This is unworkable, since "Busse" (several autobuses) should not match "Buße" (repentance). But "Busse" (incorrect spelling of "Buße" due to character set limitations/Swiss German spelling I believe) should match "Buße" by your argument.
Anyway, modern Firefox lets you choose whether to match "Apfel" against "Äpfel".
But: "Busse" is not a always incorrect spelling, it's just an "emergency" one, if you really can't use "ß" for some reason. One example is allcaps text, here "BUSSE" and "BUSSE" are not distinguishable, although they have different meanings. Also, there is Swiss German, where replacing ß with ss is the normal form and not at all "accepted in an emergency" like in German German: https://www.galaxus.de/de/page/schweizerhochdeutsch-fuer-anf...
Incidentially this is one of the instances where you really have to know the language and the context to be able to do a lowercase -> uppercase -> lowercase roundtrip, otherwise you might screw up with "Buße -> BUSSE -> Busse", changing the meaning. Or not, if the current locale is de_CH instead of de_DE.
Together, since very often search will be case-insensitive, I think that while you may be correct, being as strict as to not match here would not be what the user would expect.
Yes, again, I18N is hard and sometimes it is impossible to do correctly for a machine.
But, regex is a separate issue than languages of text.
Szene should match ß?
Also, in this case, Sz is pronounced as the two distinct letters it is composed of. Whereas when "sz" replaces "ß", the pronounciation is just very similar to a plain "s".
Admittedly German isn't my first language. But it seems odd to be permissive in one case, but more restrictive in the other. In my experience there are two cases for searching: exact matches, like you'd expect an editor's find and replace, and more permissive searches, where you might expect to skip through several matches to find what you're looking for. In this second case, what's the advantage of being more exclusive in one case, then less exclusive in the other? Why not have a more permissive default (as mentioned by the other user's reply regarding Firefox's configurable search), even if it's technically incorrect?
Whereas for umlauts ä, ö and ü, the forms with ae, oe and ue are always "emergency replacements", even the Swiss use äöü very frequently (though not always). Also, there are almost never ambiguities when replacing ä, ö, ü -> ae, oe, ue. Yet there are very frequent ambiguities when replacing ä, ö, ü -> a, o, u, because singular/plural, conjunctive and other forms are derived that way and sometimes there are just different words that only differ in one vowel being an umlaut.
So there is a difference in the chance of being wrong when picking one form of a word for another possibly equivalent one. When you do ss == ß, you are often correct. When you do ä, ö, ü == ae, oe, ue, you are almost always correct. When you do ä, ö, ü == a, o, u, you are almost always wrong.
requires, not just "allows".
> even the Swiss use äöü very frequently
I can't think of any case where Germans would use one of these and German speaking Swiss would not. But as another Swiss peculiarity, some of our words contain "üe", e.g. "Üetliberg", "gmüetlich".
Of course all of this is locale-dependent and it might be acceptable for ease of use to match "ä" to "a" for international users. But not in a german locale.
Proper I18N is very hard, and supporting Unicode is just a first step. Converting text between lower/upper/title-case can only be done knowing at least the locale of the text, and in rare cases a case-folding-roundtrip can even change the meaning of the text, so you will have to be able to speak the language.