News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by wegs on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:35PM (#23541106)
Rewrites only make sense if you get a multi-fold improvement. In the history of computing, that's rare. So they rarely make sense.

Well, JavaScript was really horrible when it came out. It was just about the worst major programming language ever made. It sort of reminds me of an interpreter I threw together for a programming language I invented when I was in high school, when I really didn't get any aspect of programming language design, and I based it on a misunderstanding of Lisp.

Given its central role, lots of people used JavaScript, and lots of smart people tried to fix it. Every few years, it'd get a lot better. It actually made sense to rewrite everything -- you got that multi-fold improvement in productivity going 1995 JS to 2000 JS, 2005 JS to 2010 JS, and so on. I mean, with each iteration, it was still obnoxiously bad, but it was that much less bad.

It looked like an exponential growth curve for a while, but you always knew it was an S-curve -- you hit an inflection point when you reach the level of competently-designed programming languages.

At some point in the past five years, JavaScript stopped being really bad. I mean, it's no Python, but it's at least within spitting range. Heck, it's better than Java. I won't even lose 2x productivity writing in JavaScript over best-of-breed languages, at least core language (ecosystem aside -- there is no numpy/scipy/pylab -- but that will come too).

With that, rewrites every five years no longer make sense. Unless there's some fundamental progress in computing, I expect JavaScript code I write today may still be used in 20 years. That's not something I would have said in 2010 or 2000.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by mettamage on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:07PM (#23541460)
How about using Typescript? That still seems like a huge improvement, especially because you can implement it incrementally (aka for parts of code where type checking is vitally important).

I'm using it now at my work and I'm surprised how much info I'm getting compared to whatever JS is throwing at me.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by wegs on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:51PM (#23542691)
TypeScript? Erm... Not for me.

There were many such systems in the past. CoffeeScript was a big improvement over 2010 JavaScript. Before that was GWT, which was sooo much nicer than 2006-era JavaScript. I could list a bunch of others. If you used any of them, you're now stuck with a legacy system(+), and you'll find fewer and fewer people able to read/write your code, and otherwise.

I'm also not a big fan of static typing. And if you do static typing, you should at least do it properly, which is not what TypeScript does.

Types should be things like "This is an integer between 0 and 100," "Meters/second," or similar. We've known this for a long time. Ada is now 40 years old and was mandated for military work since if you added feet and inches without a conversion, that was a problem, and that resulted in more robust systems (TypeScript would make them both of type "number" and never catch the error). If you tried to have 120% of your fuel tank full, you'd violate an assertion as well. Those were turned on in dev and in your test suite (but generally turned off in your deployment system, which was running on a 33MHz CPU if you were lucky).

C++ templates let you define things like "This is a list of lengths, in meters." Duck types languages like Python won't do this statically, but it's easy enough to do dynamically; while you won't catch errors at compile-time, at run-time, you'll get a clear exception.

(+) Standard disclaimers apply.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by rowanG077 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @06:27PM (#23545069)
Dependently typed language can check at compile time if you violate a ranged integer value among many other things.

I'm curious though why you are not a fan of static typing? I feel like if you have a language with inference it's pretty good. I mean you could imagine python with type inference and you could essentially write anything in it you can today (baring stuff like heterogenous data structures) without specifying the type manually.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by wegs on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @08:15PM (#23546044)
(1) I like generic code which I can use as I see fit later. In Scheme, I can write:

(lambda (x) (* x (+ 3 x)))

A half-decade later, someone can take that code, pass a pair of specially-crafted objects to it to introspect what it does, and take a symbolic derivative, pretty-print that derivative with LaTeX, combine it with a few other pieces, and compile it into native code (and yes, that does happen).

But a lot of my code is generic in a way where types get in the way.

(2) If I do have typing, the type should usually be specified manually, but it should have semantic meaning, not be based on inferring whatever types my programming language happens to have built-in. What's important isn't that something is an integer, but that it's a count-of-apples. I should be able to compare a count-of-apples to a count-of-oranges without first converting them to a count-of-fruit.

This is especially important for numerical code, and especially in education. A lot of Scratch tutorials have little kids add a velocity to a position, without first multiplying it by a time. That leads to deep-rooted misconceptions.

I don't mind type inference if it's designed to give me feedback. I've seen a few systems (designed for students) which do things like take JavaScript:

let x=5;

let y="hello";

let z=x+y;

And flag that in the IDE. That's kinda nice. And obviously, many systems do optimization at runtime based on inferred types. That's not a problem either.

