So with that "exception", you can ban absolutely anything.
1. Your assertion has empirical counter-examples. My favorite example is Tinker. The dissent in that case already foreshadows exactly your concern, that the "substantial disruption" test was quite arbitrary. But, in fact, lower courts were by-and-large extraordinarily friendly toward student speech when applying the Tinker test. So much so that SCOTUS has had to limit the scope of Tinker at least a few times in the intervening years (e.g., Hazelwood and Morse). It's not perfect, but no reasonable person looking at the historical record can say that the "substantial disruption" exception to free speech was used to ban "absolutely anything". And "substantial disruption" is probably the most mild form of harm.
2. Remember that TulliusCicero isn't arguing against free speech. They're only pointing out that DanielBMarkham's particular defense of free speech isn't compelling. I think that's fair. DanielBMarkham's approach toward defending free speech, which has at its roots in some enlightenment-era ideas about what man is, really doesn't provide us with a good conceptual framework for addressing TulliusCicero's critique.
So, although I'm pro-free speech, but I don't think the argument that either you or DanielBMarkham put forward are particularly compelling.
If you want to defend free speech, you have to honestly deal with the valid concern that speech really can harm. Insisting that man is a rational animal, or even that the search for truth will always lead to good outcomes, is... just not historically compelling.
My argument was mean in the generic and at an abstract level. I understand that for some people this is not compelling. Conversely, if were to dive down into specifics, we would need a somewhat lengthy conversation about where the guardrails were and where the (hopefully unmovable) goalposts were.
Of course at some level of analysis free speech can cause harm, otherwise there would be no point in defending it. My admittedly-oversimplified point, which I have yet to see refuted, is that in the main, we really suck at predicting the difference between harm and progress. Many times it takes decades or centuries to sort it out. From there we can end up with the law being an ass[1] or some finer definition of legitimate public policy choices. But unless we can all admit that we suck at determining who should speak or not, we really don't have a basis to continue the conversation, legally or philosophically.[2]
It's fine to say "Let's start here, and given the current tech, governmental structures, and laws we live under, where do we go?" It's also fine to say "What is the purpose of letting people say things that can hurt others, anyway?" Pick one. I chose the second one. If you'd like to talk about the first one, that's a completely different conversation. However if you don't grok the conversation on root principles, it's unlikely any sort of more complex or nuanced conversation is going to lead you anywhere useful. That has to be where we all start.
Also, insisting man is a rational animal is yet another can of worms which I didn't open up. I don't think man is a rational animal at all, and that doesn't change my opinion or where I think the conversation has to begin.
[1] https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/the-law-is-an-ass.html
[2] When I say that we suck at determining who should speak or not, I mean in a moral, ethical, and public policy sense. I do not mean in a legal sense. Obviously there's a ton of case law around most all of our amendments. I'm surveying a landscape, not preparing a legal brief.
Sorry, I'm not sure what that means. The Tinker example was just a demonstration that, empirically, adding "harm reduction" exceptions to free speech doesn't always result in arbitrary restrictions on speech. Not for any profound ultimate reason, but just because that's just not how the herd dynamics of on particular judiciary worked.
> But unless we can all admit that we suck at determining who should speak or not, we really don't have a basis to continue the conversation, legally or philosophically.
Okay. But that's a bit of a strawman. I don't see anyone here arguing that perfect censorship is possible. NB: most people in this thread aren't even arguing against free speech. We just don't think you're providing a compelling justification for free speech. Which is different from disagreeing with your conclusion. But the difference isn't pedantic; it has important down-stream effects and implications.
> insisting man is a rational animal is yet another can of worms which I didn't open up... I don't think man is a rational animal at all, and that doesn't change my opinion or where I think the conversation has to begin.
Well, I think my entire point was that you do open that can of worms and perhaps don't even realize it.
Perhaps you misunderstand what I mean by "rational" here. I don't mean "perfectly rational" or "good at reasoning" or "not susceptible to emotion/propaganda" or anything like that. I mean it in a much more basic "what is that thing that is happening when we think and speak, regardless of any consideration of truth or correctness or progress or any of that" sense.
To keep things concise and specific, the following sentences exemplify the thing I find philosophically suspect in the way you think about free speech:
- "a lot of those times we got so upset about people saying various things, we were wrong. Those people changed all of us for the better."
- "we really suck at predicting the difference between harm and progress."
