In cases where diplomas are required, the acceptance letter will always contain language stating that they will retract your acceptance if your grades drop an unacceptable amount or you don't finish the degree you're working on. Then most schools require you to submit another set of transcripts, proof of graduation, etc. before you officially enroll.
I mean, didn't you ever hear of Doogie Howser?
The claim that MIT is somehow a national treasure and unique here seems to miss the point. I know this because I was accepted early admission to MIT and graduated from there.
Extracurricular activities and evidence of capabilities have always carried significant weight in MIT's decision making process, but this is also the case for many other schools. It's only the graduate school process that requires evidence of completion of lower education. Try getting into a PhD program without a high school diploma or an undergraduate degree. And no, I'm not talking about honorary doctorates.
Does any graduate program even ASK if an applicant has a certificate of completion of secondary schooling? Which one?
(Note that the submitted post claims that the author knows someone who received multiple offers of admission to graduate programs without possessing a high school diploma, which sounds very plausible to me indeed.)
Yes - the world renowned Media Lab.
I was baffled as to why. I have good grades, above average SAT scores, a solid academic foundation(I believe). On top of that I've been working at a software company for the past year, founded multiple robotics teams in my area, and I'm now working on starting my own company.
Enough with the rant. The way I see it, if the college told me they weren't interested in me since I've been home schooled they're probably not worth my time to even apply.
Which one? I'll write to the college's admission office and tell them what they are missing (based on my acquaintance with dozens of homeschoolers in recent graduating classes).
See
http://learninfreedom.org/colleges_4_hmsc.html
for how much of an outlier such a college must be.
http://www.commondataset.org/
surveys United States colleges and universities each year about their admission policies. Question C3 asks if a high school diploma is required for undergraduate admission.
Harvard
http://www.provost.harvard.edu/institutional_research/Provos...
does not require a high school diploma for admission.
Neither does Princeton.
http://registrar.princeton.edu/university_enrollment_sta/com...
Nor does Yale require a high school diploma.
http://www.yale.edu/oir/cds.pdf
MIT has long reported that it does not require a high school diploma for admission.
http://web.mit.edu/ir/cds/2010/c.html
http://www.mitadmissions.org/topics/qanda/questions_and_answ...
There are other colleges that explicitly say in their Common Data Set filings that they do not require a high school diploma for admission. Moreover, homeschooling is widespread in around the world,
http://learninfreedom.org/homeschool_growth.html
and all of the most famous and most desired colleges and universities have admitted homeschoolers,
http://learninfreedom.org/colleges_4_hmsc.html
who often have "home brew" transcripts (as my oldest son did when he applied for his undergraduate university studies last year).
Lacking a high school diploma issued by a government-operated school is not a barrier to admission to any of the better colleges or universities in the United States, if the applicant is well prepared for higher education study.
After edit: I'm amazed that this thread has not yet mentioned pg's essay "What You'll Wish You'd Known,"
http://paulgraham.com/hs.html
his advice to high school students about how to use their time meaningfully. High school students who take this advice to heart can get into a good college with good financial support if they want to, or pursue some other challenging personal goal if they would rather do that.