News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by BrandoElFollito on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:06PM (#23577830)
This is such a loss of money. The practical aspects will never be used.

This will move some technologies a bit ahead but so would work on biology and medical areas. I would be much more happy to see people cured or otherwise helped than to know that a partcle is this or that.

This is in strong opposition to what happened in these areas of physics in the previous century. Things which were directives had a conceivable practical application.

What can you make out of events which happen at such energies, the kind we will never reach outside of such research centers.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by calcifer on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:18PM (#23578489)
Science for its own sake is a noble pursuit. Not everything has to have commercial applications or to be "practical".
Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by qwobit on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:33PM (#23579068)
Agree. But another thing I must point out is that pure mathematics is an example of ‘doing stuff for the sake of doing stuff’ and it has had an incredibly long lasting influence, with physicists turning to pure mathematics research to aid with their own problems.

The solution just has to be a perfect fit with the problem to become practical in industry. We often do not see the practicality of such abstract ideas until they are abundant in use.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by BrandoElFollito on Saturday June 20, 2020 @03:42AM (#23582470)
With mathematics you have at least hope to use it someday. Indeed, research on elliptic equations may not have been seen as important until widespread crypto hit.

Moreover, the cost is small. This is also the rational by which we can agree that philosophy is worth spending money on (because "general culture").

Here we have 20B€ so that some people discover the structure of a particle, knowing that it is exactly impossible to have a real life use because of the required energies.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by pg-gadfly on Saturday June 20, 2020 @06:02AM (#23582982)
It isn't "exactly impossible" though, it never is. You can find out a more efficient way to create it, or you might have more power available in the future.

All manmade elements have been extremely expensive to make the first ti-me, and that hasn't stopped them from being constantly used.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by BrandoElFollito on Saturday June 20, 2020 @12:06PM (#23584663)
There is no efficiency - juste pure energy needs. You cannot probe a quark with lower energy.

Then there is nothing to use from such experiments. The research is purely academic, it is not like the cure for cancer is hidden behind a gluon.

I can understand dumping even 20B€ in research which brings something tangible. Making sure that the structure of a quark is what we think it is is not one of these.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by pg-gadfly on Sunday June 21, 2020 @07:48AM (#23591498)
>There is no efficiency

There is certainly efficiency to consider when making energy. We can't tap into the full potential of any source, there are "hard limits" to many of our current methods, but that doesen't stop a paradigm shift from happening and making it so.

Many things studied before had no "tangible" use then, it doesen't come like that. It's iteration upon iteration, using previous work to achieve a little bit of something new. You cannot foresee the future beforehand.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by BrandoElFollito on Sunday June 21, 2020 @09:49AM (#23591999)
At some point in physics there is no "paradigm shift". In order to probe such structures you need an enormous energy. An energy you have to build an accelerator to have.

What do you get in return? The confirmation or not of a theory which can be confirmed only at these energies. It is not as a non-confirmation would turn around physics, it would be just some strange thing happening at these energies.

Compare this with experiments from the late 1800 and early 1900. You had obvious holes in the theory (Michelson-Morley, the ultraviolet catastrophe, ...) - these experiments were showing that something in our everyday theory is wrong. Not some fluctuations at 20B€.

There are branches of physics where the research is really cool (notably solid state physics) and which you can make a real life use of. Particle physics is not one of them.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by pg-gadfly on Friday June 26, 2020 @02:21AM (#23649242)
As I've been saying, you don't know the point at which there is no more to learn. Even minor things can have major impact when combined with further research.

Things like "enormous" are subjective, and it's indeed not impossible to get such amounts cheaply in the future, even if you can't at the time reduce it's need.

It's easy to look in the past and point out the obvious when you already have all the answers, but trying to divine something that changes the way you think about current physics is not as simple.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by BrandoElFollito on Friday June 26, 2020 @02:52AM (#23649408)
Things like "enormous" are not subjective in physics. We know that we need a certain density of energy to probe a particle. There are no miracles: it has to come from somewhere and it is not like there are sources of such energy that can pop up from nowhere. We simply do not have a place to harvest such energy on the global scale, and we know we won't have anytime soon. There are simply no sources for that.

> Even minor things can have major impact when combined with further research

We are talking about things happening at energies which are way beyond normal interactions. Let's imagine we pick a simple artificial signal from the sky, from a place that is 5000 light years away.

People will get crazy about aliens and loose their shit on how we are not alone. And so what - from a practical perspective there is exactly zero interest in this. We cannot use that information at all because whatever is there is unreachable.

There are however plenty of place in physics which are worth the effort (I mentioned solid state physics as one of the most promising ones). Not to mention biology where we are only right at the beginning and there are plenty of outcomes.

If we had infinite resources then fine. We do not have them. And putting 20B€ in some fancy research with zero practical interest (such as this one, or middle-ages French literature, or Platon philosophy, ...) is a tremendous waste of opportunities.

I understand that we need to fund research with no practical interest - this is part of what makes us human. Just not 20B€ when people are starving, dying, etc.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by d_tr on Saturday June 20, 2020 @02:11PM (#23585523)
I agree and would like to add that people have been proven to be very bad at making at least certain kinds of predictions.

Humans may still be around after 100 thousand years. The electron had not even been discovered just 130 years ago.

It is very difficult to make good predictions about the possible practical applications of our current physics knowledge. Of course, it is much more difficult to make such predictions about as yet undiscovered physics...

Besides, HEP experiments aim to expand our knowledge about the fundamental laws of nature. Fundamental laws are by definition applicable to all energy scales.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by BrandoElFollito on Saturday June 20, 2020 @03:37AM (#23582455)
When you have 20B€ to spend, you first make a round of the real needs in science.

Understanding the structure of a quark is priority 100 compared to understanding how to cure MS.

In an ideal world where we have all the money we need, sure. In the world we are in one must make choices.

Re:CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider by orf on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:43PM (#23578180)
Just wait until you see your countries military budget!