- "Unless we continue to humbly think we could continue to be wrong, we stop evolving."
I disagree that these propositions are even particularly meaningful.
To be clear and to avoid a tangent, it's not that I disagree because I think the opposite. I.e., I disagree equally and in the exact same way with the statement "we are good at predicting the difference between harm and progress".
My disagreement is at a fundamental and philosophical level. In the sense that I think there's a bunch of incorrect stuff we have to assume about the role that rationality plays in human thought and human language (and, therefore, human politics) in order for a discussion about any of these propositions to even make sense.
Perhaps this will help get the point across: when I say "you think man is a rational animal", what I really mean is that you have a very specific type of answer you're going to give to the question: "what is the reason that it doesn't occur to us to use any of the quotes I listed above to talk about deer or bears or whales?" And your answer to that question is simply not the answer I would give.
(NB, to avoid a tangent, it's the reason those sentences have meaning for humans and not other animals -- not whether they have meaning for one and not the other -- that is the thing that I think we disagree on at some sort of fundamental philosophical level.)
You see enlightened subjects coming to belief (perhaps false or perhaps true) through the use of cognition (perhaps logical or perhaps emotional; perhaps sound logic or perhaps bad logic; perhaps positive emotion or perhaps negative emotion).
I see a herd of animals acted upon by emergent social phenomenon over which no one of the herd has particularly much control.
When I think about the reason for free speech, I think about herd dynamics and the importance (or not) of entropy. When you think about the reason for free speech, you think about individuals reasoning and the limits (or not) of rationality. Of course both of us see shades of each, I'm just much more to one side of that continuum and you're much more to the other side.
That's fair. But insisting that preventing speech will always lead to good outcomes is also not historically compelling.
The problem then becomes, which speech to block. Well, speech that causes harm. That's great, in theory. But do you have an objective measure? A measure that's universally agreed-upon? And if not, who decides?
And now you're back to DanielBMarkham's argument. What if the people who decide are the equivalent of the pre-Civil-War South? (They would have classified abolitionist speech as causing harm - I mean, look at the war it caused!) Or of the 1950s with respect to gay rights? Or just hard-core Republicans or Democrats? I'm sure the Chinese Communist Party could also come up with some definitions of "causing harm" that are, um, not ones that I would agree with.
I am unwilling to trust very many people with that power...
yes, agreed.
(Also, I really meant it when I said "I'm pro-free speech".)
> And now you're back to DanielBMarkham's argument
I don't think so. His argument still seems somehow fundamentally wrong. These notions of good and evil, of true and false, etc., all seem to somehow miss the point for me.
I guess here's a good specific way of making this point: I would support free speech even if the censor were perfectly good and omniscient and all-powerful and maximally ethical and perfectly charismatic. Perhaps especially if. How would DanielBMarkham's justification for free speech ever get you to that point? I don't think it does.
Also, getting the justification right somehow doesn't seem academic to me at all. It seems quite fundamental. Why? because any supporter of censorship does believe that their censor is, if not perfect, at least better and truer and more charismatic. And perhaps they don't want the censor to be all powerful, but certainly do what the censor to be more powerful.
No, you can't. Human beings don't process language at such a low level that any statement which parses as grammatically valid is considered equally valid to all others in all possible dimensions, interpretations and contexts.
While It may technically be possible to make an argument that any arbitrary statement causes real world harm and violence, not all such statements would be considered equally credible. The slippery slope you're describing here doesn't exist.
Just a few weeks ago a NYT op ed by senator Tom Cotton caused a staff revolt at the paper which got the editorial page editor fired, and a main argument was that publishing it threatened the lives of NYT employees.
The official editorial note makes no mention of this:
> An editors’ note posted late Friday noted factual inaccuracies and a “needlessly harsh” tone. “The essay fell short of our standards and should not have been published,” the note said.
In the end, criticisms of one for-profit newspaper aren't all that compelling to "free speech". In the same way we don't force a Christian church to allow any atheist to debate evidence against the existence of a god _in_ _a_ _church_, we don't force private companies to publish that which the company doesn't want to publish.
So long as the discussion is happening somewhere in society, I don't know that we must insist that _all_ conversations are happening _everywhere_.
So what? Are you saying those arguments aren't true? If so, of course you should make that counter-argument.
Or are you saying that even if they are true, it's more important to protect "mainstream conservative arguments" than to protect those people from prejudice?
