News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by krapp on Thursday May 28, 2020 @04:52PM (#23342433)
>It really is a public web space that is operated by a private company

No, it isn't, any more than a store is a public space because it has windows the public can see into. You have to sign up for a Twitter account and accept their terms of service to post on the site. It's a private platform run by a private company for its own private business interests.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by baddox on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:21PM (#23343568)
> No, it isn't, any more than a store is a public space because it has windows the public can see into.

It is absolutely the case in the USA that private properties which are open to the public are regulated as "places of public accommodation" under, notably, the Civil Rights Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act. That includes privately-owned hotels, schools, restaurants, retail, and more.

You're correct that this is directly analogous to a privately-owned website that is primarily geared toward accommodating the general public (like Twitter), but it makes the opposite point of what you intended.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_accommodations_in_the_U...

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by MrJagil on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:06PM (#23342627)
I think that’s a simplistic view. No one is arguing Twitter is comparable to a store with a display window. The reality is that Tweets are broadcasted to billions of people. It’s a new reality. It’s a newspaper where anyone and everyone is authoring anything, including presidents, and with the roll of a die, the message is amplified to a multiple of the expected audience.

Twitter may technically be a private platform run by a private company, but the issue not one of semantics, it’s about ethics and morals and how we compose a society with mighty power imbalances, fortified by new tech.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by krapp on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:24PM (#23342859)
>it’s about ethics and morals and how we compose a society with mighty power imbalances, fortified by new tech.

But that's not what this is really about.

This is about the President being angry that Twitter fact checked him and using executive power to create a chilling effect against any platform doing so in the future. It's about fears of a nonexistent conspiracy controlling the media becoming the basis for authoritarian laws meant to stamp out that menace - a phenomenon which never goes well, historically. It's about Americans hating "the left" so much that they'll support an obvious violation of the First Amendment as long as it silences their ideological enemies.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by akira2501 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:36PM (#23343001)
> This is about the President being angry that Twitter fact checked him and using executive power to create a chilling effect against any platform doing so in the future.

That is the impetus in this case, but that doesn't mean it doesn't border on questions we've been slowly grappling with for some time now, nor does it mean we have to ignore that question.

> the basis for authoritarian laws meant to stamp out that menace

I'm not sure it's authoritarian to remove their liability protections, is it? In a sense, I think it's an interesting question, if you're willing to editorialize content on behalf of your users why should you get safe-harbor protection? You clearly are willing to put the man power and technology into it, shouldn't you then be liable for content posted on your site?

> It's about Americans hating "the left" so much that they'll support an obvious violation of the First Amendment as long as it silences their ideological enemies.

What's the obvious First Amendment violation here? If you act as a conduit for certain types of speech, you're liable for that speech. We're just bringing "content neutral providers" into the same realm that everyone else already was.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by krapp on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:55PM (#23343243)
>I'm not sure it's authoritarian to remove their liability protections, is it?

If the intent is to punish critics and suppress the speech of party opponents, then yes. Any authoritarian can justify their actions in abstract and general terms, but context matters.

>nor does it mean we have to ignore that question.

We don't have to ignore it, but we also don't have to accept an autocrat's temper tantrum by fiat as an answer.

>What's the obvious First Amendment violation here?

The purpose of the First Amendment is to prevent the government from infringing freedom of speech - the President is attempting to use government power to infringe freedom of speech, to do exactly what the First Amendment was created to prevent.

Granted, the First Amendment only explicitly applies to Congress, but I feel like if states can be accused of violating it (as they often were regarding quarantine and shelter-at-home orders) then the President can as well.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by 2019-nCoV on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:19PM (#23343542)
> If the intent is to punish critics and suppress the speech of party opponents, then yes. Any authoritarian can justify their actions in abstract and general terms, but context matters.

This is literally what Twitter has been doing. Trump's order puts an end to it.

> We don't have to ignore it, but we also don't have to accept an autocrat's temper tantrum by fiat as an answer.

Exactly why Twitter needs to be stripped of their 230 protections.

