The official editorial note makes no mention of this:
> An editors’ note posted late Friday noted factual inaccuracies and a “needlessly harsh” tone. “The essay fell short of our standards and should not have been published,” the note said.
In the end, criticisms of one for-profit newspaper aren't all that compelling to "free speech". In the same way we don't force a Christian church to allow any atheist to debate evidence against the existence of a god _in_ _a_ _church_, we don't force private companies to publish that which the company doesn't want to publish.
So long as the discussion is happening somewhere in society, I don't know that we must insist that _all_ conversations are happening _everywhere_.
So what? Are you saying those arguments aren't true? If so, of course you should make that counter-argument.
Or are you saying that even if they are true, it's more important to protect "mainstream conservative arguments" than to protect those people from prejudice?
> You can always construct a credible argument for how any statement is "encouraging sentiment that does lead to real world violence and other harms"
People disagreed, so I gave these examples.
The alternative is that we accept that all arguments cause murder and must be banned.
Just a few weeks ago a NYT op ed by senator Tom Cotton caused a staff revolt at the paper which got the editorial page editor fired, and a main argument was that publishing it threatened the lives of NYT employees.