News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by mydongle on Sunday June 07, 2020 @03:40PM (#23450082)
Nuance is not so important in this situation. The effect is that people have been effectively given a pass to disregard the virus, as long as they're "protesting". Look at the protests and all the riots, do you see social distancing happening? People are throwing punches out there my dude. It's chaos.
[dead]
Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by mydongle on Sunday June 07, 2020 @03:52PM (#23450197)
It seems you see this in terms of idea and theory. I am looking at things from a greater view, seeing the actual effect and impact of things. This is the same thing when health experts told everyone masks don't work. They were wrong. And you will be wrong as well.

Since if you believe I am against the protest, then it's in my benefit that the protests continue, so all my supposed enemies die off. Believe what you want :)

Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by pstuart on Sunday June 07, 2020 @05:02PM (#23450787)
The "masks don't work" message the beginning was a tragic mistake. I think I understand why it might have come to be, but it was a mistake nonetheless.

Mistakes happen. If we learn from them they become lessons.

I do see this in terms of idea and theory, as well as practice. These protests are a legitimate response to systematic abuse. It clearly has peoples attention, and that's a good thing from my perspective.

I don't want to be wrong, so could you clarify exactly how I'm wrong? In supporting protests? In taking the letter you cited on its word that social distancing and other preventative measures should be taken by protesters?

I can only guess that you are against these protests, in that you quoted them as "protests" and can only cite the the negatives you see (not enough social distancing and too much violence).

If the current administration prevails, I will indeed be on the wrong side of history by virtue of who is writing it, and why. I'm proud to be on the side that opposes fascism and I don't need external approval to know that authoritarianism does not promote a just society.

Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by mydongle on Sunday June 07, 2020 @05:21PM (#23450944)
When I said you would be wrong, I'm talking about the effects of that letter. The letter probably does mention that social distancing should be taken by protestors. But that is not what's happening and will not happen. So the main message the letter is: Coronavirus bad! Shut down your businesses and stay home. Except if you're protesting.

As soon as you have a confrontation here and there, the virus is no longer of concern. If you are someone who is legitimately concerned about the pandemic, you should be angry at all the health experts who signed that letter. For they have delegitimized the pandemic and vindicated those who do not believe it to be the threat it was made out to be. As with the WHO masks thing, these kinds of actions have only destroyed the credibility of the science community, or whatever's left of it. The effects of that are to be seen. But you will see them.

I don't know if I'm against the protests or not, perhaps it's more like I am against poor strategy. What has the protests done other than become co-opted by looters, dirty the perception of African Americans and other minorities, and now caused the science/health experts to disgrace themselves further? This is a big win for our enemies. I believe it's time for the protests to stop, so that we could see who's left, who are the people co-opting this movement to further their political goals. However pure and legitimate the protests are, to continue them is to continue providing a cover for those who would like to use the protests to further their political goals.

Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by pstuart on Sunday June 07, 2020 @06:46PM (#23451706)
I have to assume that you're being sincere but it feels like trolling to me. We apparently live in different worlds, and this is pointless.

Kthxbai!

Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by mrcorona on Sunday June 07, 2020 @03:51PM (#23450194)
People living in a certain form of hell aren't afraid of dying of corona... I personally would rather die of pneumonia than 20 or so bullets to the back from an agent of the state operating with a hair trigger and impunity.

Do people really think MLK felt safe when he was protesting? He was brave, new assassination was likely, and still marched.

Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by mydongle on Sunday June 07, 2020 @03:53PM (#23450211)
Yeah, but if all the proponents of BLM die to Covid-19, who is going to be there to keep up the fight afterward? This is all very short-term thinking. There are other ways to protest.
Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by pstuart on Sunday June 07, 2020 @05:04PM (#23450806)
> There are other ways to protest

I'm genuinely curious. Would you care to elaborate?

Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by mydongle on Sunday June 07, 2020 @05:27PM (#23450997)
Instead of destroying local businesses and terrorizing innocent people in their own cities, maybe they should be targetting the rich multinational corporations? Those corps will bend over for basically anything if to avoid backlash and protect their profits.

If BLM could get enough people to boycott corporations who have benefitted from this status quo, then they could force them to push through the changes they want.

If you have numbers, theres a bunch of things you could do without even stepping outside, let alone go and protesting, causing mayhem and chaos for our essential workers during this pandemic. My idea may not be the right one, they'll have to figure it out.

Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by pstuart on Sunday June 07, 2020 @06:30PM (#23451543)
Here's the thing: I'm not advocating for violence and neither are most of "us". This violence is not because of the protest, it's because of interlopers.

You only see these protests as exercises in violence and mayhem, which is exactly what the powers that be want. It completely delegitimizes these First Amendment protests in the eyes of many.

Much of that violence comes from interlopers who hijack the effort, and of that violence is manufactured by outsiders intentionally stirring up shit. The recent "antifa" account that was really a white nationalist organization comes to mind.

Consistently framing the protesters as being the ones who are inciting or participating in this violence can only be disingenuous at best.

Again, violence is bad, m'kay? We get that. It also means that it's bad when it comes from the police as well.

Boycotting is a luxury, and is a dilute and indirect route to change. Perhaps they should just calm down and file a complaint with the police department and a manager will straighten everything out just right?

[dead]
Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by dang on Sunday June 07, 2020 @11:33PM (#23453349)
Please don't paste boilerplate lists of links or talking points into HN threads. This isn't conversation, and the site guidelines ask people not to use HN for political or ideological battle.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re:America is giving up on the pandemic? by mrcorona on Sunday June 07, 2020 @04:21PM (#23450448)
I think that is irrelevant to many of the protestors. Most know that black Ferguson, Missouri protestors started to mysteriously die weeks after the protests ended (suspect foul play), they know the state may target them for the rest of their lives, and many made peace with putting their life on the line for this cause -before- they walked into the streets.

>There are other ways to protest.

Feel free to share any protest ideas you have that keep them safe and achieve Civil Rights Act level reforms without requiring people in the streets making the powerful uncomfortable.