News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by tptacek on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:17PM (#2355620)
The fact that I agree with all of this just makes me sadder at how it was presented. Thanks for building a handy straw man for the methodology developers to attack.

I flagged this --- it's virtually content free --- but that's a futile gesture given how susceptible HN is to this particular form of social engineering.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by edw519 on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:41PM (#2355772)
...it's virtually content free...

Not if you run it through ReadBetweenTheLines().

Hey Thomas, lighten up. Normally I'd agree with you, but not today. This post hit me just right...

I'm having a shitty day. Really shitty. 6 levels deep into garbage that never should have been written, trying to add one little feature. Asking myself every 7 minutes if I have time to rewrite without shifting everything else out a week.

I just returned from my 5th candy bar break in the past two hours, wondering why I'm still a programmer. Honestly, today was one of those days when supermarket clerk actually started sounding good.

Then I read this post and suddenly found the energy to make it through the day. I'll strap some kludgy fix onto this shit, ship it out, have a beer, and all will be fresh tomorrow.

Frankly, I'd rather read one post to save my day than 50 to save the world. But that's just me, motherfuckers.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by charlief on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:47PM (#2355800)
I liked the article, I just hate the inconsistency here on HN when it comes to humorous/evocative submissions and comments. We scold some for violating the guidelines, and we bless others. Can we sometimes be more relaxed about what is submitted? If the answer is yes as you are indicating, can we make it this way all the time?

Ultimately the evolving community here will make the final judgement. I just feel that the guidelines can be adjusted to reflect what is acceptable.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by raganwald on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:58PM (#2355857)
We scold some for violating the guidelines, and we bless others.

That's really the curse of comedy. The whole point of comedy is to be subversive, to sneak in under the radar of "good taste" and "propriety." But it's hard to do that, a lot of the time it gets rejected out of hand, and it seems very inconsistent.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by charlief on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @03:42PM (#2356070)
Absolutely, HN has its fair share of inappropriate/bad jokes, but I think it happens more often because the guidelines are fairly agnostic.

Comedy is subversive, but the venue is usually not. When a comedian gives a routine on stage, the audience is primed and has certain expectations. When the audience's expectations are not aligned, it is bad for both the comedian and the audience.

My limited experiences on HN as a junior user have yielded a certain kind of fuzziness as to what is acceptable. On any given day, there is a lot of variance in the content, but usually HNish and that's a good thing. Officially, the guidelines are posted and they have an emphasis on intellectual stuff/tone, but leave evocative content unexplained. So the community decides, which is usually sporadic, hap-hazard, heavily-dependent on who posted the submission (people have expectations about what Zed Shaw is going to say), and the touchiness of the content. This probably doesn't happen in other communities that are more clearly guided as either relaxed or strict.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by ebiester on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @04:24PM (#2356297)
That's easy. It's the Picasso rule -- follow the rules until you understand how to break them.

It is true that you are given more slack when your name is known. Think of it as a corollary to the Picasso rule -- others have to know that you know the rules before you are given more leeway on how to break them.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by dasil003 on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @05:21PM (#2356568)
Back in the everything2 days, this was a meme caled "Earn your Bullshit", which they then subsequently expunged from the record because once too many people "earned their bullshit" they realized the proliferation of bullshit was destroying the site.

The bottom line is that humour is easy to upvote, and in-jokes are easy to accumulate in any online community, and so we must be ever vigilant. There's nothing wrong with humour now and again, but it requires ongoing, active rejection, and yes, a bit of hypocrisy to avoid becoming Reddit, where every single story has a contentless pun-filled thread 20 levels deep with a reputation of 1000 at the top falling off logarithmically.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by davidw on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @04:20PM (#2356277)
> My limited experiences on HN as a junior user have yielded a certain kind of fuzziness as to what is acceptable.

I think that's a good thing. It keeps people on their toes, rather than trotting out the same stupid jokes time and time again. I'll vote for something that's funny in a unique way, but downvote anything smacking of a stupid meme that's been done to death.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by runjake on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @05:35PM (#2356625)
But this isn't really funny. I know the comparison is highly frowned upon, but this thread reminds of Reddit. Or what I remember of it, anyway, back when I didn't mind wasting so much time.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by Aaronontheweb on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @06:23PM (#2356808)
There a lot of members on HN who take themselves, and HN itself, far too seriously.

