News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:15AM (#23539380)
I don't really understand the positive opinion around this. Isn't the break from the Windows and Linux default architecture and thus software too high here? Like in gaming - are Apple users really okay with not having access to a single Steam game?

Okay, the ones using this only for ~~work~~ office work, the browser and Netflix won't mind, but for the rest this presents a huge separation from what is available elsewhere. I must miss something.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by burlesona on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:55AM (#23540666)
I game on Mac, and I’m not excited about losing access to Steam. But I have a 2018 MBP and I probably wouldn’t upgrade for a few years yet anyway.

Depending on how the announcement and rollout goes I could see myself buying one of the last intel 16” MacBooks, or just being content with my 2018, and either way not upgrading for a while.

I suspect that if the transition is “successful,” the first year or two on ARM will include a few noticeable trade offs, but those will quickly be “washed away” by a substantial performance gap where Apple’s hardware is just a LOT better than everyone else.

And if the transition is “unsuccessful,” well, I may end up finally buying a gaming PC... or just deciding I don’t care about the small handful of PC games I play and sticking to console.

Gaming on Mac has been second class for.... ever, so I would say anyone who really cares already has a windows machine.

But one last thought, keep in mind that while the quality of games is somewhat lower, the quantity on iOS is off the charts, including many games with high end graphics.

In a weird twist of fate, it’s possible that Apple’s decision to merge its desktops and laptops into the same architecture as its mobile phones actually increases the total addressable market so much that game makers are _more_ interested in doing the small amount of extra work it would take to make a game work on Mac as well as iOS. This happened when Firaxis started making Civ for iOS and then ended up updating the Mac version to use Metal, and when they did the performance was worlds better.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by samcat116 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:42PM (#23541177)
Here's a counter point to this argument: take Fortnite for example. Its arguably the most popular game on the world. The current Mac version runs fine but not great. They could modify the iPad version (probably pretty easily) and get better performance on these new ARM Macs than the x86 version was ever going to be due to Apple refusing to put in great gaming GPUs.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by _bxg1 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:37AM (#23539616)
Very few people use Macs for gaming, and many of those that do probably just play Apple Arcade games (which I'm sure will have a smooth upgrade path). And most of the games people play that are on Steam are (these days) built with either Unity or Unreal, which will no doubt have 1-click-rebuilds for the new architecture. In Unity your game logic doesn't even need to compile to native code.

Even beyond games, the thing is that nearly every development platform these days is an abstraction above the hardware - be it the JVM, the web browser, etc - and the rest (of the new ones coming out) are built to be cross-platform from the get go. Just look at how smoothly Rust/Cargo can target different architectures. I'm sure the same is true for Go.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:15AM (#23540119)
> And most of the games people play that are on Steam are (these days) built with either Unity or Unreal, which will no doubt have 1-click-rebuilds for the new architecture.

I highly doubt that. The architecture difference is too big, and gaming studios are not known to press that button even if it's available. The native Linux gaming support story speaks to that. That they will port existing games is even more unlikely.

Will be funny to re-read that comment in the future, be it right or wrong.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by xigency on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:38PM (#23543182)
The entire draw of Unity and Unreal is that they target all platforms. With regards to Linux, Epic Games has released their games for Linux in the past. There is no commercial incentive to release games for Linux, though. The game engines will support Mac ARM if game developers require that feature, and game developers will target Mac ARM if there is a commercial case for it.

The existence of gaming on Mac I think is largely due to companies that support it by choice, like Blizzard, and I don't see why they would abandon the platform due to a CPU architecture change.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @05:03PM (#23544082)
I disagree with almost everything in this comment.

Unity and Unreal do not only exist for their multiplatform target, but because they are premade engines to make games with in general. Many games made with them support one single platform.

There is absolutely a commercial incentive to release Linux games. Developers would not do it otherwise, or at least they would have stopped after one try. They did not.

I highly doubt that Blizzard supports MacOS out of goodwill, and I doubt even more that if it was based on that, they could easily continue doing so after a cpu architecture change. They'd have to port whole custom engines plus middleware. That would not happen in that case.

One thing I assume is correct: If there is money to be made here engine developers and game developers will make it happen. But I don't see why it would be that easy.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by simion314 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:37AM (#23540410)
Just giving you some data points, there are many people that play older games on their laptops, one such community is the Sims3 players, they got screwed when 32 bits support was dropped, some still hope EA will make a 64 bit soon (IMO it makes no sense for the devs to do the work for free for this old game).