So there's a fuzzy layer in between. But the discussion was about TypeScript, not that fuzzy layer.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by rowanG077 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @08:38PM (#23546252)
I don't really see how the first example is incompatible with static types. Most often type inference infers the most general type possible. That means you can do exactly the same things with that lambda in a statically types language as in a dynamic language.

The second example with count of apples and oranges is bad. Those are unitless and a thus Just an natural should be fine for them. Numerical code can get messy but that's exactly were the power of static typing is the best. You can have dimensions and units in a type system and you get dimensional homogeneity correctness for free.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by wegs on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:10PM (#23546509)
I agree that well-designed type systems can be helpful, and in an ideal case, I'd have a mix. It's just that TypeScript is not that. The gap between the types of type systems you're describing and TypeScript is the Grand Canyon.

re: type inference

Inferential type systems fall into a fuzzy zone between statically and dynamically typed. For example, many JITs for dynamically typed languages do type inference, and generate compiled code optimized to the types actually being used. That's a very obviously good idea. And many linters look at inferred types as well to do compile-time checks. That's also an obviously good idea. But I wouldn't call a JavaScript JIT a statically-typed system (or Python code that's been through Pylint).

re: Apples versus oranges

They're not unitless. In the first case, the units are apples. In the second case, they're oranges. You shouldn't compare or add those types. If I do have a type system, that's something I should be able to specify.

Not to mention implicit conversions, if I want them (12 inches + 1 foot = 24 inches).

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by rowanG077 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:20PM (#23546579)
Well yeah typescripts typing sucks but that's not my point. Type inference falls squarely in the static typing camp. It has nothing to do with dynamic typing.

Take a look at the Haskell units library. That can do the things you illustrate.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by gfodor on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:24PM (#23541661)
Typescript doesn't strike me as a multi-fold improvement. Dynamic vs static typing is an age-old debate, and in general, advocates can be found arguing that moving your code in either direction results in benefits. So, regardless of your stance on it, it seems unlikely to be unambiguously beneficial. Many large programs exist written in dynamic languages that do just fine.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by throwaway894345 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:12PM (#23542227)
It seems like it's trending toward static, at least recently. I think the big driver for this is the popularization of statically typed languages that aren't C++ and Java. A lot of people had painful experiences with C++ and Java and attributed that pain to static typing. It's now more clear that static typing is a net benefit, but it must be implemented reasonably and it doesn't solve other language design issues. Also, C++ and Java have each evolved some rudimentary type inference, which improves ergonomics (although I think excessive type inference a la Haskell actually makes it harder to debug issues--the sweet spot seems to be function-scoped type inference).
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by gfodor on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:20PM (#23542341)
Hard to say. It seems as cyclic as anything else. Hard to tease apart real benefit from the usual fad/hype cycles.

Ruby, Python, Erlang/Elixir, Lisp/Clojure, etc, all doing just fine without it. (Some, with some lightweight annotative-oriented typing for a subset of projects.)

The best counterargument to static typing I can articulate is that in general, the only way to be sure software works is to run it. And so, ultimately you need to backstop your software with testing, QA, and observability infrastructure to actually execute it and validate it. At that point, the question is what marginal gains remain from catching a subset of those problems at complile time, also incorporating a potential a false sense of security which may lead to less actual execution validation, and more user-facing issues. The other potential tradeoff of static typing is if the software design and architecture changes for better or worse, or if the velocity of shipping changes changes. I believe there isn't yet any hard evidence of which way this tilts in either case.

There's also a lot of innovation in the area of validation-by-execution as well, and so I think that will result in continual debate: state-of-the-art static typing may benefit compared to yesterday's testing/fuzzing tools, but may not compared to state-of-the-art testing/fuzzing tools, for example.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by throwaway894345 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:00PM (#23546880)
Python is trending toward types via support for type annotations. My extensive experience with Python and Go leads me to the conclusion that it’s very difficult to write even moderately complex and maintainable Python code at scale. This doesn’t mean that no one can make money with Python—far from it—only that they would make even more money via Go (iterate faster and spend less time fixing bugs). Of course this can’t necessarily be extended to other languages. C++ and Rust would not be as productive up front than Python and C++ would probably not save you any time fixing bugs. A lisp might be faster to develop in than Go and Python without incurring too many type errors. There are too many variables to make sweeping statements, but all else equal, in my experience, static typing is better than dynamic typing. But again, there are many other variables that can cause a dynamically typed language to outperform a statically typed language for iteration velocity or bug reduction.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by pacala on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @06:38PM (#23545166)
One of the greatest boons of static typing is formal documentation of data structures and interfaces. Catching errors early is a bonus :)
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by mercer on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:32PM (#23546681)
I'm not disagreeing per se, but at least in the Elixir community I get the impression that using Dialyzer (the wonderfully cryptic TS-ish gradual typing solution) and typespecs is increasingly advised and there's a thirst for a better solution. But static typing comes up a lot.

