News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by Bud on Monday March 21, 2011 @10:47AM (#2349913)
Mr. Arends makes a very strong argument. And really, if you need a shorthand way to understand this issue, all you need to know is that the Bush Administration stripped away the limits on one company's ownership of spectrum. Republicans talk a good game about the "free market", but it's internally inconsistent talk; you can't have a free market if the number of players in said market gets below a certain level. 4-5 is probably a pretty good guess at what that level is, and in the GSM market, we're now down to 1 player if this deal goes through. Since many customers are forced into choosing GSM for compatibility when they travel, that's an effective monopoly, just like Arends says.

I'm an AT&T customer. But I'm not optimistic about what this deal will mean. I know what it won't mean: cheaper and better service, as guaranteed by a healthy fear of competitors.

Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by Schultzy on Monday March 21, 2011 @01:55PM (#2350807)
What's so bad about a monopoly in a free market?

Doesn't that just create opportunity for some other carrier, perhaps a currently small regional company, to step up and fill that hole?

If the pain is big enough, there will be competition. If we mandate competition, it's not a FREE market.

Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by gergles on Monday March 21, 2011 @02:15PM (#2350914)
It's impossible to compete with a national wireless carrier due to a multi-billion dollar barrier to entry in the form of a spectrum license.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by jerf on Monday March 21, 2011 @03:17PM (#2351139)
"If we mandate competition, it's not a FREE market."

In addition to the other fine replies made, I want to highlight this to strongly disagree with it. In fact actually having a free market requires aggressively protecting it when a given market naturally coalesces into a monopoly or oligarchy. Trust-busting isn't an anti-free-market position, it's a pro-free-market position. The anti-free-market actions come from governments picking winners and enshrining monopolies/oligarchies through regulatory capture.

In particular, when advocates of other social organizations level this as a criticism of free market, my response is to point out that when you have lack of mandated competition with some form of government-selected winners, be it communism, socialism, or "crony capitalism", you don't have a free market at all and the criticism is more generally applicable to the social organization being argued for by the person raising this criticism.

In a free market, a new company always ought to be able to come along and completely destroy an existing company if they do a good enough job. If you don't have this, you don't have a free market.

Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by dantheman on Monday March 21, 2011 @06:30PM (#2351949)
Trust busting is an anti-free-market position. The freemarket consists of individuals voluntarily interacting. Any position that advocates coercion, i.e. government interference, is anti-free-market.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by jerf on Monday March 21, 2011 @07:09PM (#2352078)
Trusts are a coercion, and a crime greater than a bit of government trust-busting. (Or, in really far-out versions of anarchist theory, non-government trust busting. I don't know of any real-world examples of that, though.) I do not naively believe that an economy can be run completely without coercion, but that such coercion as is necessary should be turned to keeping the market free. The optimal ideal case for free markets simply doesn't obtain everywhere. Spectrum is at least dubious; perhaps now we could just run it as a free market and it could work (people with far more knowledge about radio issues than me have argued both sides of this, I can only sit on the sidelines of that one and wave genially) but that certainly wasn't the case in the analog radio era.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by rwmj on Monday March 21, 2011 @02:34PM (#2351010)
RF spectrum is not a free market - it's a government-backed monopoly.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by EricBerglund on Monday March 21, 2011 @02:16PM (#2350922)
This is true in a market with few existing regulations and a low barrier to entry, in other words the complete opposite of the mobile market.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by MatthewPhillips on Monday March 21, 2011 @02:47PM (#2351047)
Monopolies prevent competition from entering the market (by definition) by building barriers to entry. AT&T is not a monopoly, people like to throw that word out whenever a company does something like this. What Intel did to AMD is a good example of a company using a monopoly position to prevent competition.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by TGJ on Monday March 21, 2011 @02:16PM (#2350925)
The problem lies in costs. A monopolistic company keeps costs down due to scale. Any other business cannot enter the market on a competitive level because they cannot meet the same price structures.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by hyperbovine on Monday March 21, 2011 @01:22PM (#2350637)
Bush's term ended in 2008. I think that's a salient point.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by aaronbrethorst on Monday March 21, 2011 @03:27PM (#2351171)
It actually ended in January 2009.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by evo_9 on Monday March 21, 2011 @04:20PM (#2351388)
Really? I couldn't tell the differences based on how the new guy has been acting(see: Wall Street bailout, lack of standing tall with Wisconsin Union, Domain Take-Down practice, etc). I wish it were different than this, why I voted for change in the first place. Ah well.
Re:Why AT&T’s deal for T-Mobile must be blocked by wyclif on Monday March 21, 2011 @07:26PM (#2352130)
You drank the Kool-aid.