News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by jeffdavis on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:35AM (#23387828)
The fact that it was used in '92 for riots means it will be hard to challenge.

I feel it is an afront to the Constitution and the founders' intent, though. The Second Amendment is there, in part, to avoid the need for a standing military at all, because standing armies have a tendancy to be turned on the people.

Another reason the Second Amendment exists is so that citizens can remove their local police and protect themselves until they organize a new poloce force. A bit better organization could have put that into effect in Minneapolis.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by cryptonector on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:51AM (#23388356)
> The fact that it was used in '92 for riots means it will be hard to challenge.

I don't think there is any question about the constitutionality of the Act. I don't think there was any question about the constitutionality of the act in 1992 either. There might be a question about a particular application of it, however.

> I feel it is an afront to the Constitution and the founders' intent, though.

Article I, section 8 of the Constitution says Congress gets to deal with insurrection: "To provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions;"

Well, the Insurrection Act, passed a mere 20 years after the Constitution was written, before the last founder President, does exactly what the bit of the Constitution I quoted says. There had been revolts within Washington's presidency, which he himself put down in the field (not from his residence or office).

> Another reason the Second Amendment exists is so that citizens can remove their local police and protect themselves until they organize a new poloce force.

There was no police in 1787, or in 1807 for that matter. There was also no standing army. The militia was all there was, and the militia was just armed citizens. Certainly, many believe that the Second Amendment's purpose is to make feasible a revolt / tyranny difficult to impose, so in that sense you're right, but there was no police in 1807.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by jeffdavis on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @03:35AM (#23388614)
But the militia was imagined as a different thing than a standing professional army
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by cryptonector on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @10:58AM (#23391705)
Indeed, but when did I say otherwise? You said the militia existed to overthrow a then-unimagined police, but clearly that's not the case (because there was no police).
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by jeffdavis on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @11:27AM (#23392031)
Self defense is the general principle, and one of the things it offers is independence from the police.

A long time ago maybe that meant not having police at all, today it means that the police can be fired.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by cryptonector on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:20PM (#23394196)
Armed revolt certainly can be good, though it can also be bad, and the victors will decide. For example, the Founders were traitors to the British, and all then-still-alive ones would have hung if the War had been lost. That means if you're going to have an armed revolt, you'll want to make sure you win. Even now we're far from what you have in mind.

Civil war ideation is probably not productive at this time nor generally -- let it always be a remote possibility, possible, yes, but remote and unwanted. We're seeing a fair bit of legislative and social change right now, and we can expect more; there's no need to start killing people or threatening to or fantasizing about it.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by jeffdavis on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:47AM (#23418170)
Why do you think I want a violent revolt?

If you can protect yourself, you can simply (along with fellow voters) abolish the police. Once they stop getting paychecks, they will go home peacefully.

Without private gun ownership, abolishing the police would be too painful because you'd be at the mercy of the strongest criminals. Private gun ownership at least affords some protecting while you reform.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by tmaly on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @10:14AM (#23391209)
I recall there was a rebellion by the veterans of the war for independence. They were poorly supported and after we won independence from Britain they stirred up.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by xxpor on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:14AM (#23388097)
>the founders' intent, though

Are you sure about that? I feel like the Whiskey Rebellion does away with that idea.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by billme on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:24AM (#23388168)
Agree, Whiskey Rebellion at the very least made clear George Washington’s position on the matter; he personally attended to the assault on the rebels.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by 0x8BADF00D on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:49AM (#23388337)
There is still the Posse Comitatus Act, which limits the use of the military for domestic purposes.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by cryptonector on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:52AM (#23388362)
The PCA has an explicit exception for use in accordance with the Insurrection Act. FYI.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by pjc50 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:47AM (#23387900)
Just to be clear, you're advocating at best the Black Panther strategy? Or just straight up shooting at police?
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by jeffdavis on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:37AM (#23388252)
No. Without the second amendment, you are dependent on police for safety -- so dependent that there is little you won't put up with.

With the second amendment, you can simply fire the police without (as much) worry for your family's safety. It would still be bad, but at least you have an option.

So it's not necessarily a violent confrontation. You just get a mayor in place that will stop paying them. A large group of people can often get a mayor to do something if they have a specific proposal.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by billme on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:54AM (#23387948)
Disbanding the existing police force is possible without conflict, though it would require the local government taking action, having a plan, etc.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by pjc50 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @04:33AM (#23388950)
May I suggest a template: https://www.irishtimes.com/news/ruc-will-cease-to-exist-as-n...

The "replacement" of the RUC with the PSNI was achieved without interruption or total turnover of personnel, but managed to change the ethos and image enough to bring peace enough to Northern Ireland. At the same time, the troops with a record of shooting civilians were withdrawn from the streets.

