News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by brandmeyer on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:08AM (#23539302)
There's a bunch of half-answers in this thread.

> Generally speaking, when we lift matter high above, we get some of the used energy back when it falls back down.

> Where is the energy stored in the meantime?

Potential energy in a gravity well is negative. The "zero" point is the limit when you get far away from all gravitational bodies. The better question is: Where does the kinetic energy come from when you descend down the gravity well in the first place?

The answer is mass. All potential energy is ultimately realized as a change in mass, equal to the famous `mass_difference * speed_of_light^2`.

As the body falls down the gravity well, it gains kinetic energy and loses mass.

When atoms bind together in an exothermic reaction, their final state is bound more tightly than their initial state. They released some energy in the form of molecular-scale kinetic energy (ie, heat), and they have lost mass.

When atoms change configuration in an endothermic reaction, their final state is bound less tightly than their initial state. Some energy was required to push them up to that higher-energy state (sometimes in the form of heat), and they have gained mass.

When light nuclei fuse together, their final state is more tightly bound than their initial state. They released some energy in the form of atomic-scale kinetic energy (ie, heat) and a photon, and they have lost mass.

Ironically, when very heavy nuclei have fissioned, their final state is more tightly bound than their initial state. They released some energy in the form of atomic-scale kinetic energy (ie, heat) and photons, and they have lost mass.

When a spring is compressed, the molecules within the elastic material are stretched apart from one another such that their final state is less tightly bound than their initial state, and the spring has gained mass.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by saagarjha on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:50AM (#23540590)
> Potential energy in a gravity well is negative. The "zero" point is the limit when you get far away from all gravitational bodies.

Like all potential energies, its definition is relative and its zero point convention.

> As the body falls down the gravity well, it gains kinetic energy and loses mass.

So you’re a saying that hydrogen lower in a gravity well will fuse worse?

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by brandmeyer on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:05PM (#23540778)
> Like all potential energies, its definition is relative and its zero point convention.

Turns out that this one does have a unique definition because the limit exists, and because the sum of kinetic energy and rest mass determines the gravitational influence of a body.

> > As the body falls down the gravity well, it gains kinetic energy and loses mass.

> So you’re a saying that hydrogen lower in a gravity well will fuse worse?

No. The processes are orthogonal to each other. Forget for the moment that its the release of kinetic energy by dropping down the gravity well that makes the subsequent fusion possible at all. Whether you fused first and then dropped down the well, or dropped down the well first and then fused, the final state is the same.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by saagarjha on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:30PM (#23541057)
> the sum of kinetic energy and rest mass determines the gravitational influence of a body

No, I’m pretty sure it’s just rest mass. The gravitational force doesn’t change based on your kinetic energy.

> Whether you fused first and then dropped down the well, or dropped down the well first and then fused, the final state is the same.

Except the problem is that fusion only converts some fraction of mass into energy (while in your hypothesis potential energy is directly converted to mass), so in your case it would actually matter whether the fusing happened before or after falling in because lower in the gravity well, the mass would be less and you’d get less energy from the fusion.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by Xcelerate on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:27PM (#23541690)
> The gravitational force doesn’t change based on your kinetic energy.

This is not correct.

Gravity is a function of everything that has energy (see the stress energy tensor). It’s a very unusual “force” in this regard. This leads to interesting situations like a perfectly mirrored box of light (if you could have such a thing) weighing more on a scale than a box without light in it. Also, a spinning cue ball or a compressed spring weigh more than a stationary ball and an uncompressed spring. Granted, these differences are so small as to be undetectable by any equipment we could ever build, but it’s still interesting to think about.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by saagarjha on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:49PM (#23541935)
You're right, I'm being stupid. Thanks for pointing that out!
Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by beamatronic on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:41PM (#23543209)
Do materials weigh less when cooled to absolute zero?
Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by JProthero on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @08:15PM (#23546051)
The weight of a sample of matter depends on its total mass energy, and heat contributes to that total. If matter is cooled, it will weigh less, and vice-versa; if it is heated it will weigh more.

At the kinds of temperatures that normally exist on Earth, the thermal contribution to the total mass energy of a sample of matter is trivial, but in extremely hot conditions, like the first fractions of a second after the big bang, the situation is reversed.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by cuspycode on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:06PM (#23541449)
> No, I’m pretty sure it’s just rest mass. The gravitational force doesn’t change based on your kinetic energy.

