Canadian telecom policy still revolves around "facilities-based competition", where it's believed that new entrants should build out a new network. It's designed to fail. Even the incumbents, Bell and Telus, share a 3G/4G mobile network to avoid redundant infrastructure. Ironically, the two contracted Huawei and Nokia to build out this network: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/technology/bell-teams-up-wit...
Huawei was marketing 5G directly to Canadian consumers for a while, but was careful to never mention/imply that 5G could lower pricing. That would be a thermonuclear threat to telecoms with dire consequences.
One of the least dense provinces, Saskatchewan, has some of the best pricing in the country because the government has yet to selloff the provincial telecom to private investors. Manitoba too before they decided to privatize and sell off to an incumbent.
And high-density is no panacea for cost. Tall concrete buildings everywhere can mean more infrastructure costs. Especially if regulations require you to fit infrastructure into the facade. Medium-density is the least engineering: Just put up a tower and call it a day. And in Canada, antenna permits are federal. Once issued, local govs can't stop you from putting up your monstrosity of white panels on a midrise or a big metal antenna.
But you don't have to just compare Canada against the USA. Australia or Iceland have rates that Canadians can only dream of, with similarly geo-population situations.
Some of us are excited to see how systems such as StarLink develop, maybe bringing decent rural access to the network is in the cards.
Next time you make a page that requires 10Mb of assets before loading, please remember there are people dealing with terrible connections. I know my first 100mbps connection was a godsend.
More imporatanly, as someone in AB I am jealous of their cheap phone plans...
> Australia or Iceland have rates that Canadians can only dream of, with similarly geo-population situations
I worked on the NBN in Australia -- they've got their fair share of ISP-related issues down under.
Streaming games on my Mac from Google Stadia in perfect lag-free 1080p!
Which works for me because I am mostly on wifi or (current situation notwithstanding) on a very short commute.
(7GB data would be no good at all for me - I'd burn through that in about 30 minutes!)
We also tried to implement more carriers several years ago, with a wireless spectrum auction that reserved spectrum for new entrants. These startups tried to focus solely on urban areas with their build outs, and then could roam on the big 3, but struggled immensely. IIRC, one of the big complaints was we don't allow foreign ownership, which made it difficult to raise the immense capital needed for a proper build out. How much that plays into it I don't know, but unless Canadians want to put together a massive amount of capital it seems unlikely to force stronger competition.
In rural areas, using 1.7Ghz vs 600Mhz or 700Mhz spectrum means building 4x the amount of towers to cover the same square miles.
That's opex, capex *4. It's really expensive, with no benefits at all as you're not capacity constrained at all on radios/spectrum in rural areas.
The solution is to share infrastructure in sparsely populated areas where it would be uneconomic for each operator to build it's own.
The UK, despite being vastly smaller and denser than Canada, has long had poor mobile coverage in rural areas.
The UK government is now requiring (and contributing funding towards) geographical 95% coverage by 2026. Operators will use shared rural infrastructure to achieve this.
This isn't a case of looking at a map and population count whatsoever. It's an incredibly moot point when you look at where 95% of people live in both countries.
In the US* the connections aren't great, either. Not as bad as Germany, but in general I got slower practical speeds almost all over the country (and the big cities like NYC were terrible).
In Canada I got excellent 4G performance when driving the whole way between Saskatoon and Calgary as well as any time I take the train between Toronto and Montreal.
* I've been told Verizon is the best quality network in the States, but I have only been able to get prepaid plans from AT&T and T-Mobile.
Rogers wants $75/mth (CAD - $55 USD) for 10GB data and unlimited talk and text. Let's compare to the US:
- AT&T wants 65++ USD ($87 CAD) for a comparable plan.
- Verizon wants 70++ USD ($94 CAD) for a comparable plan.
- TMo wants 70 (all in) USD ($94 CAD) for a comparable plan.
And each network in Canada is dramatically better than AT&T and TMo, and roughly comparable to Verizon.
Back in the day, there was a huge difference, these days, it's kinda the same. I remember when the iPhone first came out and you could get an unlimited AT&T plan for $60/mth and Rogers wanted $120++. Those days are long past, though.
So how do you make yourself look better. Do not provide the data for the report. Canada has been removed from the list. No longer the worst.
[1] https://www.huffingtonpost.ca/entry/tefficient-canada-wirele...
https://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans/magenta
Unlimited everything... Even 5 gig of data when in Canada.