> The purpose of the First Amendment is to prevent the government from infringing freedom of speech - the President is attempting to use government power to infringe freedom of speech, to do exactly what the First Amendment was created to prevent.

This is the government upholding free speech. Twitter's policies and their selective enforcement of such run directly contrary to the underlying tenets of free speech. This holds Twitter accountable for their "un-American" practices.

Although it may be hard to see through the vitriolic debates currently raging, this will be a net win for the internet. This will encourage decentralisation in so far as there is now a soft power cap on these big tech companies.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by thephyber on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:23PM (#23344300)
> This is literally what Twitter has been doing. Trump's order puts an end to it.

Debatable, on both points. There have been studies[1] that show that accounts are banned, but it's not necessarily because they are conservative accounts or conservative content. In a civil or criminal case, causation must be established. In this case, the president is making it very much more expensive for certain companies to defend themselves.

This EO is more likely to hurt YouTube than Twitter because it has the ability to get the Federal Government to no longer approve grants to Google subsidiaries and for government agencies to stop advertising with them.

> to be stripped of their 203 protections.

You mean The Communications Decency Act, Section 230?

> Twitter's policies and their selective enforcement of such run directly contrary to the underlying tenets of free speech.

That's interesting. Government law enforcers and prosecutors have the ability to use prosecutorial discretion. Are you saying that the government should be able to select who they prosecute, but that private organizations should not be allowed discretion to enforce their own contracts?

If ISPs (where content in a pipe is pretty close to comparable to Common Carrier standards) can't be held up to the standards of Net Neutrality, how can social media companies (where content is much more subjective to interpret as violations of their contract)?

> this will be a net win for the internet

That remains to be seen. I can see it being another tool where the executive branch gets to unilaterally change the definition of which internet companies get protections, not leveling the playing field.

> This will encourage decentralisation in so far as there is now a soft power cap on these big tech companies.

More likely there will be some obvious "unintended consequences" similar to what happened after Trump signed the FOSTA bill in 2018[2] (hint: multiple dating sites, including Craigslist sections, closed up shop). It will very likely increase the cost of being a user-generated content host to the point that only a very select few companies would do it and they will all require arbitration clauses in the ToS to avoid extremely expensive litigation of the CDA230 rules. I expect a handful of forums and lots of news comments sections to close due to this "free speech" Executive Order.

[1] https://www.cjr.org/the_media_today/platform-bias.php

[2] https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/23/596460672...

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by kryogen1c on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:23PM (#23343584)
> the President is attempting to use government power to infringe freedom of speech,

thats an interestating take, considering trump is trying to stop the selective editorialization of individuals covered by the first amendment.

are we really taking twitters side of this because we hate trump so much?

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by triceratops on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:13PM (#23344196)
So by your understanding of the First Amendment, if you had a blog with a comment section, I could come by and post spam, or troll and harass other users and you have no right to stop me?

Are you required to let me organize a protest in your front yard? Do property rights not matter anymore?

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by krapp on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:42PM (#23343831)
>thats an interestating take, considering trump is trying to stop the selective editorialization of individuals covered by the first amendment.

Again, the first amendment protects those individuals from being censored by the government. Twitter is not bound by the first amendment. They're allowed to editorialize content. They're allowed to curate, moderate, deplatform and ban people.

However, Twitter is also protected by the first amendment, and Trump's executive order is an attempt to erode those protections.

>are we really taking twitters side of this because we hate trump so much?

No. I believe in the right of platforms to censor content as an extension of their own freedom of speech and association, because that still leaves the internet itself free. If one objects to Twitter's behavior, one can always find a new platform or create one. However, when the government attempts to assert censorship over the entire network, that reduces freedom for everyone.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by unishark on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:24AM (#23346526)
The executive order is not touching the protections of the first amendment. The courts are still to protect them for that as always.