So the people the play games on Mac are not the same group that play latest AAA shooters or arcade games, they are people that play some casual games or retro games on their laptops so no "hardcore gamers"

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by _bxg1 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @04:12PM (#23543480)
The story is admittedly different when we're talking about legacy games that are no longer supported. Even if pushing the button is easy, if there's nobody there to do it, that doesn't help.

But the good news it that game life cycles have gotten much longer; where in the past a game was seen as a fire-and-forget project, these days a game may get active updates for five or more years after launch. And not just AAA, but indies too.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by simion314 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @06:08AM (#23549720)
Sometimes we do not need updates, we need existing old games to continue to work. Ubuntu tried also to drop 32bit support but the community responded strongly with use cases like games and some other old apps, then Canonical/Ubuntu listen and 32 bit support was partially dropped, 32 libraries needed for games and different apps are still supported.

Meanwhile I see Mac players upset their 32 bit games no longer work (like the Sims3 players and I also see some Mac users in r/winegaming ). Again Apple can do whatever they make them more money but for example gamers voice was heard in Ubuntu/Linux and Canonical did the work (for free) to continue supporting gamers.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by sutterbomb on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:51AM (#23540604)
That’s not really “data points” in any useful sense of the word. The sim3 community could be a few thousand people - still large enough to be a community where this came up as a noticed issue, but not meaningfully large in any real sense as far as Apple is concerned.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by simion314 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:57PM (#23541344)
Sure, I don't say that Apple should do X op Y. I just wanted to present some example of people that game on Mac, because some people in this HN forum would think that gaming means only latest AAA games or console gaming. There are people that don't have a dedicated gaming device, they are not that many as percentages but they exist and they are affected by the 32 bit drop and other backward incompatibility updates.

So it is possible that this people when they buy a new laptop would not buy an ARM Mac buy a Windows one to continue playing the casual or old games - sure Apple can ignore them because as percentages is nothing for their giant vault of money.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by epistasis on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:48AM (#23539752)
I'm totally fine without having a single Steam game. Most Mac users didn't have access for many years, and I'm not sure that gaming is a big use case for Macs, at least historically. I would be interested to see if this has changed.

And most software that I depend upon is either 1) open source, or 2) developed for Mac first and foremost with a solid backup app that is open source. The one exception is Microsoft Office, whose Mac versions are second thoughts and second rate software, but necessary for collaboration with a world that has locked itself into closed formats. Office would likely get an Arm version for Mac too, I would think.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by georgeecollins on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:09AM (#23540035)
People always underestimate how important games are to PC sales, and Apple is traditionally the worst about this given their bicycle for the mind rhetoric. I don't think it is a coincidence that Apple laptops became very popular after you started being able to boot them in Windows to play a game. You got the benefit of MacOS, Apple hardware and PC game libraries.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by scarface74 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:37PM (#23541125)
I doubt very many people are buying Macs to run Windows games. Mac hardware doesn’t exactly come with the greatest GPUs.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:36PM (#23541798)
"How many people buy Macs to run Windows games" is the wrong question.

I don't buy computers just to read websites (I can do that more comfortably on an iPad), or just to write documents (ever heard of the FreeWrite[1]?), or just to play games (I'd rather use a game console). Rather, I buy a computer because it's a single device that can do all of those things.

I almost added "and switch between them seamlessly" to the end of the last sentence, but of course on a Mac with Bootcamp, that's the one exception—you have to reboot in order to play a game. Still, on a laptop, I consider the ability quite valuable—I don't want to carry around a second computer just to play a quick game of Spelunky from time to time. If I couldn't do that at all on a Mac, it would be a point in favor of Windows.