I don't think Rogers, Telus or Bell have anything close to that.
Or at least that's what the rogers rep told me.
https://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans
The Canadian networks are “better” because every Canadian rations their usage. I’d wager that Canadian networks are wayyyy underprovisioned compared to even the crappiest US network.
Check out the top div on that page, you'll see they conveniently want to sign up both you and everyone you know to qualify for that rate. I priced it for a single line in both the US and Canada. With that in mind TMo is a huge outlier in the US, too, and John Legere is responsible for singlehandedly dragging AT&T and VZW kicking and screaming into the 21st century of pricing over the last 5-6 years.
They also have far and away the worst network in the US, trust me, I've used them for years -- and love them. Their network is still hot garbage though. Frankly the best TMobile network you can get is when you roam onto Rogers, Bell or Telus in Canada.
The 5G plan includes 80GB traffic for the same package.
++++++++++
I'm actually using this 2EUR plan as my main internet service at the moment, as I temporarily moved to the country side. I could get a 1Gbps FTTH connection for around 10 EUR per month ( or cheaper for lower bandwidth), but so far I decided not to bother.
50GB did last me for 20 days, with a lot of video content, some repos downloaded, arch package updates etc. The 256kbps limit I'm experiencing now is more than ok for anything text-based but YouTube only works seamlessly/without buffering in 240p.
Here in the UK, the government has grand ambitions, but it doesn't really materialise. Most people with "fibre" broadband are limited to 20-60Mbps. Although if you live in a major city you can get 200-300Mbps.The infrastructure is ancient, and by taking half measures they spend more in the long run for far less.
This is something that annoys me about 5G. It will cost a fortune to roll out (making data so expensive it won't be fully utilised). 4G on my phone right now is 35Mbps. 5G is more a tickbox exercise than bringing better connectivity to people.
</rant>
The biggest issue with 4G is the price, with 5G's limited range it will cost a fortune to roll out, so I doubt it will make data any cheaper.
Don't get me wrong, 5G does have it's pros. Rolling it out to areas that are saturated totally makes sense (plus better wifi). I don't see the benefit of rolling it out everywhere when we're not even fully utilising 4G. My router is providing both 2.4ghz and 5ghz wifi; 2.4ghz for range and compatibility with the smart devices. 5Ghz for speed within a limited range.
I worked for a (very) large Canadian telcom for 4 years.
What you said is absolutely 100% correct.
In my region my employer was forced to allow competition in the internet space, and they submitted rates to the CRTC that were astronomical. The CRTC replied and said they would force them to lower the rates, so my employer said they would stop building out their fibre network expansion.
The CRTC caved, the telco got it's way, and to this day the ISP with the largest operating area of any on the planet has zero competition.
It's easy to say that, but Canada has a smaller population than California, but spread over the surface area larger than that of the United States. How many carriers, and how much competition, can you possibly expect in that environment? Especially in an industry that requires so much infrastructure.
Canada at the national level has Bell, Telus and Rogers/Fido. There's a few more regional players like Freedom Mobile, and then there's Videotron in Quebec.
Then on top of that there's the former Crown Corporation (now subsidiary of Bell/BCE) NorthwesTel, which provides services in the Territories (i.e the north of the north, the Yukon, the Northwest Territories and Nunavut).
That is an extremely misleading statement. Approximately 75% of Canada's population lives within 150km of the US border, and even that is not a uniform distribution , there are dense urban population clusters.
Around 30% of the total Canadian population is in the Greater Toronto Area, and if you toss in the most populous Quebecois (Montreal-Trois-Rivieres-Quebec) cities that number is around 50%.[1]
You see the same thing in the US and Australia as well -- the Eastern coasts were settled first, and that's where the population is to this day.[2]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_of_Canada_by_provin... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_megalopolis
And then there's the geography. You can drive to each major point in California in a couple hours, but it's not as easy to get to Moose Factory or Fort Mac, let alone lay the backhaul to supply the towers in the middle of absolutely nowhere.
Canadians could only dream of their rates.
[1] https://www.cellmapper.net/map?MCC=274&MNC=1&type=LTE&latitu...
I'd bet pricing would be comparable if Bell's network just extended along the Trans Canada Highway, and in each major city. Even that's not a fair comparison since Iceland is literally encircled, so you never need to drive more than half the length to get between any two points.