> You can always construct a credible argument for how any statement is "encouraging sentiment that does lead to real world violence and other harms"
People disagreed, so I gave these examples.
The alternative is that we accept that all arguments cause murder and must be banned.
This is why crying "Fire!!" in a crowded theater is not considered free speech.
Unfortunately again, there's no easy and decisive test to show what kind of utterance leads to direct harm, and what does not; this space is unavoidably nebulous. This is why it's often left for courts to decide on a case by case basis.
The US constitution guarantees that the government will not suppress free speech. But the US society needs to find mechanisms to channel speech on uncomfortable subjects so that it is not entirely suppressed and so the voices against the majority opinion can be heard, but also so that it's not leading to imminent violence and the loss of the rule of law. Without the rule off law, all free speech protections would be lost anyway.
To be precise, it _is_ considered protected free speech. For it to not be protected, the speaker has to _knowingly_ say it _falsely_.[1]
Also, this was only a hypothetical example from a SCOTUS case where an American was petitioning WW1 draftees to ignore/avoid the draft, which is far less of a black and white situation (a fire is an eminent danger to the people in the room, a war across the ocean is not), which reinforces your point.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_the...
I disagree with this mode of argument that you should not support some action A because someone might perform action A incorrectly or mistakenly.
You might have said if states were forbidden from holding slaves then that "exception" could be used to ban absolutely anything.
Man might be a reasoning animal, but his construction of belief is often not rooted in a rational search for truth.
Man might be a reasoning animal, but the words he chooses to speak are often motivated by the wielding of political power rather than an attempt at expressing his actual underlying beliefs.
Or, in modern vernacular, trolls exist and trolling is often quite effective. A good justification of free speech needs to start with realistic assumptions about how speech is used. That typically means abandoning the underlying assumption that the end goal of free speech is to enable a search for the truth. In fact, I really believe that once you start talking about the goal of free speech as a way of enabling search for the truth, censorship becomes a lot easier to justify.
This must be accompanied by a realistic assumption of how power is used. Wielding of political power (particularly tyrannical power) is nearly always accompanied by suppression of speech that expresses dissent.
Demagoguery may pollute a search for the truth, but nothing cements misinformation like a climate where people are prevented from saying true things.
But nobody can guarantee that most things people say are indeed true. So the "true things" limitation needs to be lifted, else it suppresses free speech all the same ("everybody knows Earth is flat, and humans were created less than 7000 years ago; please shut up and stop spreading disinformation").
Free speech is fundamentally about the machinations of power. Truth and sound reasoning are not unimportant per se, but they're certainly more instrumental than fundamental when it comes to the purpose of free speech.
Back in the 90s and early 2000s, people would censor things "because of the children". Nowadays, people censor things because "it's going to hurt me".
I believe in absolute free speech, even if it's wrong and it makes me nauseous hearing it. I believe that the truth and reason will convince the majority. You can't protect everyone, and you can't convince everyone. If you try to protect everyone, it's a slippery slope to fascism which is what we are seeing right now.
"We can't protect people without turning fascist" is a really rough take.
The problem is that "banning every thought or idea that hurts people" it has crossed over to just simple thoughts and discussions, which is wrong.
People need to be tougher. If you're "hurt" by an idea, then you are fragile. That's the whole point about talking, discussing, arguing and ultimately agreeing or disagreeing.
The example you mention is interesting because I think it is a good example of a statement that is both spread maliciously and foolishly. There has been both deep study and serious activism surrounding "black on black crime" yet this phrase persists because it is powerful ammunition from people who seek to persist white supremacy to convince people that people that activism is just whining and should be ignored. If you stood up in a Q&A session at a sociology conference on criminology and asked this you'd be outing yourself as truly ignorant of the field - the same as if you stood up in a Q&A session at an atmospheric science conference and asked "what about milankovitch cycles".
The heterodox academy tips their hand when they bring up examples of thoroughly discredited ideas as things that they should be able to force people to take seriously.
It sounds like people aren't even allowed to ask the question unless they wish to be fearful about their careers and livelihood. That is the definition of censorship of ideas.
And if someone were to ask a question that is ridiculous, is the answer to cancel them or to engage in a discussion and educate them? That is the essence of free speech.
No. The specific discussion of black-on-black crime is about the idea that nobody is discussing it, which is just false on its face. This is distinct from questioning whether black people are often the victims of crimes committed by other black people.
