News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by eru on Monday June 01, 2020 @03:49AM (#23376192)
Why do you say Kathryn Marinello failed?

Compensation incentives are there for a reason. Acting according to them just means fulfilling the shareholders wishes. (Unless the shareholders are idiots or impotent and the board set the wrong incentives.)

Running a riskier strategy that fails under a pandemic is a perfectly cromulent business decision to make. Shareholders and creditors knew what they were in for.

Not all gambles pay off. That doesn't mean taking on any risk whatsoever is wrong.

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by virgilp on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:26AM (#23377035)
> Unless the shareholders are idiots or impotent and the board set the wrong incentives.

That's quite a big leap. Humans are exceptionally good at gaming objective metrics if that's all that matters... setting the right incentives is by no means something any non-idiot can do; it's in fact exceptionally rare to find people able to set right incentives for an entire organization (or for it's leadership; if the leadership doesn't inherently have the right motivation, I don't actually think you can fix that via a set of incentives; probably the best you can do is constantly-modifying incentives, tracking aggressively any sign of misaligned motivation etc)

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by eru on Monday June 01, 2020 @07:16AM (#23377306)
Yes, that is indeed a problem.

However, CEO and shareholders are playing a repeated game here. So they can retro-actively reward last years performance by giving more (or less) money for next year.

Mostly, shareholders do want CEOs to take some amount of risk. And giving your CEO eg stock options means you want to encourage risk taking.

If you want your CEO to be careful, you pay them in eg long term company debt instead.

Exactly how you align the precise risk appetites is a harder problem. And there might be some loopholes clever management can exploit. But the broad strokes are clear.

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by appleflaxen on Monday June 01, 2020 @07:59AM (#23377562)
> Humans are exceptionally good at gaming objective metrics if that's all that matters

I think that's OP's point: the board should understand that, and set them appropriately.

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by virgilp on Monday June 01, 2020 @08:21AM (#23377678)
And my point is that's basically impossible to "set them appropriately", and one shouldn't throw around strong words such as "idiots or impotents" for those failing to do so. Did the board fail in its mission? Obviously. But do only the idiots fail?
Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by 082349872349872 on Monday June 01, 2020 @05:32AM (#23376694)
Shareholders also diversify over several firms — so the individual parts of a portfolio should run at riskier positions on the efficient frontier than shareholders (already the investors with the highest risk appetite) wish to have for themselves.
Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by smt88 on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:54AM (#23377200)
Good comment that I was going to make myself. I hope you won't mind if I translate for people (perhaps non-native English speakers) unfamiliar with the jargon:

Large investors have stock in many companies. Some are low-risk, some are high-risk. Ideally, these will balance each other out. In theory, this allows large, publicly-traded companies to do risky things. Amazon was a great example of this for years.

The problem is that some companies are perceived as risky or not-risky by different investors.

If 30% of their shareholders want a conservative strategy and 30% of them want a risky strategy, the conservative shareholders will always win because it's easier to build a coalition around "don't do anything" than it is around "do something". "Do something" can mean any one of a billion different strategies, and it's very hard to get a large group to agree on one.

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by ramraj07 on Monday June 01, 2020 @04:21AM (#23376347)
So by that logic the shareholders and board members _were_ idiots then.
Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by xapata on Monday June 01, 2020 @04:29AM (#23376391)
Making a bet and losing doesn't imply idiocy. What were the odds? What was the potential payoff?
Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by eganist on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:21AM (#23377002)
The odds, according to more than a few scientists (but citing just one here: https://cmr.asm.org/content/20/4/660), were 100% in not too much time.

I don't know if that makes shareholders and board members "idiots," just that it's something the firm probably should've worked to mitigate a bit more effectively.

Example: EHI is still holding on, and they (from my understanding based on employees I've spoken with) had continuity planning in place for situations that might've significantly impaired travel.

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by eru on Monday June 01, 2020 @07:17AM (#23377318)
That's good on EHI. Though perhaps that planning would have cost some extra time and money that would have been 'wasted', if the pandemic hadn't happened.
Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by eganist on Monday June 01, 2020 @08:23AM (#23377690)
> perhaps that planning would have cost some extra time and money that would have been 'wasted', if the pandemic hadn't happened.

Same with insurance, which is why there are many cases where insurance is a requirement (usually cases where people dismiss the risk).

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by eru on Monday June 01, 2020 @04:41AM (#23376450)
Yes, exactly.

Though it's not just odds and payoff, but also risk appetite. There's something like risk-aversion, and a corresponding risk-return-tradeoff.

But unless we have evidence to the contrary, we can assume that the shareholders are broadly risk-neutral. Especially since lots of shareholding these days is via widely diversified index funds, who don't need to care whether a any single company they hold goes bankrupt as long as the expected value of gambles they take are positive.

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by tankenmate on Monday June 01, 2020 @05:28AM (#23376666)
Indeed, so the correct question is "was / is Icahn's risk margin (since he had the largest shareholding and he's a known activist) too small?" Was there an implied direction of getting new management in turning the ship around and then flipping it? Would this lead to good long term decisions being traded off for short term ones?
Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by oarsinsync on Monday June 01, 2020 @05:49AM (#23376800)
> But unless we have evidence to the contrary, we can assume that the shareholders are broadly risk-neutral. Especially since lots of shareholding these days is via widely diversified index funds

Except there are low and high risk index funds as well. Just because you're invested through a passive index fund, doesn't mean you're risk-neutral.

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by eru on Monday June 01, 2020 @07:18AM (#23377322)
Yes. Hence the 'broadly'.

As an investor, you can also always just add leverage to your index fund holding, if you want more risk. If your jurisdiction allows you, that is.

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by Tyrek on Monday June 01, 2020 @12:38PM (#23380429)
absolutely not. If shareholders were risk neutral, they'd be buying bonds, or holding cash. "passive" investment is wholly built upon the concept that "passive" investment outpaces active investment - the very fact that you're in the equity markets suggests you are chasing the 6-8%+ annualized returns (and associated risks) from equity investments. Passive is a replacement for stock picking, and while more conservative in nature, isn't really so in a relative sense.
Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by eru on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @11:28PM (#23399370)
> If shareholders were risk neutral, they'd be buying bonds, or holding cash.

Huh?

Many people hold both bonds and stocks and other assets, like real estate.

Index funds give you broad diversification at low fees. That diversification mostly removes out company-specific idiosyncratic risk, but it still leaves you exposed to market risk, and no one in their right mind claims otherwise.

Even a risk averse person (and even more a risk neutral person) can rationally hold on to very risky assets. Risk aversion just means that you require a higher return for a given level of risk.

And a risk neutral person doesn't care at all about risk, they only care about expected returns. That's mostly a convenient abstraction like the famous home economicus.

I don't understand why a risk neutral person would want to prefer bonds and cash?

Re:The Story of Hertz Going Bust by ponker on Monday June 01, 2020 @11:57AM (#23379900)
It does when you kill the entire company. It’s like losing your house in a game of poker — the problem wasn’t going all in with pocket aces, it was putting your house in the pot.