FBI used Etsy, LinkedIn to make arrest in torching of Philadelphia police cars

Re:FBI used Etsy, LinkedIn to make arrest in torching of Phi... by MiguelHudnandez on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:58PM (#23558666)

We are down pretty deep into pedantry at this point, but... Current definition is that someone who has committed a crime and been convicted is a criminal. If that crime is a felony, they are also a felon. Depending on the state of residence, felons may have voting rights suspended, may be disqualified from jobs, loans, educational grants, etc.

You are right to point out that we usually use the noun "criminal" more to refer to someone that makes a habit of crime or makes their living from crime.

And I'll also add that the word "criminal" is often used to imply someone is subhuman. Possibly subconsciously, but it's common to see people outraged by police brutality only if they think an innocent person is the victim. Things like "no innocent person should be treated that way." I think this is the primary objective of the ever-present ad-hominem attacks such as "well he was no angel."

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:FBI used Etsy, LinkedIn to make arrest in torching of Phi... by throwawaygh on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:10PM (#23558736)

I don't think this is "deep into pedantry". I think it's probably one aspect of the most important conversation we need to have about the effect that "organizing the world's information" has on society.

The extraordinary permanence of certain aspects of identity ("criminal", "felon", "rapist", "racist", etc.) in the information age is radically different from how identity has worked for the past 100 years or so. The possibility of "starting over" is gone.

[ Parent | on HN ]