The energy-momentum tensor (a.k.a. stress-energy tensor) is what determines spacetime curvature, and it depends on both rest mass, kinetic energy, momentum, pressure, and shear stress.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by brandmeyer on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:52PM (#23541970)
> Except the problem is that fusion only converts some fraction of mass into energy

No. The energy release isn't actually driven by the mass of the reactants. Its driven by the strong and weak nuclear forces, which are in turn driven by quark color, spin, charge, and so on.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by afiori on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:16PM (#23541556)
> Like all potential energies, its definition is relative and its zero point convention.

But for gravity it is different. Gravitational potential energy can go to negative infinity, but never to positive infinity. in particular there is a well defined possible maximum value.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by TeMPOraL on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:52PM (#23543310)
> When a spring is compressed, the molecules within the elastic material are stretched apart from one another such that their final state is less tightly bound than their initial state, and the spring has gained mass.

Wait, isn't this the other way around? Why would molecules be less tightly bound when a string is compressed? They're all being pushed closer together.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by brandmeyer on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @05:42PM (#23544585)
"Less tightly bound" is true at the molecular level whether or not the spring is expanded or contracted from a neutral position. At a molecular level, the rest state is for the molecules is in a kind of bathtub, loosely analogous to the effect that a camlock has in a mechanical system. Strain in either the expansion or compression direction introduces an opposing stress.

Until the force exceeds enough of the bonds' strength to cause plastic deformation, both directions are "uphill" along the potential energy curve.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by TeMPOraL on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @06:07PM (#23544880)
> both directions are "uphill" along the potential energy curve.

That makes more sense to me. So they're not necessarily physically "stretched apart" when compressed, but they're still held in a higher energy state, and they want to move back towards lower energy state.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by jiveturkey on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @04:21PM (#23543593)
I only looked this up based on the comment, and I am not versed in this, beyond standard undergrad physics an eon ago. Reader beware.

The GP is wrong; it's not because molecules are closer or further apart, it's because we have introduced potential energy into the spring. The spring would gain mass regardless if it is compressed (molecules closer together?) or extended (molecules further apart?).

I used question marks there because a coil spring is a wound wire. The coil-to-coil proximity is not happening at a molecular level and is irrelevant. It is the stretching of the bonds in the [circular] direction of the winding where they get closer/further. Being helical, when deformed one side is in tension and one side in compression, so there's a net zero molecular proximity. So I'm not convinced that spring compression is molecules getting closer, and that spring extension is molecules getting further.

There's also a torsion spring, which is a bar with the ends fixed in place, that is twisted axially for the spring effect. Often used in formula car applications, but widely elsewhere as well. Here it is clear to see that compression and extension have the exact same effect, and that "closer" and "further" both occur.

The introduced potential energy is equivalent to mass, hence the spring has gained mass (and the compressing/extending object has lost mass).

https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/a-compressed-spring-ha...

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by brandmeyer on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @06:00PM (#23544797)
I agree that picking compression specifically was misleading.

> The GP is wrong; it's not because molecules are closer or further apart, it's because we have introduced potential energy into the spring.

The structure of the electron orbitals leads to a preferred bond length. So, pushing them closer or farther apart from that preferred bond length introduces potential energy into the spring. Its just that either direction is "up" the potential energy well.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by voldacar on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:49AM (#23548520)
So once the spring snaps back into its original state, this energy is dissipated as heat and its mass decreases slightly, right?
Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by brandmeyer on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:24AM (#23551752)
> this energy is dissipated as heat

Heat is kinetic energy, its just randomized. It isn't the conversion of kinetic energy to heat that makes the mass change observable, its the subsequent dissipation of the heat that does so.

The difference in mass is observable only when the binding energy you release gets outside of the measurement apparatus. Because the mass-energy equivalence goes both ways, any instrument that is set up to measure the mass won't register a change until that heat also dissipates. This equivalence is why physicists will frequently clarify what they mean by distinguishing "rest mass" from "mass", where "rest mass" is the mass that the body will have once it comes to rest.

Thought experiment: A stretched ideal spring sits inside an isolated enclosure with an instrument set up to measure the mass of the spring, enclosure and everything inside of it. You release the spring and it vibrates back and forth indefinitely. The instrument registers no change in mass at all.

Variation: The spring is not ideal; it has some damping. The enclosure remains ideal. You release the spring and it vibrates back and forth a little bit before damping slows it down and releases some heat. The heat stays inside the perfect enclosure. The instrument still registers no change in mass at all.

Variation: The enclosure isn't ideal, either. You release the spring, it vibrates back and forth a little bit before damping slows it down and releases some heat. The heat escapes the imperfect enclosure. The instrument registers a small change in mass, proportional to the energy released / speed of light squared.

Re:Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces by voldacar on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:57PM (#23553699)
Yeah, I meant as in "some heat escapes into the environment". That makes a lot of sense, thanks for the explanations as this stuff can be quite unintuitive at times :)