Bullshit. Spain, which was hit quite hard, already did widespread antibody studies and the result was that only about 5% of the population might have contracted it.
https://english.elpais.com/society/2020-05-14/antibody-study...
Educate yourself and please don't spread lies and ignorance.
Also, you picked 5%, but in your article they also say it's almost 15% in some areas. You're not spreading lies now, right?
What? 1 in 5 in a city is quite far from 90%, isn't it?
If you spew the "90% might have it" bullshit claim when you were fully aware that at best you know of a city which might have 20% then it looks like you are intentionally and knowingly spreading lies and false information. Don't do that.
> Also, you picked 5%, but in your article they also say it's almost 15% in some areas. You're not spreading lies now, right?
We were making global claims about how 90% might already contracted covid19. I presented a country-wide study, which as of today is the best and most extensive one done at a country-level.
The study points out a 5% infection rate in one of the countries which so far has been hit the hardest.
Do you have a problem with that study?
Moreover, the hotspot you cherry-picked refer to specific cities and municipalities. Soria, For example, barely has a population of 90k. Madrid comes second with 11%, which is 6% higher than the national average and still lower than 90%.
So even your cherry picking doesn't deflect the fact that your claim that 90% might have it is clearly bullshit and that you are knowingly and intentionally lying and spreading false information.
In actual trials, has a single one actually been shown to work reliably?
Here in the UK there's a new story every week about how yet another antibody test has been withdrawn or rejected by PHE because it wasn't accurate.
> From what we know, 90% of the population already could already have it.
Well, no, from what we know, 5% of the population in Spain - one of the hardest-hit countries in the world, I might add - had it.
Whether the seroprevalence is up to 15% in some areas is of no consequence to your original point.
> Also, you picked 5%
You mean, the actual title of the article and the average of the whole country?
> Antibody study shows just 5% of Spaniards have contracted the coronavirus
And there's plenty of unpleasant stories about long term effects. All in all I'm pretty scared of catching it.
I'm glad you're young and fit and happy to accept the lower risk.
I'm not so happy about your lack of concern for others.
AIDS is a good example of this. It's more deadly than coronavirus, but because it was seen as a disease of gay people, governments initially invested extremely little in treatment or stopping the spread. According to WHO, 32 million people have died of AIDS since it appeared, and most of those deaths would have been prevented with easy access to and faster development of the antivirals now used to treat it in rich countries.
Malaria is another one. It kills hundreds of thousands of people each year (mostly in Africa), and is largely preventable by relatively simply approaches like mosquito nets. For a small fraction of the trillions of dollars involved in trying to stop covid19, most of these fatalities could be prevented.
Are you concerned about the tens of millions of people who lost their jobs and businesses? Losing your job is a pretty horrible experience too, especially for the low-income groups who are most affected by the lockdown. What about the people whose mental health has been shattered by forced social isolation; "A year's worth of suicide attempts in the last four weeks": https://abc7news.com/suicide-covid-19-coronavirus-rates-duri...
In fairness I guess I was reacting less to your specific comment and more to the chunk of this community that seems to think anyone under 60 should be running through the streets with joyous abandon.
This I agree with. I'd argue however that most countries have done a terrible job of it, e.g. nobody has published a cost-benefit analysis expressed in some kind of comparable unit like QALY (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year). Seems most analysis either only looks at the cost or only looks at the benefits, or makes no attempt to quantify them. Maybe it's not politically appealing to put a number on human lives, but that's what public health officials routinely do when dealing with other issues, because otherwise it's impossible to make consistent comparisons and judgements.
>more to the chunk of this community that seems to think anyone under 60 should be running through the streets with joyous abandon.
This is a consequence of the lockdowns that some people anticipated. I.e. much like making drugs illegal isn't necessarily the most scientifically effective way to reduce drug usage, forcing everybody to stay at home isn't necesssarily the best way to keep everyone at home. People forced into something are less likely to comply for a long time than people who decided to do something of their own free will, or were otherwise persuaded to.
Keeping most of the population who is not at risk from developing herd immunity is lengthening the time of exposure for the people who are at risk.
Just the fact we haven't updated our strategy at all after getting data on the age distributions is pretty bad.
While we may have to face this outcome I think it's too early to do so until we have more data and a deeper understanding of the disease.
In the UK I get the impression that the population is more cautious about loosening the lock down than the government is. I think other countries are the same. The US might be the outlier here.
eg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zPLx4cVJW10
(Koch may be retired now, but don't think we're out of the woods yet — we're still in double digits)
So we are going to base our global health strategy on your "hunch"?
Any source on this?
GP knows that their argument is wrong, and is deliberately lying.
It is a huge country and it was "so many flights" from China, instead of "so many flights" from Hubei province.
If it's hard to wrap this try swap China and the US.
- there are direct flights from Wuhan (and Shanghai, #8 in the world) to SFO (Trump stopped the Chinese flights Jan. 31, but Chinese travellers were detouring through Africa and Europe in Feb.)
- but local travel outside Wuhan was restricted (latest Jan. 23, Disneyworld Shanghai was closed Jan. 24)
- the Cambridge and Washington corona models are overly pessimistic and start late - the first Wuhan hospitalization was Dec. 1, and with the direct flights to SFO, corona was in the US in mid-Dec.
What's hard for you and other HNers to wrap your head around is that all the reported information is completely wrong.
The best source I've seen so far is this:
The Failure of Expert Predictions and Models | The Coronavirus and Public Policy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mG2vdyfLv7U
Dr. Victor Davis Hanson also has about 3 interviews that add to that. Search Youtube for "covid-19 victor davis hanson"
(We independently came to the identical analysis of corona for California, literally word-for-word, which is the opposite of the sensationalist news media. The Santa Clara hospital dashboard confirms this, being flat for months.)
I don't have any sources for this, but living in Switzerland, and from what I am hearing from local sources - nobody is being turned away from being tested. I don't believe your statement being true for Switzerland. Early measures, people generally following guidelines has helped reduce the spread of the virus here in Switzerland.
Really? Any examples?
0. https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/494324-27m-new-yorkers...
Definitely it's not from-what-we-know-90%-of-the-population-had-it huge.
And those are the numbers from one of the most affected places in the world.
Governments are both not doing widespread testing to see how many people have the virus, and taking draconian measures to contain its spread.
From what we know, 90% of the population already could already have it. Every time I read of somebody testing a big group of people a huge percentage has it, but the virus is so mild that they didn't even know—since it caused no symptoms.
Looks like there are many other diseases and problems that cause dozen of times more deaths, so either there's a reason why this is getting special treatment, or it's just a complete loss of common sense here, in my opinion.