News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:01AM (#23359920)
> The daily shower would be hard to sustain in a world without fossil fuels.

If this is really true, then I see no hope for us. Humans will not make sacrifices to their way of life voluntarily, and will politically punish anyone who makes them do so. When this comes before the voters, “I am the person taking away your hot showers” is going to be a losing stance.

We can’t “conserve” our way out of this. We will need a breakthrough in clean energy tech. We need a world where the energy for hot showers is plentiful and clean.

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by chimprich on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:44AM (#23360160)
> Humans will not make sacrifices to their way of life voluntarily

I don't think that's true at all.

Currently (speaking from the UK at least) people have been making huge sacrifices in their lives for months. Although ostensibly this has been enforced, in reality it is impossible to police and has almost entirely been done voluntarily, through persuasion, and with much popular support. These sacrifices have been far greater than using less water in showers.

> We can’t “conserve” our way out of this. We will need a breakthrough in clean energy tech.

It's no use being defeatist about this when the problem is much greater than the solution.

It's as if at the start of WWII politicians started saying, well, people won't tolerate being conscripted and having rationing, we might as well do nothing.

Incidentally, I've heard wishes for breakthroughs in clean energy tech for decades, and we've since had major advances in things like solar, wind and batteries. We can hope for more advances in the coming years but we shouldn't bank on it - we have the technology already to tackle the problem.

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by switch007 on Saturday May 30, 2020 @07:08AM (#23360270)
> Although ostensibly this has been enforced, in reality it is impossible to police and has almost entirely been done voluntarily, through persuasion, and with much popular support.

I think the terrifying prospect of catching and spreading a virus was the greatest factor, having seen it spread elsewhere.

Also our compliance hasn't come out of nowhere. I feel we've become ever more subservient and unquestioning over the last 19 years. Barely anyone refers to the legislation (some of which is quite easy to read), but instead Government "rules". A worrying trend.

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by noir_lord on Saturday May 30, 2020 @07:19AM (#23360322)
Been a lot longer than 19 years, before 911 we had the Troubles and the Soviets as a convenient fig leaf to hide all sorts of justification behind.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Saturday May 30, 2020 @07:03AM (#23360252)
The examples you are giving are examples of short term sacrifices.

However, take a look at the UK post WWII. Winston Churchill got voted out of office. The big thing people wanted was a return to normalcy and the way things had been before.

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by lmm on Saturday May 30, 2020 @07:22AM (#23360336)
On the contrary, Atlee won the 1945 election on a platform of radical social reform: national healthcare, social security, and state-funded education.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by mhh__ on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:43PM (#23365489)
Normalcy as in voting in socialists?
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by rocky1138 on Saturday May 30, 2020 @09:45AM (#23361142)
This may be true for adults. The key is to teach children the proper methods so that when they grow up, being conservative will be natural.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by Ma8ee on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:44AM (#23360163)
It isn’t true. There isn’t any shortage of renewable energy sources, there’s just a cost of switching to them (and companies and states that depends on the income from the fossil fuels that resist the change).
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by kgin on Saturday May 30, 2020 @08:40AM (#23360743)
Even at this stage of development, the electricity needs of the US could be met by wind and solar. It would be extremely expensive, but it could be done.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by Ma8ee on Monday June 01, 2020 @02:42AM (#23375913)
Oh yes, without any problems. And the cost shouldn't be exaggerated, in particular compared with the costs of doing nothing at all to reduce CO2 emissions.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by MatekCopatek on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:23AM (#23360026)
"Humans" aren't an inherent unchangeable force of nature. What you're describing is a result of living in the current socio-economical system, which can be changed.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by throwaway894345 on Saturday May 30, 2020 @11:51AM (#23361970)
I took it as implied that the change has to happen in the near future, before runaway climate change is a fate-sealing certainty. And we don’t need to change the current socio-economic system in any fundamental way; we just need to tax pollution so the cost isn’t externalized. This is a pretty simple, small change; just need the political will.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by fulafel on Saturday May 30, 2020 @07:00AM (#23360239)
Humans make voluntary uncomfortable changes to their way of life all the time. They move to other countries / cities, break up and form new relationships, quit or pick up religion, become vegan, move to cabins from cities or vice versa, start families, volunteer to fight in wars etc etc. Whether the changes perceived as voluntary or not is highly subjective.

Shortening you shower time can feel like too small a change to feel like a meaningful, if anything.