---

1: https://getfreewrite.com/

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by scarface74 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:08PM (#23542172)
And the casual game market is much larger and those are mostly on mobile. Besides, Apple will probably already have a large number of casual games via Apple Arcade.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by epistasis on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:17AM (#23540144)
I know a lot of people wi Th Macs, but they are all developers or scientists, and I've never known anybody to install Windows via boot camp! So I'm clearly not in this demographic. However I do wonder how large it is compared to the rest of the Mac userbase.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by geekles on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:06PM (#23541445)
Mac support in games is less important now than ever before. Services such as Shadow are how I game on my Mac now.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:13AM (#23540087)
I'm not so sure that generalizes. Steam has a huge userbase and according to https://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey, 4% of that is using MacOS. That's a big number - especially keeping in mind how much inferior MacOS is in gaming support compared to Linux, where almost everything works. I don't see that going well with the ARM switch.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by klohto on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:50PM (#23543282)
1) Let’s take the latest amount of active steam players per month, which is 90MM. That is a number for 2019, I will assume that it grew a little per the usual percentage it does (accounting for Covid) to 100MM. 4% is 4MM.

2) Macbook Pro & Macbook Air have a total share of 78%. I’m ignoring other models, since we are talking about ARM on notebooks, not towers. That brings the number of players to 3,1MM

3) We can assume that most people still rock macbooks since 2012. But let’s start counting from 2013. (We don’t have unit sales, but only the total amount, so I work with the amount that most websites quote) Apple, on average, sells 18MM Macs per fiscal year. Till today, that is 135MM Macs the market.

4) We need to estimate the amount of Macbooks vs Macs, but I cannot find a single stat on this. I’m gonna pull this out of my ass and say that it’s around 90%. The Macs have always been supplemental to Macbooks and Apple has been “forgetting” about them a lot. This brings the total to 121,5MM

5) That is 2,56% of people who game on Macbook. I would say Apple doesn’t care about ~3%. This stat also doesn’t account for hardcore vs casual players. Eq. Those who won’t care vs those who will switch platforms.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by cwhiz on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:39AM (#23539633)
Gaming on Apple hardware is dead. Apple killed it when they killed 32 bit support.

But I have had a pretty nice experience with GeForce Now. I don’t see why that would have to change with macOS ARM.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:05AM (#23539967)
Good point, streaming games would continue to work.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by klohto on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:51PM (#23543296)
1) Let’s take the latest amount of active steam players per month, which is 90MM. That is a number for 2019, I will assume that it grew a little per the usual percentage it does (accounting for Covid) to 100MM. 4% is 4MM.

2) Macbook Pro & Macbook Air have a total share of 78%. I’m ignoring other models, since we are talking about ARM on notebooks, not towers. That brings the number of players to 3,1MM

3) We can assume that most people still rock macbooks since 2012. But let’s start counting from 2013. (We don’t have unit sales, but only the total amount, so I work with the amount that most websites quote) Apple, on average, sells 18MM Macs per fiscal year. Till today, that is 135MM Macs the market.

4) We need to estimate the amount of Macbooks vs Macs, but I cannot find a single stat on this. I’m gonna pull this out of my ass and say that it’s around 90%. The Macs have always been supplemental to Macbooks and Apple has been “forgetting” about them a lot. This brings the total to 121,5MM

5) That is 2,56% of people who game on Macbook. I would say Apple doesn’t care about ~3%. This stat also doesn’t account for hardcore vs casual players. Eq. Those who won’t care vs those who will switch platforms.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by mcspiff on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:01AM (#23539920)
Assuming this is targeting the lower end of the Apple line up, AAA gaming wasn't really much of a thing to begin with. In general though, iOS/iPadOS has a pretty expansive gaming lineup. I’d expect that library to mostly end up working on any hypothetical ARM-based macOS machines. Especially considering the iPads are already adding keyboard and mouse support.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by thewebcount on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @07:47PM (#23545775)
I have about 35 Mac games on my Steam account. I avoid Steam like the plague because its interface is awful and the experience of using it is awful compared to most other software.

I love Apple Arcade's subscription model, but it's still coming up to speed. The offerings it has aren't great yet, but I suspect they will be with time. If Apple can improve its offerings on Arcade, I'll never look back. I don't need to play the latest FPS and I suspect other Mac users also don't fit that demographic. If Valve doesn't want to port Steam to an ARM-based macOS, I'll simply drop Steam. It's that easy because Steam offers very little of value for me, personally. I've heard from others that they feel the same, though I can't say how prevalent that feeling is among Mac gamers.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by dannyw on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:42PM (#23541184)
Intel has been stagnating and dropping the ball for years. AMD is catching up but still just caught up to Intel, more or less.

I welcome competition. I want CPUs to get faster again.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by akmarinov on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:15AM (#23540108)
https://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/Steam-Hardware-Softw...

