yeah, maybe we've been driving a (now 70)-year old Kombi and trying to convince ourselves one day we'll be able to just bolt ABS brakes on it.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by anonuser123456 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @12:26PM (#23616148)
Economists solved this problem a long time ago; Pigouvian taxes. No need to dump markets. You just make them pay for their externalities.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by swsieber on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @11:31AM (#23615236)
If what we have today is a market econmy, then a market economy is perfectly acceptable way to address the issue: taxes of some sort.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by ahoy on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @05:34PM (#23620623)
The very companies that cause that cause the negative externalities hire lobbyists and buy politicians to write the tax code.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by swsieber on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:10AM (#23624004)
Would things be any different in a different type of economy? I think that's ba political failure, not a market failure. I think at the very least, you're likely to run into corruption issues no matter what economic model you use.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by blueline on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @11:53AM (#23615600)
taxes aren't a silver bullet. if the affected companies were to just pass the extra cost to consumers (why wouldn't they?), then you effectively have implemented a regressive tax that affects the poorest consumers the most.

clearly there's more to it than that, but assuming that the market can address any negative externalities just with taxes is pretty naive IMO

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by dwiel on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @12:01PM (#23615710)
I heard of this first with respect to a carbon tax, but one solution is to evenly redistribute the collected tax among all citizens. This way, the market can internalize the externality while keeping the average person no poorer.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by anonuser123456 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @12:28PM (#23616198)
You set the price of the tax equal to the mitigation cost. In this way consumers pay to mitigate. If mitigation is coat prohibitive, consumers substitute products that are not harmful.

Edit: W.r.t. regressive taxation... No one has the right to force their externalities on someone else. Just because you are poor doesn't mean you can dump your garbage on my lawn because it's cheaper than paying to haul it to the dump.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by LaurieKoudstaal on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:40AM (#23627733)
That isn't how pigouvian taxes work. The point is adjusts the price so that it correctly includes all external costs not already reflected in the costs. It is not about raising revenue to deal with the problem, but changing relative incentives.

For this reason, if the tax is regressive, its perfectly OK for the revenue to be redistributed in tax breaks to lower income.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by ip26 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @04:02PM (#23619486)
Affected Company A passes the 1% cost increase of the tax to the consumer.

Affected Company B changes their packaging, e.g. to recycled paper, to avoid the tax at a 0.1% cost increase and passes it to the consumer.

You tell me what happens next.

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by bluGill on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @05:02PM (#23620216)
Problem is company B increased their costs by 5% to avoid the tax. Plastics are so cheap compared to alternatives that this is a real situation.
Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by lend000 on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @02:27PM (#23618118)
This is an externality, and the best role of government in a market economy is to tax externalities such that the tax imposed is enough to "fix" the externality. Fixing it would be extremely expensive, so it would make plastics only viable where they are needed most, and in applications where there is tracking and accountability in recycling and waste management.

Also note two major flaws in your reasoning about trying to blame pollution as a "market economy" failure.

1. The US military is the biggest single polluter around [0], outside of perhaps some "non-market-economy" country's militaries like China and Russia. It's hard to know exactly how much damage they do and impossible to hold them accountable for it. The substances they leak into groundwater tend to be worse than plastics. Good luck finding a government model that doesn't have a military.

2. Most of the microplastics in the ocean are coming from third world countries, where there simply isn't enough wealth for there to be political willpower to reduce externalized pollution.

The real solution we need is more futuristic waste management technologies that can break down harmful pollutants and turn them into usable material, and I expect they will come from the "market economy."

[0] https://qz.com/1655268/us-military-is-a-bigger-polluter-than...

Re:Nanoplastics accumulate in land-plant tissues: study by chapium on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:59AM (#23613267)
The market seems like any system really. It can be stable, but this is only common with a diverse array of variables. Otherwise it gets into positive or negative feedback loops. Human behavior acts as a dampener or an amplifier.