News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by Grimm1 on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:41PM (#23579595)
They do it at no benefit to the OSS providers, that's the issue.
Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by xyzzy_plugh on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:46PM (#23579632)
Why do they need to benefit the OSS provider? The license doesn't contain anything suggesting otherwise.

If authors want credit and money, the license needs to state as much. You can't publish something saying "do whatever you want" and then complain that people aren't being fair to you.

Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by Signez on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:56PM (#23579701)
> You can't publish something saying "do whatever you want" and then complain that people aren't being fair to you.

Well… you can complain. You just can't sue them. But the complaint would still be valid.

You can act like a jerk and follow all the laws at the same time, it's just that the consequences for you won't be identical.

Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by sukilot on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:41PM (#23580047)
Doing exactly as you are told by the copyright holder isn't being a jerk.
Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by Sean-Der on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:58PM (#23579715)
Do you believe that authoritarian measures is the only thing that makes people do the just thing?

I am sure some people don't steal/murder because of laws, but I optimistically think the majority don't because they don't wish to hurt others.

Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by typomatic on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:57PM (#23579709)
My parents asked me for some money the other day, but I told them to pound sand--if they wanted my help they should have made me sign something before they gave me all that free room and board. Suckers!
Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by tathougies on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:33PM (#23579976)
Legally, yes, that is how it should be. even if worthy of criticism socially.
Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by Grimm1 on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:08PM (#23579789)
1 point by Grimm1 8 minutes ago | edit | delete [–]

The licenses weren't conceived of with the thought of something like AWS. Now that we're in the midst of things that's changing but what is an officially supported open source license [0] is too slow so you can't use the OSS label if you've you're not using the approved licenses. Both Mongo and Elasticsearch have changed their licenses to prevent cloud players from taking advantage of their work and companies like Gitlab make a clear distinction between their FOSS parts and what they make money on by using two different licenses. The issues are only a little over a half decade old now the OSS players are starting to figure it out.

Open source just doesn't mean anyone can use it, there's a definition to adhere to and and org managing that definition. [1]

It was never intended as a free for all.

[0] https://opensource.org/licenses [1] https://opensource.org/about

Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by baddox on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:36PM (#23579999)
> The licenses weren't conceived of with the thought of something like AWS.

You mean...a hosting company? I find it hard to believe that the open source movement was blindsided by the realization that there are companies that sell hosting services and that somehow this destroys the viability of their movement.

Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by MattGaiser on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:48PM (#23579646)
But isn't that part of the point of open source? If you want people to have to pay for it in some way, it needs to be part of the license. The license is essentially free for all.
Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by Sean-Der on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:00PM (#23579729)
Open Source isn't just one mindset. This isn't exhaustive, but the ones I encounter the most.

* You have people that are ideologically driven (FSF)

* You have companies that Open Source as a weapon [0] (Chromium)

* You have projects that are very pragmatic. They believe it is the path to technical excellence.

* You have individuals do it for their resume

* You have individuals that do it just for fun :)

[0] https://www.gwern.net/Complement#open-source-as-a-strategic-...

Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by Grimm1 on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:59PM (#23579724)
The licenses weren't conceived of with the thought of something like AWS. Now that we're in the midst of things that's changing but what is an officially supported open source license [0] is too slow so you can't use the OSS label if you've you're not using the approved licenses. Both Mongo and Elasticsearch have changed their licenses to prevent cloud players from taking advantage of their work and companies like Gitlab make a clear distinction between their FOSS parts and what they make money on by using two different licenses.

The issues are only a little over a half decade old now the OSS players are starting to figure it out.

Open source just doesn't mean anyone can use it, there's a definition to adhere to and and org managing that definition. [1]

It was never intended as a free for all.

[0] https://opensource.org/licenses [1] https://opensource.org/about

Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by searchableguy on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:57PM (#23579712)
Legality doesn't always cover everything because that would result in a lot of problems. People operate on the spirit of the law, not the actual words or at least they are supposed to.

There is an expectation of contribution back.

Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by sukilot on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:43PM (#23580060)
The spirit of open source is to protect the users, not benefit the authors.
Re:You download the app and it doesn’t work by ric2b on Saturday June 20, 2020 @04:41AM (#23582664)
With GPL yes, with MIT no.