News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by pjmlp on Saturday June 06, 2020 @05:26AM (#23437854)
Plenty of those can be better expressed in C++20, alongside clang tidy and VC++ analysers.

Compile time reflection and metaclasses already exist as VC++ prototype, demoed at Visual C++ 2020 virtual conference.

While I enjoy using Rust, what I care about are the libraries and IDE tooling, specially for .NET and Java integrations, so for better or worse, C++ keeps being the tool to pick.

Also I have big hopes for Rust/WinRT, but it is still very early for it to eventually reach C++/CX tooling, which even C++/WinRT is currently playing catch up and where WinUI team is placing their resources.

Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by carlmr on Saturday June 06, 2020 @06:17AM (#23438120)
>Plenty of those can be better expressed in C++20, alongside clang tidy and VC++ analysers.

Aside from lack of C++20 support on many targets, Clang tidy and extra analyzers require other people to take the same care as you do, an assumption that, as somebody mentioned in that article, is unreasonable to make in a non-solo project.

>Compile time reflection and metaclasses already exist as VC++ prototype, demoed at Visual C++ 2020 virtual conference.

A prototype in a Microsoft dialect of C++? That's apples and oranges.

>While I enjoy using Rust, what I care about are the libraries and IDE tooling

IDE tooling has gotten better, but of course that does still lag behind. While C++ build systems IMHO lag behind cargo, so for me that's a tie.

Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by pjmlp on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:56AM (#23438546)
It isn't a Microsoft dialect, rather what might be coming in ISO C++23.

Conan and vcpkg are already establishing themselves, and they have a killer feature over cargo, binary dependencies.

Also too many Rust libraries still reach out to unsafe, needlessly.

Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by ncmncm on Saturday June 06, 2020 @07:57AM (#23438552)
Willingness to lock oneself into corporate walled gardens never fails to mystify me.

To my understanding, the only reason Java was embraced with any enthusiasm in 1995 was as a way off of Microsoft's frameworks treadmill.

Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by pjmlp on Saturday June 06, 2020 @09:53AM (#23439177)
Then you will gladly refuse any contribution from Microsoft, Apple, Oracle, Google into Rust.

Better let Microsoft know about their mistake to sponsor Rust.

Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by ncmncm on Saturday June 06, 2020 @05:50PM (#23442533)
Whenever Microsoft can get people writing unportable software, and locked in again, they benefit; same for any corporate octopus.

We don't.

Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by pjmlp on Sunday June 07, 2020 @10:49AM (#23447727)
Yet the Rust community doesn't seem to think the same way as you.

I see the community quite happy with the corporate help it is receiving across the board.

Waiting to see you pushing a Rust fork, corporate free of any kind of contribution.

Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by ncmncm on Monday June 08, 2020 @07:14AM (#23455545)
You entirely miss the point.

Any resources MS provide to improve the compiler is an obvious pure win for Rust users. Likewise, any portable code they release.

But all the code other people write that only works in MS's walled garden benefits mainly Microsoft, at the wider community's expense.

I am astonished at the need to explain this, as if the last several decades had not happened.

Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by pjmlp on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @02:13AM (#23464173)
You are the one missing the point, either you embrace corporations support or not. There is no pick and choose here.

Plus what makes Microsoft bad, and Oracle, Apple and Google contributions good then?

I am astonished that FOSS religion keeps being a thing, while it has been proven in the last 25 years where most projects without corporate love end up.

Re:Why the developers who use Rust love it so much by ncmncm on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @03:00AM (#23464395)
Again you entirely miss the point.

Nobody but you has mentioned rejecting Microsoft contributions to the Rust compiler and library suite. Nobody but you has mentioned there being anything wrong with MS, GOOG, AAPL, ORCL or anybody else contributing to projects.

The topic is people who are not otherwise beholden to Microsoft (and, thus, not employed by Microsoft) writing code that works only in Microsoft execution environments.

I have explained this three times in this one thread. I don't know a way to make it any clearer. What is so hard to grasp about this distinction?