The places where the money hides, so to speak, include (1) handling complex cases [customers] (2) scaling a human's ability to process non-automatable settlements. (3) scaling internal support interactions with customers (4) introspection to claims data and support data. (5) graceful handling of prior authorizations.
These problems are not as attractive, but they are where insurance companies spend most of their money. It's still a tech problem, but it's not super fancy.
Existing carriers struggle to solve these problems, because they have historically grown by acquisition, and as such do not have the kinds of unified data systems required for the rapid development of applications that perform the required kinds of introspection. It's a space that's ripe for disrupting.
I’d say customer acquisition is the biggest cost and insurance companies are terrible at it because differentiation is almost impossible in a price driven by extreme price war.
It’s not uncommon that 30-50% of your travel insurance premiums are going to a broker or price comparison website. Talking about great value.
It’s not as sexy as ML in claims but one of the big innovations Lemonade has developed is looking like the anti-insurer and creating a huge PR machine around that. True or not, it worked.
Like you, I’m not convinced that the value they add to the chain justifies their expense, but they’re legally and economically entrenched.
My only hypothesis for their eventual dissolution is that unit commissions will get smaller and smaller over time, as more brokers use tech to manage bigger books of business with lower employee headcount requirements, and brokers become more indistinguishable from carriers.
Or maybe some consortium of carriers will get together to build THE comparison shopping site, like healthcare.gov, and offer some ridiculous bonus payment to you the member for shopping there.
Most people in the tech industry don't apply the ML label to these kinds of software. However, there is a ton of knowledge invested in these systems: certainly more than any one currently-living human has in their head.
A more apt, though out-of-fashion label might be "expert system": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expert_system
Ιmagine a spaghetti code. Now think of an IT eco-system that has grown with half-baked interfaces, patches, MANY MANY MANY MANY spreadsheets, legacy systems (and I mean having MS Server versions 10+ years old), and nobody dares to change passwords because there will be pain.
Now imagine that a mega-big insurance is growing by M&A, and it becomes mega-big by absorbing other companies, (speghetti-zed) IT eco-systems, and they try to absorb processes and data with even more spaghetti-ish manners. One sneeze and the world is coming down...
Now consider a new, modern company that has the talent, and none of the inheret problems/risks. They may not be mega-big (yet), but they got the potential to slowly steal chunks of the market, only if/the grow clean, fresh, and organically.
In the UK it's a (growing?) trend to have your app on someone's phone, tracking motion from the phone's sensors (accelerometer, GPS/speed, etc.) and they can give you lower premiums. The possibilities are endless... as long as they are modern enough.
My understanding is that it is generally considered that renter's insurance is too high at most large carriers. There are historical reasons for this which I won't go into (and I don't understand all of them anyway). The carriers don't change this because:
1) Lowering renter's insurance premiums would require raising premiums elsewhere (e.g. homeowners). Raising rates causes customers to leave.
2) Renter's insurance is fairly cheap as it is and people don't price-shop all that much.
3) Shifting premiums brings regulatory scrutiny and you have to do it right (and legally). It's not worth the hassle.
I think Lemonade started largely with renter's insurance to take advantage of that gap. It's one of the things that put fear into the major carriers.
Before I started working in the business space I knew almost nothing about insurance (and didn't care). It's been fairly interesting and I have more empathy for the carriers than I used to; they aren't quite the blood-sucking maggots that some maintain.
Or maybe Lemonade is like many other "tech" companies, and is selling their product below costs in the hopes of growing into profits. From a consumer standpoint, gambling with your insurance in such a manner is scary.
This is exactly what they're doing. Take a look at their losses from claims. Brilliant marketing though, especially for an insurance company.
(Anecdotally, they are offering me about 95% of what I pay Geico for similar coverage, and without the auto insurance discount.)
I assume that Lemonade is banking on doing away with almost all manual processing so they're ideas are different from mine.
You’ll see the same kind of jobs that exist today, but they will be smaller in number, and way less paper-oriented.
- Processing claims with humans is expensive; every step that can be accomplished by a computer will probably be cheaper.
- A claim processed via ML will probably be handled fast. A fast response = happy customer, which helps with retention. This is a big one.
- A claim that is processed and closed quickly is harder to amend. Some customers slowly realize that adding items to a claim is free money. Others (legitimately) forgot items and want to add them. A quick claim is usually cheaper than one that might take a few days (or weeks) to process.
- Younger generations are more used to working with a web pages and will likely look at humans (e.g. agents) as old-fashioned.
The big carriers are both scared and dubious of Lemonade. If Lemonade can somehow make it work they could do serious damage to the carriers. But it's hard to see how they'll make the numbers work, as their current losses show. Most of the carriers are trying to implement something similar (which is where I'm slightly involved).