The order regards the additional protections of section 230 which even protect twitter for content that is not protected by the first amendment. Trump is essentially trying to say if Twitter takes sides by fact-checking some tweets, then they are also responsible for all the other "facts" they allow to be posted on their platform without fact-checking. And by the way the courts are still perfectly capable of deciding in favor of twitter regarding blame for all those other posts too. Twitter just won't be shielded by a special law from such decisions.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by perl4ever on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:57PM (#23344001)
Anyone who replies to you is guilty of selective editorialization of an individual covered by the first amendment. Except me. I'm not expressing an opinion. It seems unwise in an age like this.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by revscat on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:15PM (#23344777)
Trump is the head of the government. In his role, he is attempting to control private enterprise (and failing). It is laughable that you think him a victim given that he has the full force of the federal government at his beck and call. The fact that he has cried like a child about this is embarrassing, petulant, and disgusting.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by Mirioron on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:33PM (#23343719)
The talk is about rolling back special privileges that platforms get. Privileges that you and I don't have. If you publish something illegal then you bear the consequences. If a user on Twitter does it then Twitter doesn't bear the consequences, but the user does instead. Doesn't this mean it's the user that's expressing speech rather than Twitter?
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by JoshTriplett on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:52PM (#23343941)
> Privileges that you and I don't have.

You absolutely do. The same protection that applies to Twitter applies to a personal blog that allows comments, or any site that allows users to post.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by FireBeyond on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:59PM (#23344031)
> If you publish something illegal then you bear the consequences.

So let's look at today. You have a tweet from a conservative group that "concludes" that the only way forward for America is violent action, up to and including murder of political opponents. "The only good Democrat is a dead Democrat".

To me, it seems that there is a plausible argument to be made that this group is inciting violence.

And then Trump re-tweeted it, with the additional commentary, "Thanks, Cowboys of America!".

If we want to compare "consequences of speech and platforms", then on one hand we have hand-wringing about "Twitter _annotated_ a tweet with links to resources about the substance of that tweet", versus "group hints at violent oppression of political opponents, and is given the thumbs up by political leader".

I was going to say "I know which one I find more problematic", but lest someone attempt a slippery slope retort, I'll be more clear: I find only one of these actions at all problematic (and it's not annotation of tweets).

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by anigbrowl on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:41PM (#23343818)
If you act as a conduit for certain types of speech, you're liable for that speech.

There's some merit to that position, but things like adding a fact check (which you might or might not agree with) do not incur any sort of civil or criminal liability. You make good points, but we should also engage with the reality that the president and his supporters are demanding a quality of representation/protection for their political views that they don't have any particular entitlement to, and for which no mechanism currently exists in law; it seems (going by the general tenor of their arguments over the last few years) like they want to bring back the 'Fairness Doctrine' that obtained for broadcast media up to the Reagan era to create some protected space for their viewpoint.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by perl4ever on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:58PM (#23344017)
I didn't know the Fairness Doctrine was a mechanism to prevent the juxtaposition of opposing views.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by thephyber on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:33PM (#23344403)
> to prevent the juxtaposition of opposing views

The way I interpreted it, your parent comment was arguing the opposite of the way you framed it.

It's a long run-on sentence, but the `;` is meant to be interpreted as "start a new sentence that is related to the previous one"

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by perl4ever on Thursday May 28, 2020 @10:07PM (#23345573)
I don't know what it was arguing. It seemed to be implying that the Fairness Doctrine created a protected space. Didn't it do the opposite?
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by visarga on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:12PM (#23344189)
> You clearly are willing to put the man power and technology into it, shouldn't you then be liable for content posted on your site?

Power and technology can't curate content to the level where you are safe from lawsuits. What you're saying is that if they are willing to do a bit of moderation they should do total moderation.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by jjcon on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:38PM (#23343034)
Again, this has been drafted since at least last summer and has little to do with the recent twitter news.

https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/28/politics/trump-twitter-social.... > consistent with a draft order whose text CNN first reported last summer

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by joshuamorton on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:46PM (#23343132)
If it has little to do with the recent twitter news, why is it signed today instead of last week?
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by Mirioron on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:34PM (#23343739)
They were probably waiting for one of the social media platforms to screw up somehow.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by FireBeyond on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:03PM (#23344074)
1. That link is broken.

