The point is that an order to siege an American city would not be unlawful, under the Insurrection Act, because there are parts of the Act that give a lot of discretion to the President about when to use force. That siege order could be legal.
At that point, disobeying has to be a moral act, and the law isn’t a concern anymore.
I say this living in an apartment about three blocks from a tank in Los Angeles.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act?
by cryptonector on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:55AM
(#23388379)
By the way, the U.S. armed forces includes in its ranks a small army of lawyers. That doesn't mean they'll necessarily identify unlawful orders as such and refuse to comply. But it's something.
United States vs Keenan being one example — soldiers need to obey lawful orders, but obeying unlawful orders puts them at risk of criminal prosecution.