Lighten the hell up - the message between the lines is that many programming teams are heavier on process than they need to be.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by jacoblyles on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @05:01PM (#2356470)
>>>Can we sometimes be more relaxed about what is submitted?

That path leads to http://www.reddit.com

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by CamperBob on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @06:56PM (#2356925)
And what's wrong with that? If I don't like what I'm reading on Reddit, I move on to the next comment, story, or subreddit.

Reddit does a better job at support a diverse community of interests and personalities than any single Web forum in the history of computing, IMHO. It could be the next Usenet if it received the funding and infrastructure it deserves.

I honestly do not get all the hating on Reddit that takes place on here.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by syaz1 on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @10:07PM (#2357583)
If you want Reddit, you go to Reddit. Why must HN become one?

I can't keep up with Reddit. Too much noise. Good you have time to. HN currently give ~80-100 RSS items daily to me which is good enough to keep me from surfing all day, and still keep up with latest tech news.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by tptacek on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @03:28PM (#2356015)
No retreat! No surrender! I'm here watching the battlements keeping the undesirable content out when you can't be. It's what's called "watching your back". I know you'd do the same for me! :|

I really do believe this stuff is a slippery slope. It makes the site worse. Just like yesterday's "Apple Says Yes" comment thread. But I made my snarky comment about it, hit my flag button, and now I'm done. I'm not out for a holy war.

On another note: sorry about your day.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by skunkworks on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @03:51PM (#2356119)
Yes. You are just as welcome to flag this as we are to vote this up, and then we can let democracy sort this out while we go Program, Motherfucker.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by davidw on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @04:19PM (#2356269)
"Democracy" would emphatically vote for funny cat pictures.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by billswift on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @08:05PM (#2357193)
That depends on the community doing the voting. Which is why I read here rather than Reddit.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by kirubakaran on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @05:31PM (#2356614)
"Tricia had just been to see Woody Allen's new movie which was all about the angst of being neurotic in New York. He had made one or two other movies that had explored the same theme, and Tricia wondered if he had ever considered moving, but heard that he had set his face against the idea. So: more movies, she guessed."

- Douglas Adams in "Mostly Harmless"

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by VladRussian on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @03:29PM (#2356026)
>I flagged this --- it's virtually content free

http://www.russianpaintings.net/articleimg/malevich/malevich...

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by zedshaw on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:18PM (#2355633)
Yeah, humor's so damn manipulative.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by VladRussian on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @03:36PM (#2356049)
yea, man. A little bit of pressure and you immediately "I'm just joking".
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by tptacek on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:21PM (#2355657)
See: XKCD.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by cachemoney on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:31PM (#2355725)
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by KirinDave on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @07:03PM (#2356965)
I wish there was a flag like flagging, but instead of "flag" it would say "Does Not Understand The Word Irony". Actually, I'd settle for just a "Wrong" badge.

I'd probably Wrong your post, then UnWrong it so I could Wrong it again.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by cachemoney on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @07:31PM (#2357091)
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/irony

5. an outcome of events contrary to what was, or might have been, expected.

6. the incongruity of this.

Seems fine to me.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by charlief on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:35PM (#2355753)
What irony?
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by jsn on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @07:09PM (#2356996)
I liked the piece, it made me smile. Also, I don't think it's inappropriate for HN -- why, we need things like that now and then.

But the fact that this link has 700 upvotes and so many comments makes me cringe. All those talks about HN quality getting worse -- I was never sure if I agree. I am now.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by moogatronic on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:22PM (#2355669)
I'm not sure how this is content free. It's offering up a gateway to a discussion/criticism of a lot of crufty-methodologies. Opinionated and vulgar maybe, but it is still about software, hacking, and maybe even business.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by scott_s on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:35PM (#2355747)
I don't expect to see much civil or useful discussion in this thread. I haven't so far.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by tptacek on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:26PM (#2355692)
If it wasn't plain as day that Zed was serious about this, (a) I wouldn't be voted as high as it was, and (b) I wouldn't have commented on it.

I just wish he hadn't built a caricature.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by zedshaw on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:29PM (#2355721)
Yeah, I'm totally serious about it with that picture of Samuel L. Jackson right at the top. Totally dead serious. Going to start the conference tomorrow.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by tptacek on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @03:15PM (#2355947)
Apart from the picture of Sam Jackson and some but not all of the words "motherfucker" on this page, which part of this post do you not believe?