We're doing fine without, but it's definitely a sore point and I'm one of those developers who has become more and more fond of static typing.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by oalae5niMiel7qu on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @04:55AM (#23549299)
The trend toward static typing is a fad, like NoSQL in the early 2010s. Who knows what the next fad will be. Perhaps correctness proofs will make a comeback.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by mettamage on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @04:17PM (#23543558)
Yea, this is why I posted it. To me it seems:

- Small codebase. Fine, use both.

- Medium codebase. Fine, use both.

- Large codebase. You're definitely going to have some typing bugs with dynamically typed languages.

- Humongous codebase. You're definitely going to have many typing bugs with dynamically typed languages.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by throwaway894345 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @04:40PM (#23543802)
I'll say that we have a small-medium code base and we see lots and lots of dynamic typing errors in production every day. I would also say "even though we have lots of people who are experienced Python developers", but I think it's actually because we have so many developers who have only developed seriously in dynamically typed languages and don't "think in types" if you will.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by blackrock on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:04PM (#23546463)
Can’t you write the Python functions to force check the input parameter for its type? And error out if not.

This should enable you to catch most errors immediately during development.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by throwaway894345 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:26PM (#23547039)
No, this doesn’t help at all. You only hit these errors if you run those paths in your tests, but those paths would already error downstream. Those paths that weren’t tested may still contain errors that go to production, and again you just hit your new type error instead of the downstream type error.

What you need is something that can help you test more paths, and static type checking checks all paths. Further, they can check all paths without writing any tests (you should still have tests, but you need fewer with a static type system to keep your bug rate the same). Moreover, static type checkers catch errors almost immediately, so you get feedback about your errors sooner rather and more frequently, so you spend less time investing in code that will have to be rewritten. Lastly, they put rails on the code—it’s harder to write bad code including gratuitously magical or abstract code, so your coworkers aren’t writing as much bas code that you have to interface with. If you find static type systems to be frustrating, you’re probably the problematic coworker. :)

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by blackrock on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @01:10AM (#23548039)
I don’t disagree with you. Python seems to encourage poor development practices. Basically, anything goes. This can be problematic if you use other people’s libraries, and if their libraries are not fully vetted.

This is not a Python problem, per se. It is a developer problem. It is a human problem.

However, with your own code and libraries, you can enforce your own rigor. Keep your functions smaller, test all the inputs, and validate all the outputs. Although you may end up with smaller production code, but more unit tests.

The unit tests are good, as they give you evidence that you did cover those corner cases.

However, the good thing, is that if the functions are smaller, and well unit tested, then it becomes rare that you have to modify it at a later date. And especially if you think through all the different angles, and try to future proof it. Now you have the ability to do functional composition. Just keep chaining the outputs of one function into another.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by mixmastamyk on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:18PM (#23546569)
Yes, but easier to just write tests.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by throwaway894345 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:27PM (#23547043)
And easier still just to use static types.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by mixmastamyk on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @01:52PM (#23554437)
Often not, if the overhead of adding them outweighs their utility for the project.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by gfodor on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:02PM (#23546443)
well, sure. certainly one of the costs of a dynamic language is the possibility of typing bugs, and those will likely grow linearly with the size of the code base.

the question is if those programs were written in statically typed languages, how the world would differ, in-full. for example, they may have been built faster or sloer. or they may have better or worse test coverage, affecting severe defect count overall. or you may have had to hire a different team, with tradeoffs. hard to say.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by nisten on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:47PM (#23541917)
I would avoid doing state management in Typescript. It's still too early in my opinion.

Use as many hooks and context as possible and keep your redux store as simple as you possibly can because if you end up with a deprecated state management library (redux-thunk, sagas, easy-peasy) replacing that is like pulling gum out of hair.

If you add up the time spent working around typescript errors when dealing with state, it's possible for it to be more time than you need to rewrite the entire app.

For backend work then yes, I'd say doing a singleton or an abstract class in typescript makes more sense in hardening your API code and even making it more readable too.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by acemarke on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:36PM (#23542542)
I'm a Redux maintainer, and I'm _strongly_ in favor of using TypeScript for any meaningful app development [0] [1].