And Iceland isn’t exactly flat/seismologically stable.
If anything, Canadian rates should be far cheaper than Iceland’s because Canada telcos only cover a small fraction of the landmass.
Outside of AB and Sask, the coverage usually is along the trans-Canada and populated pockets.
I'm not aware of what was going on behind the scenes. It could easily have been that the Canadian government told the telecoms a long time ago that they wouldn't be allowed to use Huawei, but kept this secret for the sake of contract negotiations. Do you know this not to be the case?
I figure the government ran its Huawei-ban proposal by the telcos and they balked and said: "don't regulate it, we'll just not choose them". It's a direct access to government influence that the public could only dream of. Meanwhile, the public gets told "well, if you don't like being ignored when new laws are created/passed, vote for someone else in [0-4] years".
Basically, just pissed that CDN telecoms get to craft the law (or lack thereof) in their favour.
Didn’t CRTC force the incumbents to sell wholesale network access to new players like Freedom Mobile?
I think the voice pricing out-of-network was okay, but the incumbents definitely cooked the books on their costs on data.
They once had a plan for $39 with 6gb data and unlimited calls/LD in-network and anywhere in USA. But it had small limits for out-of-network in Canada.
Meanwhile, they incumbents charge cheap-enough prices to American or French providers so they can allow their subscribers roam in Canada with many gb included in the base plan. A French subscriber roaming in Canada would have 5x the data as a local plan at half the cost.
Koodo was offering it for $0 additional dollars on their "medium tab" plan ($15/mo for 24 mos). The other options were pretty bad.
I don't really have a lot of brand loyalty when it comes to phones, as I don't use a ton of apps, and the ones I use the most are the browser, email and some messaging apps. I also don't really use the camera as much as most other people. I just want something cheap and fast that can last 3 years or more.
But they can't with the ban-but-not-a-ban on Huawei. It would be too obvious that there was a ban if providers scrubbed Huawei consumer products entirely, and those consumers pay the price.
And while you have the option to not buy them, it's not so easy to avoid communication with anyone with a Huawei device.
> But if Huawei is a Chinese spy
Has Huawei been caught with a smoking gun? Is Huawei worse in terms of security compared to other telecom suppliers?
If (national) security is really Canada's top priority, it seems the most needed ban is on American consumer products/websites [0]?
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program)
2) US is a democracy with an independent judiciary and media. China is not.
If govs knew, they wouldn't publish it to avoid straining already strained relationships. But would do behind-the-scenes work to keep Huawei out of critical infrastructure.
Edit: the risk may be theoretical, but we know all equipment can be bugged. Not a terrible decision to be bugged by a close ally.
Canada is happy to share data with USA and vice-versa. Perhaps gov should fear USA more, but currently they don't.
I don't follow; the Western world has put sanctions on China in the past [0], I don't think they would avoid straining their relationships with China in a situation like this.
> Canada is happy to share data with USA and vice-versa.
I don't think sharing is the same as being spied on... Or you mean Canada and America are sharing the information obtained via spying? That would make sense.
[0]: https://www.cnn.com/2018/06/04/opinions/tiananmen-sanctions-...
Those weren't economic sanctions, but focussed ones. And against a much less economically-important China. If China cutoff a country in '89, whatever. In '20, uh oh.
The US already strong-armed Canada into arresting Huawei's CFO/founder's daughter. Things are a bit strained at the moment.
The lifting of some of those sanctions probably helped China become as economically-important as they are now.
I remember buying computer hardware in the 80s and 90s. There was always a threatening information slip or page in the box that warned about penalties against export of the technology to countries like China. And now? Most of that export-controlled stuff is produced there.
that's exactly why you shouldn't use American network equipment. The Canadian government cannot spy on Canadian citizens due to legal restriction. So instead it tells the CIA to spy on you and then share what they learnt through the intelligence alliance.
If you don't trust who you're communicating with to follow the same measures, then you shouldn't be sending them your secrets.
Many Canadians were frustrated by this, feeling like they didn't want Huawei networks but that they weren't being heard.
It occurs to me now that had any of those steps been taken before reaching a deal with Ericsson, it would have given Ericsson a much stronger bargaining position and they probably could have charged a lot more.
This isn't the first time where I've felt frustrated, unheard, and kept in the dark, only to later realize that there may have been important considerations that I just wasn't aware of.