News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by davesque on Saturday June 13, 2020 @12:18AM (#23506701)
There's a flip side to that though which is that the other side of the aisle is also a howling mob. The discourse across the board has become so radically polarized that it's impossible to reconcile the competing world views. In the mean time, there's apparently a belief in the news room that centrists are rare enough that they need not be catered to.
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by phaus on Saturday June 13, 2020 @09:42AM (#23509288)
Centrists would be somewhat rare it it hadn't become a slur for both extremes to label anyone that's not an extremist.

Moderates are far more common than centrists. But these day's you're either completely toxic and insane or you get ridiculed as a centrist for not caring enough.

[dead]
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by phaus on Saturday June 13, 2020 @03:25PM (#23511964)
This is exactly what I was talking about. You make a bunch of assumptions about peoples' political opinions that are incorrectly portraying them as centrists and supporters of nazis if they don't adopt your world view. "Us or them" is killing America. Lack of nuance and intelligent discourse is destroying us.

There's more to the extreme left than "Everyone deserves to be treated equally and with dignity."

Politics in the US lacks nuance. You can be politically moderate and lean towards the left. It isn't simply conservative wolves in centrist clothing.

I can vehemently disagree about many things that extreme leftists do and still vote for one over Donald Trump. But that doesn't mean voting for Donald Trump automatically makes someone a Nazi either.

[dead]
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by mistermann on Saturday June 13, 2020 @06:16PM (#23513283)
> Doesn't it make them a Nazi enabler, though?

Calling Trump a nazi seems incredibly disrespectful to people and their family who actually lost their lives to real nazis.

Are you aware that you don't actually know what Trump supporters think? That your opinion is based on heuristics running on top of the absolutely tiny sample of the real world that you've been exposed to, much of it likely incredibly biased if not outright untrue?

[dead]
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by phaus on Saturday June 13, 2020 @08:10PM (#23513982)
Did you grow up with 49% of the voters in this country, or are you generalizing them based on caricatured versions of your anecdotal experience?

I haven't and don't plan on voting for Trump. However, you can't generalize a group of people consisting of approximately 60 million very easily. Even if you can't fathom why they would support him, there's a wide variety of backgrounds, experiences, and ideologies within that massive group.

There are also many different political issues that have significant impacts on peoples' lives. Not everyone gets the same information about these issues. Even if they did, not everyone interprets and values them in the same exact way. I would bet most people voting for or against Trump are trying to do what they think will make the US a safe, fair, happy place to live. The problem is that many political issues are incredibly complex and most of them don't have clear cut solutions. Even in cases where they do, people still can't agree on the best course of action.

Some people like to hand wave the complexity away by taking the stance that "one party just wants freedom and equal rights for everyone and the other wants the opposite".

[dead]
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by CamperBob2 on Saturday June 13, 2020 @07:43PM (#23513842)
I'm very familiar with the Nacht und Nebel directive, but not with that particular film. In fact, "Night and Fog" was the first image that came to mind when I saw a protester being kidnapped and shoved into an unmarked vehicle recently. [1] I can perhaps be forgiven for thinking that it might be a good time to get off the fence and pick a side.

I've also found some post-war narratives out of Germany to be downright bone-chilling, such as 'The Lives of Others.' Definitely recommend that one if you haven't seen it. Are there any specific points raised by 'Night and Fog' that you have in mind?

1: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-06-06/video-un...

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday June 13, 2020 @08:33PM (#23514092)
There really isn't more to the "extreme left" than equality and dignity.

The problem is that even suggesting that equality and dignity are valid as bedrock communal values in business, politics, law, and economics is considered an aggressively extremist ultra-left position in the US - and not a sane and mature common sense centre-left view, as it is in parts of Europe.

There's a reason for this, and it's to do with the real bedrock values of US culture.

Bottom line is the Left in the US operates the same way as the rest of US culture does.

And the underlying problem is understanding why, not complaining about superficial dynamics that are actually consistent with the way the culture operates as a whole.

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by jlawson on Sunday June 14, 2020 @01:29AM (#23515349)
What is North Korea? Cuba? Soviet Union? Doesn't sound like equality and dignity to me.