People are allowed to ask questions. I just ask two things.
1. That when somebody provides you with an answer, you stop asking the question.
2. That you recognize when a question has been weaponized as a means to dismiss activism and analysis rather than as a means to expand activism and expand analysis.
This is the same as my point about Milankovich cycles. They are real things. But "what about Milankovich cycles" is a weaponized idea among climate deniers designed to convince people that the experts haven't considered this, when they really have. Similarly, "what about black on black crime" is a weaponized idea designed to convince people that experts haven't considered this, when they really have.
Experts have concluded clearly that the existence and even high frequency of black-on-black crime absolutely does not dismantle claims about white supremacy and systemic racism. Similarly, experts have concluded clearly that the existence of Milankovich cycles does not dismantle claims about climate change and the role of carbon emissions.
So now we're taking the literal definition of "nobody", and using it to say that this is false. Personally, I'd feel comfortable saying "nobody is talking about cause X", if related cause Y was being talked about 100x more. Otherwise "nobody is talking about X" is always trivially false - by saying that, you are talking about it. But by the 100x standard... Yeah, nobody (right now) is talking about black-on-black crime, in comparison to white-on-black crime.
> Similarly, "what about black on black crime" is a weaponized idea designed to convince people that experts haven't considered this, when they really have.
> Experts have concluded clearly that the existence and even high frequency of black-on-black crime absolutely does not dismantle claims about white supremacy and systemic racism.
The problem with this argument - that this is a bad-faith question and it's been sufficiently addressed so shutup and stop asking - is twofold. First, many people will ask this due to not being familiar with those answers. Second, some people might think those answers are insufficient. Why not just link to the experts addressing it?
I'd truly encourage you to go engage with the literature and experts on this subject. You might find that your "100x" expectation is wildly inaccurate.
> Why not just link to the experts addressing it?
Because they are easy to find for people who are interested and spending time navigating the literature for people engaged in an intellectual denial of service attack is a waste of time. Same reason I stopped engaging with quacks causing trouble in my field of expertise.
Funny thing is, for the people asking that question (and IIRC literally the case that led to this discussion, which was an on-the-street-interview) they aren't looking at the academic literature - they're reading Vox, or watching CNN, or Fox, or reading the NYTimes. And I think that 100x is pretty accurate there.
> Because they are easy to find for people who are interested and spending time navigating the literature for people engaged in an intellectual denial of service attack is a waste of time. Same reason I stopped engaging with quacks causing trouble in my field of expertise.
"This is easy, and people ask me to do it often, but instead of doing it once and saving the results I just say 'educate thyself' and walk away"
Things that are easy for you - a person evidently up-to-date with the literature here - might be extremely difficult/impossible for someone who's not familiar, or who doesn't have free journal access.
You say this, but my wife is a historian and she and her colleagues get this crap thrown at them all the time. The "what about talking about black on black crime" meme is clearly being directed everywhere rather than specifically at the media. People use this phrase to specifically attack activists and academics.
If you want to criticize the media, great! Leftists aren't exactly big fans of the organizations you list. Just don't retreat to "its about the media" after criticizing other people.
> Things that are easy for you - a person evidently up-to-date with the literature here - might be extremely difficult/impossible for someone who's not familiar, or who doesn't have free journal access.
A core problem is that "wall of links" tends to not be productive. This isn't unique to fields like sociology. If somebody asked me about abstract interpretation and I just threw a bunch of Cousot papers at them it wouldn't be productive. The trick is to engage with people who can help you synthesize the literature and actually trust them. Look up the sociology faculty at a nearby university, find somebody who works in a thematically related field, and write them a letter.
I'm pro-free speech, but this is a pretty disingenuous take on the other side.
Pretty much without fail, the argument to restrict speech is not merely, "but they're wrong!", it's some variant of, "but they're harmful! Their speech is hurting people!"
And the truth is, quite often they're right. Not in the sense of "people's feelings are hurt by bad speech", but in the sense of, "this speech openly displayed encourages X, which is associated with actual, tangible harms to people". E.g. maybe that one racist dude isn't himself inciting anyone to violence through his screeds, but he's encouraging sentiment that does lead to real world violence and other harms.
One of the more understandable restrictions is the ban on Nazi imagery in Germany. Yes, it's a violation of free speech, but given their history one can see why they would consider this a special case.