Aren't colleges looking for people who will study the most? Who have the motivation and the ability for the motivation to translate into results?
Dunno about you, but even if this is true, something that shows you were highly motivated and took time to do something seems very valuable if your goal is to produce people what produce.
In most areas of study, being motivated and investing time are key contributors to success. They aren't the only one. Intelligence, diversity of thought and resources matter too, but they certainly aren't negligible or dismissible.
I was under the impression that SAT prep doesn't move the needle much. Am I mistaken?
I have seen scores improve 100-200 points per skill on average for middle range scores, and 50-100 points per skill for higher range scores with quality preparation.
Reasons:
- familiarity with test format
- improved test taking strategies
- familiarity with test content
- developing the mental stamina to perform at a high level throughout the relatively long test
- lowered anxiety and (often) increased confidence
The college board says that an SAT is better predictor of success in college than GPA, which based on my experience of American high schools makes sense. I get that wealth probably has a positive correlation to both. But it seems that should matter a little.
Is this data or anecdata? You be the judge. He finds it easy to bank on professionally.
I encourage you to talk to someone who has worked at a high-end SAT training program (not Kaplan or that type). They can tell you the real deal, both successes and failures. Don’t rely on talking to the businesses themselves, because they will be selling their services rather than telling the complete truth (unless you know them personally).
Fwiw, failures are usually due to one of a few factors:
1. anxiety
2. learning blocks
3. physical issues (e.g., lack of sleep, sick, etc.).
But if you get put in the “honors” track of a lot of high schools where the name of the game is to teach material informed by the SAT, ACT, AP, and IB teats then you almost can’t help but do well since you’ve been cramming for 4 years.
That's not called cramming. It's called "learning". It means the test is working as intended.
You could say the same for pretty much every educated person who has done an undergraduate or postgraduate degree. Seems like a lot of human progress has been made as the result of people that have been "cramming for 4 years"
Test scores don’t prove much except who had the resources, time, and motivation to study the most. You could replace the SAT and ACT with obscure movie trivia and you’d see roughly the same distribution of scores and it would have the same predictive power. The people who signal that they’re willing to put it a lot of time, money, and effort into their education do well… surprised pikachu.
There’s no such thing as qualified for college outside of a genuine desire and motivation to do it.
So I don’t see any sort of contradiction in colleges admitting people based on novelty, coolness, and straight-up effort.