Re:Show HN: PodCastle - Reddit for podcasts
by roryokane on Friday March 18, 2011 @01:30PM
(#2341152)
For the first instant I saw the page, I thought it was one of those spammy, ad-filled domain placeholder pages. It's because the design is similar - boxy, list of links, no images. I'm not sure if that first impression will actually drive people away, but you think it might, you should change the design a little to distinguish your site from those placeholder sites. Perhaps adding a podcast-related image or a large logo to the main page would work.
Re:Show HN: PodCastle - Reddit for podcasts
by spaetzel on Friday March 18, 2011 @01:44PM
(#2341204)
Note, I'm the developer of CastRoller.
I was able to submit that episode by getting the RSS feed from the podcast's main page (http://castroller.com/Podcasts/BigIdeas) and submitting that directly.
I don't know if PodCastle is able to pick up the MP3 on the CastRoller episode page.
Re:Show HN: PodCastle - Reddit for podcasts
by sorbus on Friday March 18, 2011 @01:37PM
(#2341186)
Might be worth noting that there's already a podcast called Podcastle, so that might present some naming issues - I was confused for the first few seconds.
Also, seconding what roryokane said, your design does not look good. It's bland, it's boring, and it looks a bit spammy.
Re:Show HN: PodCastle - Reddit for podcasts
by glenngillen on Friday March 18, 2011 @01:54PM
(#2341243)
Really loving some of the things happening in the "podcast" space lately (check http://said.fm/ for another approach). Does make me wonder why it's taken so long for these types of services to come to market though, I've been after decent way to discover interesting content outside of iTunes for years.
But was obviously not motivated enough to do anything about it myself :/
Re:Show HN: PodCastle - Reddit for podcasts
by KevBurnsJr on Friday March 18, 2011 @01:28PM
(#2341143)
Working on ways around this. Reason for lag right now is that iPhone requires that play events come from a UI event rather than any arbitrary javascript function call. To get one-click play on the homepage, you have to load all 40 players on page load. The alternative is 2-click play. 1 click to load player, 1 click to play. Opted for 1-click and laggy over 2 click and snappy.
Re:Show HN: PodCastle - Reddit for podcasts
by colkassad on Friday March 18, 2011 @05:38PM
(#2342087)
Ah, I see. I didn't even notice you could click once to play (the play icon should have been obvious to me). Honestly, I would always click through to the description anyway to see what's up, unless it was a podcast that I regularly listen to.
Re:Show HN: PodCastle - Reddit for podcasts
by beagledude on Friday March 18, 2011 @03:18PM
(#2341581)
I listen to podcasts 2 hours a day on my drive to/from work. Looking forward to you expanding on the site, keyword searches, tags, descriptions would be nice
Re:Show HN: PodCastle - Reddit for podcasts
by shaunxcode on Friday March 18, 2011 @09:34PM
(#2342701)
Isn't reddit primarily about the comments/community? I don't see a way of logging in/creating a throwaway account or commenting on the particular podcasts?
And it failed. What exactly do I need to submit?
I was able to submit that episode by getting the RSS feed from the podcast's main page (http://castroller.com/Podcasts/BigIdeas) and submitting that directly.
I don't know if PodCastle is able to pick up the MP3 on the CastRoller episode page.
The episode is on PodCastle here: http://podcastle.us/e/CMB5V
Also, seconding what roryokane said, your design does not look good. It's bland, it's boring, and it looks a bit spammy.
Namespace collision proved non-fatal, but still a bit confusing.
But was obviously not motivated enough to do anything about it myself :/
- the dev show, good combination
- on the internet, entertaining
It keeps crashing my tabs in Chrome OS X