2. What was drafted last summer was legislation. Legislation that would likely not stand up to political or legal resistance. This is an executive order to make an end-run around all that "bureaucracy".

> has little to do with the recent twitter news.

This fails the plausibility test. This came hot on the heels of this incident, Trump _said_ it was related to this incident, and that he'd be doing this as result, and the last several years are packed with a multitude of examples of exactly that: Trump knee-jerking an angry response (words, actions, both) to those who he deems to have slighted him.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by jjcon on Thursday May 28, 2020 @11:26PM (#23345992)
Can’t edit so here is the fixed link

https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/28/politics/trump-twitter-social...

And no it wasn’t legislation it was a draft of an executive order from last summer as mentioned in this article.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by threeseed on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:11PM (#23342695)
Newspapers have restricted what they publish for centuries.

They don't allow libellous, defamatory, salacious or inappropriate comments for example.

So it sounds 'new tech' hasn't really changed anything.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by jtbayly on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:50PM (#23343176)
Newspapers do that because they are liable for what they publish. Twitter is not liable for what it publishes. Why should it not be liable? The answer is because they are just providing a platform and others are publishing. But the moment they use their platform to modify and censor what people publish, then they should probably be liable, right?
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by thomaslord on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:01PM (#23344645)
I don't see why they should be.

If someone uploads their library of child porn encoded to base64 split across tons of tweets, do you want Twitter to have a choice between removing that content and continuing to operate?

We have 3 options here:

1. No moderation allowed whatsoever on a site without a court order. That obviously leads to a terrible, toxic community with lots of reprehensible content that the average person wouldn't want to participate in.

2. A good faith effort at moderation. This allows the most reprehensible, highest-impact content to be removed and allows users to participate in the moderation process.

3. No content can be published without moderation, on any site anywhere. Want to post a Facebook status? Have fun paying $20 for the privilege of waiting 48 hours for a human to review it.

All of this is irrelevant though, because this executive order is not targeted at censorship. It's targeted at a private individual who voluntarily, for free, passed on a message from one person to many other people and decided to tell them "this seems fishy, you might want to read up on it."

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by berryjerry on Friday May 29, 2020 @04:50AM (#23347776)
Twitter is actually required by law to remove child porn, not being forced to keep it up, that would be insane. This isn't a call for no moderation, it is a call for a neutral platform when companies are on the verge of monopolies. They are definitely monopolize your followers, switching platforms is not even a choice. You can work you're entire life building a channel and audience on social media site and they can take it away in a heartbeat and you don't even get a chance to let your followers know what happened, e-mail them even, let them know where they can find you going forward. That's not the worst part, the worst part is they can and do do it without any reason whatsoever, it could be just because someone at the company dislikes what you said. Again this is not about moderation, this is about companies that were built off of being a neutral platform that cannot be sued for liability, like a phone company but are now using their monopoly over your follower's information to hold over you and control what you say. If anything what really needs to be in legislation is rights to notify followers where else they can find you if you are banned or censored.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by belorn on Friday May 29, 2020 @04:50AM (#23347774)
There exist many more options and law is notorious for having grey zones where the complexity of context, and intent and outcomes.

In the specific example of child porn, would removing it be protected speech and a copyrightable work? To my knowledge, no, it is not.

However telling someone "this seems fishy, you might want to read up on it.", attached to someone else copyrighted work, is to me speech. It is also a copyrightable work if its original enough. It could also be a defined as a derivative work if it includes major copyrightable elements of the original, which in this context is likely.

The difference between removing child porn and creating derivative work is one that I don't think courts will have a problem to distinguish between. Both may end up being described as moderation, but the outcome, intent and context is very different.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by perf1 on Friday May 29, 2020 @03:12AM (#23347091)
Why have a Supreme Court or even normal Judges if Laws are only allowed to be this binary? Why not option 4 you are allowed to censor if you give reason and the reason is in your TOS. But you are for example not allowed to Edit (Fact Check), Censor or manipulate Votes of your political opponents, or loose your libel protections.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by triceratops on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:22PM (#23344295)
Why should they "probably be liable"?

