Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations
by vegetablepotpie on Thursday June 11, 2020 @12:26PM
(#23490482)
When they mess up is when it changes.
When you look at old institutions and powerful people, sometimes their rule ends abruptly because of scandal, bad decisions, or corruption. Bear Sterns, Enron, and Nixon are examples of this.
For a new publishing platform to succeed, the old one needs die. For an organization built on prestige to die, it needs to be mired in scandal wrapped up and packaged in the political zeitgeist at that moment that not only affects its small community but also develops the ire of the entire society. At that point a new platform will emerge, likely backed by, and inheriting its prestige from, another institution.
Edit: I realize, unfortunately, this post doesn’t give anything actionable that anyone can enact. It at least offers hope that things can change.
"Flipping" journals is an option, but doesn't happen often because it's risk for the editors with little personal benefit.
The answer the project I volunteer for [1] is that the prestige of a journal comes from the researchers who submit or review for it, so we can also employ their reputations without the middleman - by having them endorse works, thus having their names instead of the journal names attached to the works.
When the prestigious expert editorial board resigns at the same time and creates a new journal. It has happened several times, e. g. Glossa for linguistics.
Also JMLR in machine learning is independent and still well regarded.
It wouldn't surprise me if this is a massive part of the problem. Any new system to replace Elsevier may be perfect in lots of ways, but it doesn't count as prestigious, which means everybody will still want/need to publish with Elsevier. How do you magically grant a new publishing platform this 'prestige'?