Note: we're just nerding out. I'm reacting to your attempt to imply that that this is entirely or even mostly a joke. I don't really care. And, like I said, to the extent that it's not a joke, I agree with it.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by jedsmith on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:34PM (#2355743)
You dismiss the power of Samuel L. too quickly. If anything, he made it more serious.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by bch on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @03:33PM (#2356043)
The truest truths are said in jest.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by yakto on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @03:08PM (#2355901)
And I'll buy a ticket today.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by ascendant on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @02:35PM (#2355752)
MotherFuckerCon 2011. It's a bunch of Agile coaches all standing around in circles passing rubber ducks to each other waiting for their turn to talk about what they're going to do...someday.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by dkarl on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @05:06PM (#2356498)
It's about yak shaving as applied to process. (Assuming you read between the lines, as edw519 suggested.)

Yak shaving means getting deep into a series of tasks that are apparently unrelated to your final goal, but which logically follow from it: http://sethgodin.typepad.com/seths_blog/2005/03/dont_shave_t...

When you're shaving a yak, it might be a productive step whose necessity is not apparent until you analyze the problem. However, the term is usually employed when you feel logically compelled to do something, but your intuition tells you that it isn't necessary. You trust your intuition more, but you feel compelled to shave the yak anyway because there's a logically compelling argument for shaving the yak, and you can't justify not shaving the yak.

Yak shaving as applied to process means things like the Dilbertesque meeting to define the goals for choosing the committee to comment on the draft of the process to change the process. Logically, if you believe in the value of process, changing your process is an important thing and can't be done without process. Process requires buy-in, so you need a public draft of the process before it can be adopted. Obviously, the comments of random stakeholders won't automatically assemble themselves into coherent feedback, so you need a committee of representatives from different process stakeholders to compile the feedback. Choosing the committee is a politically sensitive task, so it should be done transparently, and the choices must be justified. So let's get together to define objective goals for choosing the committee members to head off any hard feelings.

Somewhere that chain of logic must be interrupted. No, we don't need any meetings, we don't need any documentation of goals, we don't need a list of stakeholders, and we don't need to produce a public draft for review. We can just do it and it will be fine. Maybe that comes at the top level -- we don't need a process to change the process -- or maybe you stop at a lower level -- okay, we need a documented process to change the process, but we don't need to publish a formal draft and get feedback.

You can't logically justify doing something without any process. You can always imagine things that can go wrong, and you can always imagine more layers of process to prevent those things from going wrong. You could justify an absence of process by performing an evaluation of the risks involved in proceeding without process, but that itself would be a layer of process.

At some point you have to stop trying to mitigate risk and JUST DO IT. At that point it may be helpful to pretend you're Jules from Pulp Fiction and toss around a few "motherfuckers" so you feel bad-ass enough to face the awesome responsibility of, say, choosing a meeting room without consulting a committee and without even articulating a reason for not consulting a committee. That last part is what makes it completely bad-ass, because you aren't even pretending to be responsible. You don't give a FUCK. You're going to choose that motherfucking meeting room for that motherfucking meeting, and you aren't going to explain how, and any motherfucker who wants you to explain how you chose that motherfucking meeting room can talk to your motherfucking balls, and if he can't pull his head out of his motherfucking asshole to find them you will stick them in there so he can chat with them at his motherfucking leisure.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by janm on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @08:35PM (#2357305)
Yes.

I have seen many projects fail in big companies because management are frightened of programming. The "risk mitigation" is using large teams of people with the right "skillset" who don't need to think very much because they are doing things according to the "industry best practice" using expensive third party software so that the in-house programmers don't have to make hard decisions.

If you work in an environment like that, and you're reading this, you are probably part of the problem because you are keeping the stupidity alive by struggling through the process and letting management get something delivered. Best to step away from the stupidity and let it fail.

Now I'm going to go and do some programming.

Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by dmoney on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @07:24PM (#2357060)
You could always write your own, more politely worded, manifesto.
Re:The Motherfucking Manifesto For Programming, Motherfuckers by lawnchair_larry on Tuesday March 22, 2011 @04:07PM (#2356215)
Flagged ---- seriously?

With a title containing 'motherfucker' ----- you should have known it wasn't totally serious.