Twitter isn't liable for illegal content posted by their users, as long as they take it down in time and make good faith efforts to keep it from being posted in the first place. If they weren't free from liability then a service like Twitter would need heavy human moderation and be extremely expensive to operate - perhaps it wouldn't exist at all.

That's the only reason this non-liability exists. It has nothing to do with moderation or censorship. Twitter, as any other web property, have the right to curate their platform and make it pleasant for their other users. It's their personal property.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by anigbrowl on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:51PM (#23343928)
but newspapers aren't required to express support for particular political candidates or viewpoints. That can get into trouble for publishing libel, ie maliciously presenting false statements as fact, but the criteria for what constitutes libel are very narrow. A newspaper can certainly publish an opinion like 'Politician X is a fool whose proposal should be ignored.'
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by jeremyjh on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:48PM (#23343904)
> But the moment they use their platform to modify and censor what people publish, then they should probably be liable, right?

They've always done some editing and removal of certain content.

In this particular case, was anything modified or censored though? It seems more like Trump had his say, and Twitter had theirs. Is Trump saying that Twitter can't also express themselves on their platform?

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by visarga on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:16PM (#23344232)
> But the moment they use their platform to modify and censor what people publish, then they should probably be liable, right?

There are degrees to moderation, but not to liability. This black or white approach doesn't seem appropriate. They should be liable in a degree proportional to the moderation they introduce.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by rbanffy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:17PM (#23342762)
Newspapers hire and pay people to write for them and exercise editorial control on everything that's published.

That's very different from, say, a public restroom where people write on the walls. The owner of the restroom is not responsible for what people write on their walls.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:48PM (#23343157)
> Newspapers hire and pay people to write for them

Newspapers also have zero obligation to convey the words of the President, and by frequently contextualise them.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by pnw_hazor on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:12PM (#23343473)
And newspapers get sued if their paid editors publish defamatory content.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by rbanffy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:43PM (#23343842)
And that's totally fair, because the hired the person, vouched for them, submitted them to editorial scrutiny an, still, decided to publish defamatory content.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by suff on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:35PM (#23342982)
It would be, if the owner began editorializing the content, because the point at which they get involved, they lose neutrality, and therefore Section 230 immunity protection.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by luckylion on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:41PM (#23343077)
> Newspapers have restricted what they publish for centuries.

Absolutely. And they don't say "we're just a platform transporting information", they restrict what they publish.

> They don't allow libellous, defamatory, salacious or inappropriate comments for example.

They do. And they get sued for it, and they can lose, see Gawker. Precisely because they are not like Twitter.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by gamblor956 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:23PM (#23343586)
The reality is that Tweets are broadcasted to billions of people.

No, they're not. You have to visit the Twitter website or otherwise pull the data from some source to get tweets.

it’s about ethics and morals and how we compose a society with mighty power imbalances, fortified by new tech.

It's technically trivial to create your own Twitter. There are indeed plenty of competitors to Twitter. Twitter has no moral or ethical obligation to carry lies. Indeed, the opposite is true: because of their market position, they should be ethically and morally obligated to prevent lies from being spread through their platform because they have the greatest reach.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by Mirioron on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:38PM (#23343781)
>No, they're not. You have to visit the Twitter website or otherwise pull the data from some source to get tweets.

Would you make this same argument when it comes to privacy? Technically it's your computer sending your data to Google/Facebook, therefore you are giving them permission to use your data, because you're so generously providing it to them. Technically this is true and any real privacy solution would have to address this point, but it's clearly not what is done in legislation.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by gamblor956 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:15PM (#23344214)
I don't understand your point.

When you send your data to Google or Facebook by explicitly providing that data, you are giving them permission to use that data for purposes of providing the service for which the data is granted. This is true everywhere, even in the EU.