What you're not getting is that equality and dignity aren't even compatible if you try to push equality to extremes. Dignity means giving people freedom to make their own choices and live as they wish; the opposite of dignity is enslaving them. But as soon as people can make different choices they'll start achieving different outcomes - inequality. Not to mention the need to forcefully people who step out of their assigned 'equal' band of achievement - there's nothing dignified about crabs in a bucket.

NK and Cuba and USSR stamped out inequality pretty well, and they gave up on dignity to accomplish that.

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by xnyan on Sunday June 14, 2020 @01:48PM (#23519669)
Let’s see, a state that no longer exists and two of the worst examples of left based ideology nation states.

You sound like a rational person. If I give you three examples of current capitalist ideology authoritarian states (one more example than you gave), reason would dictate that you will of course instantly become a leftest because you are a rational person and by your own self-described logic, the correct ideology is determined by which ideological system has a higher count of authoritarian states.

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by jlawson on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:49PM (#23541263)
Not a higher count of authoritatian states. A higher fraction.

Far-left: 100% Far-right: 100%

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by phaus on Saturday June 13, 2020 @09:17PM (#23514325)
You put "extreme left" in quotes as if there isn't such a thing and its simply a way to malign mainstream liberals. Once again this is the kind of tribalism I'm talking about. All or nothing. Purity tests.

There are leftists in the US to whom equality and dignity are the foundations of their belief system. However, that doesn't represent the whole of leftism in the US and it certainly doesn't represent the foundation of actual leftist extremism in America.

To clarify, I don't think most people that fall on the left half of the political spectrum in the United States are extremists. I think that due to their fanaticism and tendency to be more vocal, the extremists have a voice disproportionate to their actual size.

That doesn't mean they don't matter. It just means they don't represent as many people on the left as one would perceive them to based on social media and mainstream media.

I'm not a leftist extremist. I'm a socially liberal moderate that likes the general idea of free market competition but understands that completely unregulated markets are probably just as toxic and doomed to fail as attempts to form completely planned economies. Prudent regulation can minimize predatory and exploitative behavior.

I think there is a balance to be struck between people having individual freedoms and the ability of the government to take measures to prevent groups of people from making it impossible for marginalized groups of people to live enjoyable lives in the US.

My search for that balance is founded on a desire for equality and dignity. For example, I don't think a city or state full of racists/homophobes should be able to use States' rights protections to establish bubbles where its impossible for certain minorities to comfortably exist.

However, I believe that we are often really quick to take knee jerk reactions and pass legislation that may have unintended consequences when it comes to preserving everyone's freedom, equality, and dignity.

You may choose to ignore them, but there are vocal voices in the progressive movement that are racist and sexist and are more interested in establishing a society that revolves around revenge against white people. Some of them are nobodies, but some of them are influential people in places of power in various industries.

Leftist extremism exists. There are people advocating for violence against white people and men in general on Twitter for a daily basis. Reporting these people usually gets ignored.

I'm opposed to leftist extremism and conservative extremism. People that advocate for violence and who advocate for a new type of inequality are assholes, regardless of how many of their unrelated political opinions I might share with them.

I do, however, believe that the US has more work to do in regards to how it treats many different minority groups. I also believe that white privilege exists. I don't think every white person faces a life-changing situation where they benefit from it, but it happens. In my case I'm not sure how much of an impact it had, but it probably had an impact.

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by fzeroracer on Saturday June 13, 2020 @05:01PM (#23512696)
I mean, Donald Trump literally reversed transgender health protections this week. If you're voting for a Republican, you're voting for the party of Donald Trump and efforts like that which take away the rights of certain classes of citizens.

You can't vote for a party and try to avoid taking the whole package deal. You get what you voted for.

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by AnimalMuppet on Saturday June 13, 2020 @06:01PM (#23513165)
But that logic means that if I vote for a Democrat, I'm also taking the whole package deal. And, bluntly, there aren't very many people that actually support all of that package deal.
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by fzeroracer on Saturday June 13, 2020 @08:13PM (#23513995)
Yes, that's right. I don't agree with the full package deal, but I think it's far better than the alternative

Again: You get what you vote for. Using 'I disagree with what my party is doing, but I'm voting for them anyways' as an attempt to avoid criticism doesn't work. That's the nature of US politics. If you vote for one party despite them doing some heinous things, then you tacitly support what they're doing. If you don't like it, then either don't vote or vote for the opposite party.