It's not perfect, but it's definitely a success.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by adrianN on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:04AM (#23388025)
Where I live we have trouble training enough new police officers to keep the number of officers stable or slightly increasing. I can't imagine that replacing the whole force is possible in the short term.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by jeffdavis on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @03:34AM (#23388601)
The point is, if citizens are armed, they can keep the peace (more or less) without police for a while.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by adrianN on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @03:55AM (#23388741)
I don't think that the peace comes from guns. Police in my country very rarely use theirs. And "for a while" can be quite long if you need to find and train a complete new police force. Besides, I'd rather have somewhat trained but biased and bad police officers, than a completely untrained mob enforcing the law.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by adt2bt on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @04:28AM (#23388917)
I agree. It feels very American to believe we cannot keep peace without the persistent threat of having your life ended.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @04:32AM (#23388945)
> I don't think that the peace comes from guns. Police in my country very rarely use theirs.

It comes from having them, not from using them. You don't have to shoot at gangs robbing everybody at knifepoint if the threat of getting shot deters them from going around robbing everybody at knifepoint.

> And "for a while" can be quite long if you need to find and train a complete new police force.

In practice most of what the police do is paperwork and interviews. If the general population is armed (so the deterrent is still there) then you could take the guns away from the police and never have them leave the police station and still almost all of the policework would get done.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by adrianN on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @04:39AM (#23388986)
How would that work in practice? Say I have a traffic accident and the other party is uncooperative. We both threaten to use our guns unless the other party admits fault and then somehow the necessary paperwork for an insurance claim gets done?

Or my neighbors decide that 2am is a great time for some jackhammering. I threaten to shoot them unless they stop? They threaten to shoot me in turn?

Does this depend on righteous mobs of gun owners assembling and holding an impromptu court martial?

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @04:44AM (#23389008)
> Say I have a traffic accident and the other party is uncooperative.

You take a picture of their license plate number and bring it to a courthouse. They show up in court or the court gives you a default judgement and orders their insurance/bank to give you the money.

> Or my neighbors decide that 2am is a great time for some jackhammering.

You make a timestamped recording of the jackhammering and bring it to a courthouse. Do you see where this is going? You don't need police to have courts.

And most of the time you don't even need to use the courts for the same reason you don't need to use the guns -- the other party can predict what will happen and it's easier for everybody to settle things and not go there.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by adrianN on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @04:46AM (#23389019)
What if I don't want the jackhammering to continue for a year until I have my court date? What if my neighbors don't give a fuck about court dates?
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @04:55AM (#23389075)
What happens in that case now? The police show up, they agree to stop and then don't, you call the police again, they agree to stop and then don't. You're still in court if you want them to stop and they won't, and they still actually stop because they don't want to end up in court. (You could also write to your legislators to hire enough judges that you don't have to wait a year for a court date.)

And if they don't show up in court then you win and the court fines them.

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by adrianN on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @05:50AM (#23389367)
I'm reasonably sure that the police would take away their jackhammer and/or arrest them after repeated calls.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday June 03, 2020 @02:51AM (#23400668)
People generally don't get arrested or have their stuff stolen over noise complaints. More likely they'd issue a citation, which is really just a piece of paper that leads to a court date, i.e. the same thing you can get by bringing your evidence to a judge/prosecutor.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by Koshkin on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @08:20AM (#23390187)
In theory there’s nothing wrong with jackhammering at 2am. This is just the classical issue of the will of one (or a few) vs. the will of the many. (Imagine yourself being the only one who doesn’t do the jackhammering at 2am.)
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by zaphirplane on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @06:31AM (#23389532)
You live in a country with civilian political control of the police. Police miss behaving/corruption/brutality/public execution are political problems. A mayor/governor can sack the police and they will hand in their badges and walk away.

The reason it doesn’t happen is because society allows the political to not hold the police accountable.

There is no possibility of sacked police execution a coup , it isn’t an armed confrontation problem

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by pjc50 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @04:34AM (#23388959)
The question at issue in the protest is protecting the citizens from the police.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by dividedbyzero on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @04:12AM (#23388830)
In the current political climate, I just can't picture that not ending in horrible carnage.
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by billme on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:14AM (#23388094)
Obviously would not be easy, but it is possible:

https://www.governing.com/topics/public-justice-safety/gov-c...

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by kirykl on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @03:09AM (#23388467)
They replaced the force with itself mostly tho:

“ The Camden County Police Department rehired most of the laid-off cops, along with nearly 100 other officers, but at much lower salaries and with fewer benefits than they had received from the city.”

Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by csharptwdec19 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @10:40AM (#23391497)
Re:What Is The Insurrection Act? by 0x8BADF00D on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:54AM (#23388374)
One possible solution is to deputize local law abiding citizens temporarily. And rehire officers that undergo stricter training.