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by thefounder on Saturday May 30, 2020 @07:13AM (#23360288)
>> "Humans make voluntary uncomfortable changes to their way of life all the time"

--- hoping their life will eventually improve(i.e work hard, make more money, then move to a nice neighbourhood where you can enjoy the fruits of your hard work). The religious people hope for a better life in heaven and so on. What's the incentive to for a worse showering experience? What do you get in return?

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by Spivak on Saturday May 30, 2020 @08:21PM (#23366070)
Monetary savings would probably be the main motivator for most people. Being seen as virtuous is also a huge motivating factor. That kind of shower being installed by default in hotels, rental properties, and new construction puts a tiny barrier to people being motivated enough to switch.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by fulafel on Saturday May 30, 2020 @07:52AM (#23360483)
Obviously the fight against climate change and saving untold billions of people from misery and death not to mention the rest of the biosphere. And everything that comes with that (like feeling better about yourself and the social/psychgological benefits from being part of a movement for good).
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by chongli on Saturday May 30, 2020 @09:02AM (#23360867)
I don’t know about those who volunteer to fight in wars but I’m pretty confident that people become vegans/environmentalists when the social benefits outweigh the costs of doing so. It’s not a coincidence that veganism and environmentalism cluster around left wing ideologies.

For a right wing person in a right wing area to become a vegan would have a social cost, not a social benefit, and thus is much less likely to happen.

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by kgin on Saturday May 30, 2020 @08:34AM (#23360721)
The reaction against the shutdowns in the US have made me realize this is 100% correct.

We can’t even address an actual situation happening this minute. We have no chance of finding the political will to address something where the consequences are years or decades away if it means asking people to do without.

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by rocky1138 on Saturday May 30, 2020 @09:46AM (#23361146)
There are many more countries around the world and most got on just fine with the shutdowns, lockdowns, and reduction in services.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by netsharc on Saturday May 30, 2020 @10:30AM (#23361433)
The threat of potential death within 2 weeks probably contributed to this. And after a few weeks people were getting antsy and screaming the need to go back to normal they assumed they'd get after 2-3 weeks of lockdown...
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by kgin on Saturday May 30, 2020 @10:48AM (#23361564)
Absolutely, and as with the Paris accord and every other attempt at taking action, the United States was the odd one out.

Our culture is a unique mixture of “you can’t tell me what to do” independence and “let me speak with the manager” entitlement.

It powers a lot of the great things about the United States, but also makes it hard to accomplish anything requiring doing without.

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by fock on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:46AM (#23360174)
You are aware that a shower every week or even clean water for consumption is _not_ available for 30% of "humanity": https://ourworldindata.org/water-access

I am not sure, how "I am gonna give you clean water and one shower a week" is a loosing stance with these people. Granted they are not the typical voters relevant in gerrymandering and co, but they are humans - and since we alle strive for global democracy instead of neocolonialism and imperialism and killing the poor (aren't we?), these people are a significant proportion of humanity.

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by thefounder on Saturday May 30, 2020 @07:20AM (#23360326)
Many people have a hard life(lack of food, clean water, decent shelder, education etc) and many other people don't care. This happens at a very local level(i.e people living on the same street or even in the same building) let alone globally. It happens even between relatives. That 88" TV in my living room is definitely a better proposition than sending the money to some poor people. The communist system promised economic equality and we've seen how it ended-up. I believe that instead of cutting off shower time we should invest more in technology. Make the oil companies pay for for this transition.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by fock on Saturday May 30, 2020 @07:55AM (#23360492)
the communist systems so far were mostly autocratic and yeah, most of them were not worse after a transition period than the previous autocrats and provided far more social mobility and care for poor people than a lot of other systems... I'm not sure how you mentioning an 88" TV helps for anything but blaring out you're a far-right bigot.

Btw: making the oil-companies pay at this point means no dividends from them immediately and them eventually folding very fast - how do you propose they pay for that transition then (especially with most of past dividends safely stored awy in trusts on Panama)? You could always tax fortunes I guess...

Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by billy_beef on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:19AM (#23360003)
Austerity measures are passed all the time under guises of a balanced budget or trimming fat. When govts cut food stamps people die, I think govts cutting hot showers might be doable.
Re:Mist Showers: Sustainable Decadence? (2019) by austinjp on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:22AM (#23360020)
While I partly agree with you, unpopular political moves are weaponised during elections. If the opposition win they can revoke previous changes. This highlights issues around populism, and democracy in general.