News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SCP – Familiar, Simple, Insecure, and Slow by ggm on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:20PM (#23579878)
We all use rsync but rsync itself has massive risks and is equally prone to stupid buffering consequences. (I worked on a write up of an exploit to hose an rsync server in rpki and the lack of channel protect in rsync is a problem. Rsync over SSH is less risky but not risk free to either side. What is sent and what is asked for do not have to align well) rsync over SSH needs tuning to be buffer efficient.

Tar may well be better if you know you need all the files and don't need the block checks per file to detect change and minimise data sent.

Rsync can hose the file buffer cache and slow a server down. If you want speed mbuffer is good but lacks channel security too (ZFS send over mbuffer is awesomely fast)

Re:SCP – Familiar, Simple, Insecure, and Slow by kbenson on Friday June 19, 2020 @08:16PM (#23580294)
> but rsync itself has massive risks

Err, what risks? If you run a server? Sure, but as a replacement for scp, where it's assumed you have an account on the remote system, an rsync server is not the equivalent solution, running rsync across an ssh connection is.

> Rsync over SSH is less risky but not risk free to either side. What is sent and what is asked for do not have to align well)

Glossing over that no system is "risk free", can you explain in a bit more detail here, or reference what you wrote up or some other thing? That's the kind of thing I would really want to know about, and an unsubstantiated throw-away aside does not do justice to the problem if accurate.

Re:SCP – Familiar, Simple, Insecure, and Slow by ggm on Friday June 19, 2020 @10:53PM (#23581125)
Re:SCP – Familiar, Simple, Insecure, and Slow by ggm on Saturday June 20, 2020 @12:13AM (#23581595)
The principle point is that if the server is compromised, the ssh tunnel just becomes a mechanism to propagate things. If you say --size-only or --no-delete or whatever, it doesn't acually constrain what happens over the rsync protocol. It just says what you want the other side to know: if the other side is a bad actor, it can send you whatever it likes, and that can include filepaths outside the local constraint you think you scoped it to (the target can be ../../.. specified)
Re:SCP – Familiar, Simple, Insecure, and Slow by kbenson on Saturday June 20, 2020 @12:21AM (#23581631)
Yeah, I was just reading, thanks for sending the link. What I'm at so far, which is that you were able to successfully get a client to write outside of it's expected root location using a 119 line python script as the server, is pretty problematic in itself if not yet fixed/mitigated in some way. :/

Did you event submit these finding as a bug? I would be interested in tracking this if it was accepted. It looks like this note from 3.1.2's release[1] is it, but I'm not sure:

File-list validation in 3.1.2 December 21st, 2015

If you're using a version of rsync older than 3.1.2 as a client and receiving files from an rsync server that you might not fully trust, this version adds extra checking to the file list to prevent the sender from tweaking the paths and/or the transfer requests in a way that could cause a file to be received outside the transfer destination.

1: https://rsync.samba.org/security.html#s3_1_3