Edit: Nevermind. The author of the article is the bit-coin investor how first tweeted about Chloroquine being a potential cure, https://www.wired.com/story/an-old-malaria-drug-may-fight-co...
It wasn't anything particularly intensive, just making sure the other sources said the same thing. But it was still a lot of work.
For most people, learning is a lot of work in and itself.
The scientific community purportedly polices itself.
It also is a twist on all the calls for the importance of rigorous peer-reviewed studies, as if the preprint flood is just an example of why we need traditional academic structures. Here's a case where we needed the traditional academic structure and it failed miserably, even when prestigious institutions.
The irony is that this is being caught, but outside the confines of the traditional peer review. That is, there is peer review, but in the general public of scientists. So which is better? It seems like open publication and transparency is key, more so than the traditional structures per se.
What appears to have happened here is that a rapid peer-review gave the benefit of the doubt to a purported data source, and then the community rapidly discovered that the data source was not behaving honestly. All of this occurred in a matter of a few weeks, during a time when peer-review is almost certainly moving even faster than normal due to the urgency of the pandemic.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23412482
Look at the all the infrastructure involved there, all the automatic tests that exist in the originating infrastructure, and still only 1) an independent fuzzing test by the company with the most computers in the world 2) the work of the leader of another project; bring "medial" attention to the existence of the problem.
Nothing can be always perfect in the first try.
In science specifically, the "intentional frauds" aren't the starting assumption of those who do review, that's why the frauds manage to pass the checks that do work most of the time.
"Falsehood flies, and truth comes limping after it." Johnatan Swift (1667-1745)
Genuine question: What else is it assumed WHO may have made the decision based on?
The media sells it as a clickbait story "All trials STOPPED because of a flawed study" implying they were stopped PERMANENTLY to excite the general audience. For them it is entirely something that brings them huge revenue from ads when they write such "emotinally driven" stories, they do not care about the effects it has on the public in the long term by reducing faith in world health organizations.
Or even the direct effects on the public in terms of healthcare.
The article makes a strong case the Surgisphere is shady and the study is badly made but other than timing (paper published 22, ban started 25th) the article does not provide any further information that the Surgisphere study was the source of the WHO decision.
I quoted the unsupported accusation below.
Instead of performing its own due diligence, the WHO immediately relied on an observational study cloaked in the reputation of the nearly 200-year old medical journal The Lancet.