A common carrier must strictly avoid regulating the content of their carriage.
There are different regulations in place for different businesses. A common carrier must scrupulously avoid even the appearance of modifying or restricting the information they carry.
The grey areas lurk in what publishers condone and promote: what constitutes hate speech or child pornography and is subject to reasonable restrictions on speech in a free and democratic society at one end of the spectrum, and what constitutes political campaigning and is subject to campaign finance and political contribution laws at another.
It’s a company. Of course that’s its motive. I’d argue this is true for most people, too.
Which is fine. It is incumbent upon those users whose free speech Reddit impinges upon to rectify the situation, but bringing other users to support their cause or setting up a competitor.
Either way, this is all orthogonal to the First Amendment concern of this case.
This article makes it look like they are in support of the former (free speech) when in fact they are in support of their own butts.
Fighting for the First Amendment does promote feee speech. Without the First Amendment, free speech is dead. With it, it has a chance (but is not guaranteed).
e: At least when I disagree with somebody on an imageboard they don't go through my user profile and downvote every comment I've made in the past day like somebody just did to me here =p
a Platform that want special legal status from liability that other people do not get well that liability shield should and does come with strings attached and one of those strings should be neutrality
One Suggestion that I have seen talked about is to modify Sec 230 to says that a platform will only get immunity from liability if follow the the First Amendment of the US Constitution as if they were a US Government Agency, Thus only illegal content would be prohibited
Free speech versus the First Amendment.
One can believe private platforms have the right to regulate their content while holding the government doesn’t.