Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by hordeallergy on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:51AM
(#23348465)
If I'm not mistaken it's not the entire red series - it excludes 8TB.
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by nix23 on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:08AM
(#23348573)
True, there's a good list:
https://nascompares.com/answer/list-of-wd-cmr-and-smr-hard-d...
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by PeterStuer on Friday May 29, 2020 @08:03AM
(#23348948)
The original 2TB - 3TB - 4TB - 6TB Reds with the 'EFRX' suffix were CMR, the later ones with the 'EFAX' suffix are SMR drives.
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by donatj on Friday May 29, 2020 @08:17AM
(#23349057)
Update: EFBX looks to be entirely CMR
Know anything about EFBX? SMR I assume? I literally have one arriving today to replace a disk in my single disk redundancy JBOD
The whole disk buying process was irksome because I up until WD shut them down always depended on HGST.
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by PeterStuer on Saturday May 30, 2020 @08:58AM
(#23360849)
If you mean the FFBX (I can't find any reference to EFBX models), the Red Pro series, those are CMS (and 7200rpm which is what the B stands for).
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by WrtCdEvrydy on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:08AM
(#23348575)
8TB SMR does not currently exist in the consumer level.
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by d33 on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:50AM
(#23348840)
Not really true: https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=seagate%20archive%208t...
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by jotm on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:08AM
(#23348205)
On a related note, RAID rebuild failing on slower drives is ridiculous these days. Is it so hard to implement something like buffer underrun protection in CD/DVD writers? Or just longer/adjustable wait times?
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by zozbot234 on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:13AM
(#23348598)
These issues mostly crop up with hardware RAID controllers that were not designed for anything like that. And what you'd need is actually the opposite of buffer underrun protection; you have to protect against congestion, whereas having the drive idle would not per se be an issue.
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by ndespres on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:21AM
(#23348659)
The enterprise hardware RAID controllers have battery backed memory that is heavily utilized during a rebuild. Operations that would take days without it are reduced to hours. I'm not sure what a typical NAS does though.
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by ComodoHacker on Friday May 29, 2020 @05:44AM
(#23348068)
They were so assured in their drives' quality they haven't thought one of them can fail and others face rebuild workload.
/s
Re:Western Digital Lawsuit for Shipping Slower SMR Hard Driv...
by beagle3 on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:57AM
(#23348506)
Or, they may have actually tested raid rebuild on a system that did not have a single write during the rebuild and only with fresh drives - under this very specific use case, if the RAID controller does things right, all writes are sequential from the first disk sector until the last -- which is a use case that SMR doesn't slow down in; essentially, the only such use case.
When WD stealthily swapped to using device managed SMR technology in the series, they hoped that typical users wouldn't notice the change in behavior of the drives, as they assumed a small NAS would have enough downtime for the drive to manage the data being behind the scenes rearranged towards the slow shingled sections.
This assumption is not always true, but specifically it doesn't hold at all when an array has to be rebuild e.g. because of a drive failure in a raid array, as that requires writing data continuously and for a long time.
WD was caught not just using a technology that made their drives unsuited for the advertised purpose, but initially even denying that they had done so.