News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by human on Thursday June 04, 2020 @10:28AM (#23416958)
Listening to that argument is a clear “catch 22”. If he quits his job, it’s not much of a stance but obviously staying is not a stance either. What was he supposed to do? I think that in a capitalist country we choose who we buy from and who we work for. These are two powerful choices that can shape society. He’s doing the right thing.
Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by luckylion on Thursday June 04, 2020 @10:54AM (#23417386)
> He’s doing the right thing.

He worked at Facebook, let's not get carried away.

Working at Facebook and then leaving because of the non-intervention wrt to the President is a bit like manufacturing landmines quite happily, but having a change of heart because you saw a dog stepping on one. You've still been manufacturing landmines all that time, making money and not giving a damn.

Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by mauvehaus on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:13AM (#23417696)
Beating people up for not having your morals is not a great way to get them on your side.

Facebook has been on my list of companies not to work at for a long time, but I have friends who work there. Accepting that other people value different things and being willing to interact with them on a basic, human level is a lot more likely to build bridges and lead to constructive conversation about important matters down the road than casting people aside because they don't conform to your worldview today.

I'll grant you that Facebook, among others, enables exactly the sort of thing I'm advocating against. I'll grant you that it seems to promote people yelling at each other over the internet instead of building the relationships that enable difficult conversations in time. And I'll grant you that they do it to sell ads for shit we mostly don't need.

But that doesn't make everybody who works there bad, and it doesn't mean that people who decide that continuing to work there is no longer consistent with their values should be equated with merchants of death when they publicly leave.

You're castigating somebody for voting with their feet, but presumably mostly because they didn't do it as soon as you did.

Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by luckylion on Thursday June 04, 2020 @12:45PM (#23418867)
> You're castigating somebody for voting with their feet, but presumably mostly because they didn't do it as soon as you did.

No. I'm saying they did always vote with their feet. And "get money, fuck society" was the vote they cast.

Facebook isn't the army, there is no draft, they had and have plenty of other options. It's greed and a general feeling of superiority that sees the general population the same way the owners of factory farms see pigs.

Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by tjchear on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:25AM (#23417866)
That analogy does not work though. Landmine's sole purpose is to kill/injure whoever steps on it. I don't use Facebook much, but plenty of people have benefited from it.

Instead of personal cost to him, I'd rather view it through the lenses of the impact of his action. It's inviting a lot of constructive conversation and making people re-evaluate Mark's decisions, which I think overall is a net positive.

Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by luckylion on Thursday June 04, 2020 @12:47PM (#23418902)
> I don't use Facebook much, but plenty of people have benefited from it.

Namely those who hold stock options or who used it to hyper target unsuspecting fools and scam them.

> Instead of personal cost to him, I'd rather view it through the lenses of the impact of his action.

Let's. The "constructive conversation" has been going on already. This doesn't move the needle on that conversation, it's not one with a lot of grey area where the world is on the fence. This is great - for him. But not much else.

Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by tjchear on Friday June 05, 2020 @05:36AM (#23426616)
> Namely those who hold stock options

Oh sure those too. But small businesses benefit from it immensely, e.g using fb live and fb groups to connect with their customers for example.

> Let's. The "constructive conversation" has been going on already. This doesn't move the needle on that conversation, it's not one with a lot of grey area where the world is on the fence. This is great - for him. But not much else.

If that's the case, what do you think he should have done, or we should have done?

Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by majewsky on Thursday June 04, 2020 @10:32AM (#23417030)
> obviously staying is not a stance either

This is not obvious to me.

Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by thomasfedb on Thursday June 04, 2020 @10:39AM (#23417146)
I think the suggestion here is: if you are in a position to leave your job, and you do not, then than is implicit support for your employer.
Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by indigochill on Thursday June 04, 2020 @10:52AM (#23417354)
I might even say explicit support. After all, how better to support a company than directly working for them? In some business models you're probably generating more value for the company working for them than you would as a customer.
Re:I'm resigning from my job at Facebook by majewsky on Thursday June 04, 2020 @02:16PM (#23419906)
Ah sorry, I think I parsed this wrong. I thought it meant "no stance" instead of "not much of a stance".