News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by runxel on Saturday June 06, 2020 @05:57PM (#23442585)
It is really hard to read through all that marketing nonsense. Not sure if I should cry or burst out in tears from laughing.

In any case I can't stand all that false statements. Let's take this one for example:

> Subscription demands constant improvement of our product and enables us to make $Product better for you — faster.

In fact, the opposite is the case! Just look at Adobe. Or maybe CAD/BIM products, like Revit from Autodesk. The only thing that was new in this years version was slanted walls (!). Something competitors have for ~20 years already.

So for me subscription basically is equivalent with the opposite. As soon companies decided to switch from the possibility to let me buy their software, as in "I own this thing and I can use it indefinitely." to "rent" their software, progress came to a grinding halt most times.

The reason why this doesn't work like in the PR statement above is the way things work in real life. First you lock them customers in: all their files are now in your proprietary format. The presumption from above is, that you won't renew you subscription when you don't like the new yearly version – but then you can no longer access your files you need, since you do business! So cancelling of subscriptions basically never happens, turning your company into a gold mine.

Yearly realases are bad btw and nobody likes them. Except shareholdes maybe.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by buserror on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:07PM (#23442669)
Completely agree here. I think subscribtions are bad for customers, AND THE DEVELOPERS too. Basically companies cut down on R&D instead of pushing on R&D to gain new upgrade and customers fees.

I bought GraphicConverter [1] a zillion years ago, and I just upgraded to their v11, and so I paid them probably more than I've ever paid any other software -- BUT, they always come up with a list of improvement 5 pages long, and I've been using that stuff on/off for 20+ years.

I have no problems pushing money their way, I know where that money is going ultimately. It certainly doesn't go in shareholder or marketing drone's pocket.

[1]: https://www.lemkesoft.de/en/products/graphicconverter/

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by api on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:28PM (#23443272)
This is driven by the shift toward valuing companies entirely on recurrent revenue. I've been told that non-recurrent revenue is meaningless and is often ignored.

Its just the latest business fad.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by vikramkr on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:50PM (#23443402)
Its not a fad. Recurring revenue has always been worth than non recurring because valuations are forward looking and recurring revenue is lower risk. Look at smartphones. Just because someone bought a smartphone last year doesnt mean they'll buy one this year. That sale last year does not matter as much for your current valuation as if you sold a subscription
Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by x86_64Ubuntu on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:25PM (#23442824)
Yep. Subscription models become a necessity when companies have a mature product and the feature set and stability changes don't apply pressure to update. Once the product is mature, people don't upgrade because it costs money and the old version does what they need it to do. That's a losing proposition for an MBA dominated world. So you counter that by making it so no one can ever own their software but they have to subscribe to it so you can continue to extract value.
Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by qppo on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:57PM (#23443442)
You never owned the software, just purchased an indefinite license to use it. This has turned out to be ultimately unprofitable and has changed from infinite subscription terms to finite ones.

I don't know why you think it hurts R&D. The alternative is a dead company.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by justinmeiners on Saturday June 06, 2020 @08:02PM (#23443465)
> I don't know why you think it hurts R&D

Because before they had to make the product a lot better to sell you on an upgrade.

> The alternative is a dead company.

Were software companies dead before 2013?

Of course, it is legal and fair for them to run this particular business model. The other poster is just expressing that as a consumer they like it less.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by qppo on Saturday June 06, 2020 @08:15PM (#23443526)
Yes lots of them died before 2013.

Conversely they're not charging you a massive one time update fee. They're charging many smaller fees for smaller updates which is more representative of the development costs of the product, where you'd have to split next years development on updates and bug fixes for customers that would never give you another dime.

This is unsustainable for many software shops which is why many of them died. We're seeing such growth in SaaS today because pricing based on how much value your product creates for users, on a schedule that reflects how much it costs to deliver it is much better for everyone involved.

Like Adobe is a good example of this. Their products are much better today than they used to be and more affordable for everyone. The real trouble is the CC runtimes which are just shitty software, the pricing model is not a problem.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by justinmeiners on Sunday June 07, 2020 @12:57AM (#23444870)
I understand and agree with basically all of that. All I'm saying is that in the old model there was a more urgent incentive for them to add great stuff. In certain circumstances this benefited consumers. There were plenty of companies that did just fine without Saas.
Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by Marsymars on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:40PM (#23442939)
> In fact, the opposite is the case! Just look at Adobe.