If you're asking whether that upload would grant Googlebook broader rights to use your data, then the answer is yes in the US because there are no laws currently restricting such use, but no in Europe because EU law says permission must be explicitly granted for other uses.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by DEADBEEFC0FFEE on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:30PM (#23342928)
I think you're overestimating the number of users. Hardly anyone I know uses Twitter. It may be a big thing for you but it's largely irrelevant for others. It's an opt-in service
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by phkahler on Thursday May 28, 2020 @04:57PM (#23342502)
You have to pay the old telephone company and it's a lot more private communication than Twitter. Yet they had common carrier statis, which is how we should want ISPs regulated. Where twitter and friends fit simply hasn't been defined yet.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by komali2 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:01PM (#23342573)
The argument falls apart at the ISP level - why does the UN consider internet a human right, but not, specifically, access to Twitter? It may seem like there's no distinction at all but it is there and it is important.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by threeseed on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:09PM (#23342675)
Much better examples than Twitter.

If I have the right to every website then how about password-protected ones. Do I then have the right to demand that Apple give me access to everyone's iCloud website ?

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by rbanffy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:18PM (#23342778)
Because you need a phone to phone someone, call an ambulance or the police. You need an ISP to get to the internet.

You don't need Twitter.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by salawat on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:32PM (#23342947)
That's actually kind of funny right there. Politically, internet access is being championed as a fundamental human right (I.e. being classified as a need).

Yet we still have people trying to define what activity on the Net constitutes the necessity that access is supposed to fulfill.

I understand where you're coming from though. I just wanted to point out the amusing dichotomy that stood out in my head.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by rbanffy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:07PM (#23343387)
Right to access the internet is much more important for allowing someone to interact with the government through their various websites and to access sources of information that allow people learn and to fully exercise their rights.

As much as Twitter is important, it's not nearly as important.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by berryjerry on Friday May 29, 2020 @05:07AM (#23347866)
If you have followers on a twitter you have already built then it is just as important, especially if you have 20 million followers you stand to lose if twitter just decides they don't like you. For many it is your job, your livelihood, and your outlet to the world. For people and companies it may be the only way to reach out for collaboration with someone who you do not have a phone number yet and a twitter follower count is often used as a indicator that you are who you say you are, a filter of sorts. Since you can't go and meet every stranger in person elsewhere it is a requirement to have. Some people may not use twitter or only follow and never tweet but a lot of people use it as a necessity for communication, their personal well being, and businesses. Like it or not Twitter is worth billions for a reason and that reason is it provides a necessity for many that they cannot get elsewhere. The sheer size of Twitter already self-perpetuates their monopoly over that method of communication. It doesn't matter that you can go to Facebook if Twitter bans you. Take another industry for example such as TV. Disney bought Fox but was forced to sell Fox Sports because otherwise Disney would have had close to a monopoly on sports content as it already owned ESPN. Note it was not TV, it was only sports, a sub section of TV where they were deemed to have too much control. The internet monopolies just haven't had to face a determination of what is and isn't a subsection of social media but to be sure they are monopolies of public discourse.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by sneak on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:26PM (#23342874)
Forget Twitter, and substitute “gmail deliverability”? Without that, you cannot run a business.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by rbanffy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:08PM (#23343412)
Do you need Twitter to interact with your bank? To pay your taxes? To buy groceries? Is it the only way you have to reach your family?
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by sneak on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:17PM (#23343523)
When my Twitter account was suspended recently after 12 years, I also lost access to my DM history, including usernames which I had not memorized.

For some of my friends, Twitter was the only contact information I had for them. I have now totally lost the ability to communicate with those friends in the midst of a global emergency, even if I make a new account (which itself would be subject to immediate termination at any time), because I don’t know their usernames.

A few of the closest ones fortunately noticed my absence without prompting, went to my profile, saw it suspended, went to my website (I presume it helped that my username, @sneakdotberlin, describes my website address), and emailed me. As for the busier or less attentive friends? No word yet. :(

You can’t export your data or do “data takeout” from a suspended account, sadly, and you can’t view your DM history either inbound or outbound.