Also, I don't know why you're referring to thunks and sagas as "deprecated". Thunks are the recommended default approach for async logic in Redux [2], and we include them out of the box in our Redux Toolkit package [3]. While most apps don't need sagas, they're a great power tool to have in your toolbox. Neither of those is in any way "deprecated".

[0] https://blog.isquaredsoftware.com/2019/11/blogged-answers-le...

[1] https://redux.js.org/style-guide/style-guide#use-static-typi...

[2] https://redux.js.org/style-guide/style-guide#use-thunks-for-...

[3] https://blog.isquaredsoftware.com/2020/02/blogged-answers-wh...

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by nisten on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:10PM (#23546510)
Sorry I meant as in an older version of a library that an app has been built on and hasn't been updated or maintained for a few months.

I should have put that better, the libraries themselves are not deprecated, their dependencies can be.

While this negligence problem would be on the fault of the dev team and management for not doing regular package updates it is an all too common issue in many companies.

What I am saying is that bad typescript is harder to fix than bad javascript because type errors compound the problems of convoluted code.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by kqr on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:32PM (#23542496)
In my opinion, if you're going to add a compilation stage to your bundling anyway, you can get far more mileage out of other options (such as Fable) than the tiny improvement TypeScript is.

The additional compilation complexity is not worth the small benefits of TypeScript, in my opinion. An even better language, though? I'm in.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by mettamage on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @04:19PM (#23543567)
Never heard of Fable, will check it out! :D
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by pacala on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @06:36PM (#23545144)
Typescript greatest features are optional types and the extensive type inference. On small projects this can work well, but on larger ones I can see overly rigid style guides requiring typing everything explicitly in triplicate becoming cumbersome in an Enterprisey way. Curious what people's experiences are.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by mercer on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:18PM (#23546570)
Typescript, for me, makes JS jump from 'good enough' to 'might use it even if I have other options'.

I still prefer using other languages when I can (back-end), but hypothetically, if I had to choose between Ruby and Typescript I'd actually go for the latter. And I like Ruby!

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by nwienert on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:23PM (#23541645)
Typescript is leagues ahead of Python. Types and async/await are the big ones, but destructuring, no lambda weirdness, optional chaining, nullish coalescing, proxies, JSON support, and generally debugging tools are all better.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by throwaway894345 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:09PM (#23542187)
I'm not well-versed in TypeScript, and I have plenty of frustrations in Python so it's not that I don't believe you, but I do have a few questions:

* Python has async/await. It's not as pleasant as goroutines, but it exists and is presumably about as pleasant as async/await in TS, at least assuming you're using or not using the type system in both cases.

* Python has tuple/list/iterable destructuring. What is the specific limitation here? Maybe key/value destructuring?

* What's python's lambda weirdness? The single expression limitation? I agree that's tedious, albeit you can do a lot with a single expression (but not handling exceptions).

* JSON support. What's wrong with Python's JSON support? I mean, the type system can't model recursive types yet and that's super annoying, but the JSON stdlib seems fine. JSON maps pretty neatly onto Python dict/list/str/int/float/None/etc types.

* What are proxies and why are they desirable? Genuinely curious.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by nwienert on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:14PM (#23542263)
Python has some async, but it never felt as core and easy.

Tbh, it’s been years since I’ve done much Python. But the last time I did it was just really clear that TS had leapt ahead. Ecosystem may be part of it.

Proxies are essentially meta programming tools, tbh not fully sure Python doesn’t have similar but on looking they don’t seem as intuitive.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by throwaway894345 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @04:49PM (#23543909)
As previously mentioned, I'm a Python critic, but it has changed a lot since you last used it. Async (for better or worse) has gained a lot of traction as have type annotations (although the type checker is a huge pain--can't model JSON or any other recursive type, can't express a callback that takes kwargs, getting it to acknowledge type stubs on upstream libraries is a forbidden art, it's pretty slow, etc).

No doubt that TS is better, however. It has amazing engines, an MS-backed developer experience, coherent type system, not the worst package management ecosystem, etc. If I could switch us off of Python to any language, I would choose Go but I wouldn't be angry if we landed on TS.

Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by DaiPlusPlus on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @07:31PM (#23545640)
Proxies are a feature in ECMAscript that TypeScript inherits - it lets you substitute one object for another so you can intercept and override object properties.
Re:Do Not Follow JavaScript Trends by pacala on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @06:42PM (#23545202)
Having used both Python and Typescript recently, I largely prefer the consistency of Typescript. [Hey mom, I like cherries better than strawberries]. Having said that, I'd love to have named function arguments in Typescript. Props workaround is, well, a workaround.