Well from some points of view, they're right - I had an Adobe CC subscription for a little while, and after six months of no improvements, I abandoned Adobe products entirely.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by tomnipotent on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:56PM (#23443434)
> after six months of no improvements

Historical Adobe releases were years apart but you're unhappy with a couple of months because it's a subscription? I can't follow this logic.

Below history is just Photoshop, and if anything it looks like change velocity has increased since it became subscription-based.

https://adobe.fandom.com/wiki/Adobe_Photoshop_release_histor...

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by Marsymars on Sunday June 07, 2020 @05:35PM (#23451071)
> Historical Adobe releases were years apart but you're unhappy with a couple of months because it's a subscription? I can't follow this logic.

I was unhappy with the overall product/service. Since I was paying on a subscription basis, I'd spent less money over those months than I would have on a full release, so had more money to switch to an alternative. There's also no psychological burden of a sunk cost on the status quo - you feel free to switch at any time there's a better alternative.

My problems weren't that Adobe hadn't made general improvements in the six months time frame, it's that I had specific issues that they didn't address, and I didn't want to keep paying a monthly fee to be having those specific issues.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by tomnipotent on Sunday June 07, 2020 @06:05PM (#23451304)
> It's that I had specific issues that they didn't address, and I didn't want to keep paying a monthly fee to be having those specific issues.

So let me get this straight. Adobe has adopted a payment model that allows customer to more easily switch to alternatives (thanks to no large upfront cost), while simultaneously making more changes overall to the software over the same fixed-period of time, but because those changes didn't match your exact needs in the moment you had them you switched to an alternative?

How is Adobe the bad guy in this situation? Not necessarily saying your comment is painting Adobe negatively, but that seems to be the general feeling towards Adobe's subscription model in this thread.

It seems like a pretty good deal to be able to minimize your investment in a software product.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by Marsymars on Sunday June 07, 2020 @07:07PM (#23451875)
I don't have a problem with Adobe's subscription model - just providing my own anecdote about how subscription models saved me from giving Adobe money, and avoided software lock-in. I'm incentivizing faster improvements by only giving my subscription dollars to companies who deliver - and I can evaluate who delivers on a monthly basis.
Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by justinmeiners on Saturday June 06, 2020 @08:04PM (#23443473)
> Historical Adobe releases were years apart

Because they were new versions and they had to sell you on the upgrade.

Presumably one of the advantages of subscriptions is they can make ongoing improvements regularly as opposed to big releases. They release updates now, they just don't have many new features.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by tomnipotent on Sunday June 07, 2020 @05:30PM (#23451034)
> they just don't have many new features.

The feature cadence over a 2-year period doesn't look any different to me. The only change is you're getting piecemeal changes faster vs. a large number of changes all at once.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by trickldwn8nxjf on Saturday June 06, 2020 @08:54PM (#23443730)
Blender costs nothing and is used extensively throughout the digital media industry.

Presumably the advantages of a subscription is to cater to the meme “free == fascism”.

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by tomnipotent on Sunday June 07, 2020 @06:17PM (#23451408)
Blender is great. I use it myself (3D resin printing). But I've also used similar software I had to pay for, which was much better than Blender overall. Same way Photoshop is better than Gimp, and Windows UI is still better than Gnome/KDE. Sometimes to get great software and experience, you have to pay for it. And that's ok, it doesn't make the free software, like Blender, any less eff'ing awesome.
Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by vertis on Sunday June 07, 2020 @03:26AM (#23445472)
I can't justify an Adobe CC subscription since I use it so sporadically. A few months ago, I happened across Affinity Designer[1]. I bought it and I've been very happy. It has all of the functionality I would know how to use in Illustrator anyway.

Combined with Sketch, another non subscription product, it provides everything I need for the little UI design I do.

[1]:https://affinity.serif.com/en-gb/designer/

Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by cartoonfoxes on Saturday June 06, 2020 @08:37PM (#23443649)
The hand tool / spacebar panning has been broken for literally years now. It's disgraceful. Adobe can metaphorically go die in a fire.
Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by interestica on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:42PM (#23442960)
Adobe, please just fix bugs and stop taking away functionality. Exporting as SVG in Animate is under the "legacy" option and I figure they're going to take it away soon. There used to be multiple vector export options (svg, eps, fxg).
Re:SketchUp Goes Subscription-Only by ur-whale on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:44PM (#23443366)
They're just taking a leaf from Facebook and Apple's book and are walling off their ecosystem to keep you prisoner.

And there ain't a darn thing you can do about it other than switching to Open-Source.