EDIT: Also, I do need Twitter (and a high follower count) to meaningfully interact with my bank or my airline’s (or Google’s) customer service department. The 1-800-i’m-a-schnook line doesn’t seem to get things done.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by rbanffy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:33PM (#23343720)
> You can’t export your data or do “data takeout” from a suspended account, sadly, and you can’t view your DM history either inbound or outbound.

This is a big problem.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by thephyber on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:03PM (#23344660)
That example seems like something you can fix yourself by keeping offline backups of content that you need (general gd practice for all digital content).

More impactful would be access to any accounts which you only have access to with Twitter/Facebook/Google/etc federated login (like OAuth). It's very significant if you can't access your email/cloud/DNS accounts if you make a gray area ToS-violating comment/video on YouTube.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by Normille on Friday May 29, 2020 @11:09AM (#23350830)
This is not only a big problem, but it seems to be in flagrant breach of GDPR regulations:

https://stiobhart.net/2020-03-18-twittergdpr/

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by sneak on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:55PM (#23353245)
The GDPR simply doesn’t apply to most internet users or most internet companies.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by phkahler on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:37PM (#23343765)
>> Forget Twitter, and substitute “gmail deliverability”? Without that, you cannot run a business.

I was going to say it's not really about access but censorship. Using gmail as an example is nice because I do appreciate their spam filtering which spammers might consider a form of censorship (lack of deliverability). And yet I'm against platforms like twitter censoring things. The spam situation quickly leads into another set of arguments with me about traceability.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by sneak on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:08PM (#23344124)
I imagine this is because you haven’t been bitten by missing critical emails due to gmail’s overzealous spam filtering.

This has happened to me multiple times. Most people would likely never notice the opportunities they missed as a result of such.

I’m talking about real live false positives, on important messages from real live human beings.

Additionally, gmail spam folders even well run, nonspam, properly configured and secured mailservers AFAICT simply for not being part of the wider deliverability cartel.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by CamperBob2 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:28PM (#23342896)
That arguably changes when the President starts to use it as a primary means of communication with the citizenry.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by rbanffy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:10PM (#23343437)
They didn't remove his message. They merely pointed out it was misinforming the public.

Speaking of which, shouldn't we make it a crime to lie or substantially mislead the public while holding public office?

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by CamperBob2 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:14PM (#23343493)
Yeah, I don't disagree with their actions in this case -- if anything, they didn't phrase it strongly enough. ("Get the facts about voting by mail," as opposed to "Caution: this Tweet is unadulterated horseshit.")

But I also think that the more Twitter is used to disintermediate political communication, the more it starts to look like a vital public utility. It's tough to say where the line will or should be drawn. I don't envy Jack Dorsey's position, that's for sure.

As far as making a law that prohibits politicians from lying to the public, I don't see a way to write a law like that without making the situation even worse.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by Izkata on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:32PM (#23343709)
> "Caution: this Tweet is unadulterated horseshit."

Except it's not. Trump is right here; most of the confirmed voter fraud is on mail-in and absentee ballots, despite being less used than in-person in the past decades. Switching everyone to mail-in will cause a sharp uptick in voter fraud.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by jessaustin on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:46PM (#23343885)
I hear this from friends who are Limbaugh fans, but I'd like to see some other source. Many people on the Left seem to think this whole "voter fraud" concern is a fig leaf for denying minorities their voting rights. When I've listened and asked follow-up questions, the Left's narrative seems more plausible.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by Izkata on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:54PM (#23343972)
PDF of individual confirmed cases: https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/files/docs/p...

Spot-checking and using search for counts, most are manipulation of mail-in or absentee ballots (many being a bunch of ballots by a single person), with the next highest looking like individual people voting who didn't realize they were ineligible.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by mattkrause on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:17PM (#23344234)
These don't seem like vast criminal conspiracies. Also, if they can successfully prosecute little cases like these....what's the problem?

"Carlos Lopez and his wife, Luz Lopez, registered to vote and voted on three separate occasions (2004, 2006, and 2007) in Hartford, where they own a furniture store, while actually living in Farmington." (Fittingly, this story is included twice: once with each spouse first).