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by AnimalMuppet on Saturday June 13, 2020 @11:24PM (#23514835)
And if I also disagree with some of what the other party is doing, then what? "Don't vote" seems to be the only option you have left. And I strongly disagree that that's the best option.
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by fzeroracer on Sunday June 14, 2020 @12:04AM (#23515030)
Then you compromise and pick the party that you think best accomplishes what you want.

But part of that compromise is that you accept the party is going to also do things you don't like. Which is something you can't escape criticism for. Voting is approval for that party. You're choosing to value what Party B does over Party A, which means you weigh the negatives of Party B as being less of a problem than the positives.

That doesn't mean you get to avoid those negatives when someone else calls you out on who you decided to throw your lot in with.

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by jessaustin on Saturday June 20, 2020 @12:07AM (#23581561)
Instead, do as all thinking humans: vote for the third party that most appeals to you. I've been swapping between the Greens and the Libertarians... this year looks Green so far.
[dead]
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by dang on Saturday June 13, 2020 @08:16PM (#23514008)
This is trolling. There's no view that requires that level of disrespect. If you continue to post flamebait to HN we will ban you.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by buzzkillington on Saturday June 13, 2020 @08:55PM (#23514212)
Even the guy who started this site had something to say about shitting on orthodoxy:

>What scares me is that there are moral fashions too. They're just as arbitrary, and just as invisible to most people. But they're much more dangerous. Fashion is mistaken for good design; moral fashion is mistaken for good. Dressing oddly gets you laughed at. Violating moral fashions can get you fired, ostracized, imprisoned, or even killed.

http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by dang on Sunday June 14, 2020 @01:26AM (#23515334)
pg would most likely have just banned you a long time ago. He was like 100x quicker to ban HN users than we are, and he never gave warnings like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22709413 or https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22606579.
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by thisiszilff on Saturday June 13, 2020 @05:36PM (#23512969)
The charitable interpretation of the centrists position is trying to straddle the line between "I believe the government should be responsible for intervening in order to secure equal outcomes for all people" and "I believe individuals should be responsible for their owns lives and own outcomes." Or something along those lines. Centrists are not centrists because they embrace some negative, immoral 'other side', but because they recognize the other side has it's own values that are good and worth preserving. Many centrists likely see themselves as trying to strike a balance between these values.
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by wherewillitlead on Saturday June 13, 2020 @04:52PM (#23512618)
How do you situate Max in Oakland on this spectrum? Taibbi writes about him at length in the article - and his original comments were https://twitter.com/lhfang/status/1268390704645943297.

I'm not asking a rhetorical question, genuinely interested in how you see this. It doesn't seem like to me like he falls in any of the categories you listed. Same with Lee Fang, the interviewer who got attacked for publishing Max's remarks.

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by djohnston on Saturday June 13, 2020 @05:36PM (#23512972)
Lol this sentiment is exactly the problem being discussed and you've inadvertently provided a great example for the thread to examine. Thanks!
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by dang on Saturday June 13, 2020 @06:03PM (#23513179)
Please don't be a jerk in HN threads, no matter how wrong another commenter is or you feel they are. Nothing good is going to come of it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by aspenmayer on Saturday June 13, 2020 @10:45AM (#23509738)
Agreed on all points. Appeals to centrism are a negotiation tactic; not with the one considered too extreme who should be more moderate, but to the third party who is watching who is sympathetic to the one calling for moderation. It benefits the status quo, and therefore is innately conservative.
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by humanrebar on Saturday June 13, 2020 @11:26AM (#23510088)
No, centrism is to also find areas of consensus and pursue them, however imperfect. For instance, criminal justice reform has made some progress recently. Gradual decriminalization of some recreational drugs as well.
Re:The American Press Is Destroying Itself by aspenmayer on Saturday June 13, 2020 @01:12PM (#23510917)
I don’t disagree. I view the two as mutually compatible rather than exclusive. Incrementalism is working within the Overton window to affect change within the system. Progress happens in fits and starts as well as by design and committee.