Only 4% of people using Steam are using a Mac, gaming isn't that popular on macOS, unfortunately. And it's getting worse with the OpenGL deprecation.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:38PM (#23541815)
Macs only have ~10% market-share overall, so this just tells us that Mac users are (very roughly) 50% less likely to play games than PC users. That's certainly a drop, but not such a catastrophic one.

And, Apple's asinine decisions around OpenGL don't tell us anything about what users actually want.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:24AM (#23540231)
That's still about 5 million users. Looks huge to me. Well, maybe that's tiny from some perspective.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by user5994461 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:47AM (#23540546)
Negligible compared to the 738 million iPhone users.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by thevardanian on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:44PM (#23541207)
That's not how any of this works. It's about the ecosystem of developers and users. How much VR work is happening on macs? How much AI?

This is a long term race that Apple will fail because it failed to nurture its roots.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:54AM (#23540654)
But we are talking about the MacOS users, not iPhone users... They won't be affected by this.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by scarface74 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:40PM (#23541152)
Apple sells about 20-25 million Macs a year. That’s negligible to Apple to lose some small percentage of a segment that’s only 10% of it revenue.

Think about how many games died when they dropped 32 bit support.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by onli on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:06PM (#23541453)
There are many good arguments in this thread and I honestly appreciate to see the many perspectives, also this one.

But I can't get behind that argument. If all you sell is 20-25 million, to possibly lose 5 million of that is huge. Think about how much they would have to save with the processor move (or how much performance they'd have to gain to make up for it in new sales) to make it worth it. Also, the effort will be huge to make the transition work.

All while there is the easy alternative to just use AMD processors if they wanted a performance boost?

I mean, I'm happy about this. It will probably further cement Linux as the only relevant gaming OS next to Windows. But I'm still surprised. It will be interesting to see how this plays out, if it happens.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by user5994461 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:39PM (#23541828)
For reference, they can save $200 per laptop and up to $500 on the high end CPU option.

That ought to put things in perspective.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by sudosysgen on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:52PM (#23542702)
I guarantee you that Apple isn't paying 500$ for a CPU. And developing a good laptop/desktop ARM will cost conservatively north of a billion dollars a year.
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by user5994461 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:19AM (#23551000)
The top i7 generally open around $1000 a piece and can stand there for years. Noting this might change a bit with Ryzen entering the competition on the high end.

Even if Apple is getting some bulk discount for buying 10000 CPU, I have troubles imagining 50% off. Intel is known for enjoying their margin, not for giving steep discount.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by sudosysgen on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @04:07PM (#23556091)
Except Apple doesn't buy 10000 CPUs, they buy 10 000 000 CPUs.

If they were paying even 50% of list price, Intel's revenue coming from Apple would be much higher than what it is right now. Also, laptop CPUs are priced very differently from desktop CPUs.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by scarface74 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:02PM (#23542804)
They already have a good laptop ARM chip....
Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by scarface74 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @02:05PM (#23542137)
All of those 5 million users on steam didn’t buy the Mac that year. Assuming you buy a computer every 3 years. That number is a lot smaller.

Besides how many new users might Apple get by selling laptops that are cheaper and have longer battery life.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by xigency on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:48AM (#23539746)
> That means that the next version of the MacBook Air, for example, could be cheaper even as it has better battery life and far better performance

As someone who does web development work on a MacBook Air and plays games on a Windows Desktop it’s good news for me. I think the fraction of Mac users that play games on Mac is pretty slim.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by tpush on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:11AM (#23540058)
> [...] are Apple users really okay with not having access to a single Steam game?

The fraction of people using Macs that care about gaming is tiny, and among them those who care about Steam even more so.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by pier25 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:17AM (#23540151)
I agree. I do care about gaming but I have a dedicated PC for that.

OTOH would Mac users have cared more about gaming if the platform hadn't shipped with obsolete versions of OpenGL and Metal had been introduced much sooner?

Before Metal was introduced in macOS the included OpenGL version was like 4-5 years behind.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by tobyhinloopen on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:08PM (#23542853)
I don’t care about steam on mac - i have a gaming PC.

Companies that still care will compile an ARM version just as easily.

Re:Apple, ARM, and Intel by Leherenn on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @06:05PM (#23544858)
Didn't they drop most of the games already with Catalina, since most of them are 32-bits?