News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:41PM (#23541842)
So now there are new slightly faster processors for three Ryzen 3000 processors, two of them were always a bad deal so far and that won't change with a few MHz more. A "faster" 3900X is nice of course, the 3900X was already nice, but without the cooler this is effectively a big price increase for virtually no gain. All while making AMDs sku lineup more confusing. What an unnecessary release.

I hope that benchmarks prove me wrong here, but I doubt it.

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by Nursie on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:53PM (#23541991)
Why were the 3600X and 3800X a bad deal?

With higher TDP they achieve higher sustained speeds than the 3600/3700X. A further boost at the same price point seems a good plan. Presumably the non-T parts are superseded by these.

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:03PM (#23542101)
Because they are not significantly faster in practice. The higher TDP does not help as much as you would think. Gamersnexus called it "paying for the letter X"[0]. I see the same in my meta benchmark in games especially[1], but also in apps[2]. There are differences, but if you are not in a situation where every single inch of performance counts that's not worth the higher price. It's not like that's just a few cents.

And now you have a price increase of $50 (for a good air cooler) to $100 (if you follow AMDs advice of buying a 280mm AIO) on the 3800XT. Makes the deal a lot worse for most, if there are not hidden performance advantages not visible so far.

[0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PAGQwWDyURI (I think that was here, might have been for the 3600X)

[1]: https://www.pc-kombo.com/us/benchmark/games/cpu/compare?ids%...

[2]: https://www.pc-kombo.com/us/benchmark/apps/cpu/compare?ids[]...

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by Nursie on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:14PM (#23542256)
There's a fairly small performance increase, around 4% sure, but the price difference is only about 10% in the UK at present. yhese XT processors increase it a little more at the same price point.

Really not sure what there is to complain about...

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:21PM (#23542352)
0% for the Ryzen 7 in games, 2% for the Ryzen 5s. In applications 2% and 4%. Might differ a bit with a different benchmark selection, but that's the gist. 10% higher price for that is already bad.

> These XT processors increase it a little more at the same price point.

Only for the Ryzen 5s (and the 3600XT could come out a bit better looking). For the Ryzen 7s the price point is not the same, you have to factor in the cooler you have to buy now. That will make the offer even less attractive.

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by Nursie on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:39PM (#23542566)
>0% for the Ryzen 7 in games

The CPU is less and less relevant for gaming. The reviews I've seen put it out ahead consistently but only by a 1-2fps. And as you say, a few percent in applications. If you want those couple of percent then you'll pay a 10% higher price for it. Disproportionate but to me it's still a great value processor.

And also for me the price would be the same - AMD's wraith cooler was noisy and I ditched it ASAP on both the 3700X and 3800X we have in the house here. They're in boxes in the attic so pretty much have negative value.

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:47PM (#23542655)
> The CPU is less and less relevant for gaming

I wouldn't say that. We had a couple of very cpu heavy game releases recently, and with new console generations that usually makes a jump.

And you can get a bigger performance jump in games - with Intel.

> The reviews I've seen put it out ahead consistently but only by a 1-2fp

Right, rounds down to 0%.

> Disproportionate but to me it's still a great value processor.

No, by definition it's not a great value anymore if you pay that much more for that small gain, if you have equally fast alternatives after a minimal overclock.

You could have sold the Wraith cooler :) But that's a valid argument, for some the cooler inclusion or non-inclusion does not matter.

AMD won't do that change without a reason. They probably feel they are in the position for that now. They boosted the stock cooler importance for Zen 1 (that thing was great) gaining goodwill, then made it worse, now start to remove it completely. The infinite circle of corporate attention and customer focus in action.

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by Nursie on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:23PM (#23543010)
>And you can get a bigger performance jump in games - with Intel.

Which intel product is more capable than a 3700X at a lower price than a 3800X?

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:30PM (#23543079)
In games the 10600K[0]. And the 10400(F) is equally fast[1]. Outside of games the 3800X wins against those two, though the 10600K could keep up with it a bit better if we would look at its overclocked results.

[0]: https://www.pc-kombo.com/de/benchmark/games/cpu/compare?ids%...

[1]: https://www.pc-kombo.com/de/benchmark/games/cpu/compare?ids[...

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by Nursie on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @06:44PM (#23545224)
> In games the 10600K[0]. And the 10400(F)

2 fewer cores, that's a far worse deal.

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @06:49PM (#23545270)
Doesn't matter, if it's faster.
Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by Nursie on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @07:27PM (#23545610)
That's highly debatable.

It matters to me, I do a lot of parallel software builds. Two more cores makes a difference.

If you only game, that's one thing. I don't.

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @08:58PM (#23546423)
No, that's not debatable.

I was specifically talking about gaming, and mentioned in all my comments specifically what performance category I'm talking about when making performance claims.

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by Nursie on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:10AM (#23550909)
Actually if you go back to the top of the thread there are no such claims, just that the chips are not good value.

I'd argue that going forward the intel chips are going to hold their own less well in games too, with a lower core count, especially as the core count in consoles goes up.

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by delfinom on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @07:06PM (#23545437)
You do not want to ever use the stock cooler on the 3900X, it does work but at the cost of high fan RPM cool it and you'll want to stab your ears out from the fans ramping up and down cyclically every 15 seconds from the aggressive PBO bumps that translate to immediate temperature spikes and CPU fan ramp ups. You want some of the larger heatsinks available like the Dark Rock Pro which can suck up the heat without needing to spin up fans.
Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by Macha on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:02PM (#23546447)
Yeah, while AMD's stock coolers reviewed well on other CPUs, I went a few weeks with the wraith prism on a 3900x then decided it had to go.

Though if these are the same more efficient chiplet bins as the 3950x, maybe the prism would make more sense on a 3900xt. Given they're not including it though, I guess AMD didn't think so

Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by heelix on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:33PM (#23547076)
Same. The stock fan on the 3900x was a bit noisy - spinning up and down all the time. Replaced it with a closed loop water cooler after a couple weeks.
Re:AMD to Launch New Ryzen 3000 XT CPUs: Zen 2 with More MHz by reitzensteinm on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @06:25AM (#23549813)
I bought a 3900X and have a stock cooler on it, and have a Dark Rock Pro 4 sitting next to me which I purchased because the stock cooler was way too loud. If you build a PC with a high end Ryzen in it, you should listen to this advice.