"In 2009, Lillian Cummings Stevenson agreed to a consent order after the State Elections Enforcement Commission found her guilty of illegally signing and submitting two absentee ballot request forms on behalf of her sons, who were living in Europe. She was given a $200 fine."

"James Bryant, Jr. admitted to improperly assisting voters in completing their absentee ballots in the 2005 Americus mayoral election...."

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by CamperBob2 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:02PM (#23344073)
OK, now where's the .PDF of individual confirmed cases of in-person vote fraud versus vote-by-mail fraud? We can't compare fractions by their numerators, you know.

The document itself admits that it is "only a sampling," which, in the absence of further methodological detail, should raise their hairs on the back of your neck.

Nobody ever said that vote-by-mail is fraud proof, only that it's good enough. Which it indisputably is, at least as implemented here in Washington state.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by Izkata on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:20PM (#23344824)
> only that it's good enough

Well.. How about another case I just learned of today? 'Cause it kinda doesn't seem like we're even at "good enough":

> “Invalidate the election. Let’s do it again,” said Rev. Kenneth Clayton said amid reports more that 20 percent of all ballots were disqualified, some in connection with voter fraud allegations.

[..]

> In addition to apparent problems with the vote count in Paterson, NBC New York has shown video of ballots left out in building lobbies, of one voter handling many ballots, and reported on postal workers reporting finding hundreds of ballots at a time stuffed in mailboxes in Paterson – and even in a neighboring town, Haledon.

https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/politics/nj-naacp-leader-cal...

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by CamperBob2 on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:25PM (#23356280)
'Data' isn't the plural of 'anecdote.' What are the actual statistics? Do we even have access to statistics that haven't been cherry-picked by the Heritage Foundation, the DNC, or another interested party?

One good aspect of the vote-by-mail system we use here in WA is that the voter retains a code they can use to verify that their ballot has been counted. There is an auditable paper trail at every step that's accessible to all parties - the voter, the election officials, and the candidate. That's more than you get with many in-person voting systems, especially those involving closed-source machines made by companies with questionable ethics and engineering practices.

Yes, I'm sure it's possible to build a vote-by-mail system that is more prone to corruption than in-person voting. But the point is, it's not necessary.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by perl4ever on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:15PM (#23344213)
My understanding is that he supported the concerns about fraud with a specific lie (maybe more than one) about how the state authorities are sending out ballots to everyone, whereas they are only sending them to registered voters.

This could, and presumably is intended to, mislead people on both sides of the political spectrum.

Assuming for the sake of argument that someone could be trying to promote a fundamental truth using lies, it doesn't make it sane to trust or acquiesce as a result of lies.

Maybe in our brave new world, disbelieving in something because it is supported with lies is an example of an ad hominem fallacy?

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by newacct583 on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:18AM (#23346495)
> Except it's not. Trump is right here; most of the confirmed voter fraud is on mail-in and absentee ballots,

Thomas Bayes is screaming in his grave, something about cancer diagnoses...

Actually I don't know if that's even true. And almost all the significant cases of any kind of election fraud aren't about ballots at all. It's stuff like voting in the wrong jurisdiction, or count fraud, or registration fraud.

Please cite me where you got the info that most election crime is from remote voting. That info doesn't exist.

What does exist is the facts in the WaPo article that twitter linked, which show that effectively zero mail-in ballot fraud is happening.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by username90 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:36PM (#23343762)
> They didn't remove his message. They merely pointed out it was misinforming the public.

Why should a private company have this power? I don't think that people who run a successful website automatically are qualified to fact check the president and insert blurbs directly in his messages. That needs to be regulated some way.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by perl4ever on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:17PM (#23344237)
Your tone is as if they were editing his message. I don't believe they were doing that in a way that would create any confusion as to what he wrote, were they?
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by username90 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:34PM (#23344407)
It doesn't matter, they didn't post a message like everyone else instead they made an official statement using their own privileged way. It is fine to do it on this message, I don't see the harm, but if this continues and people gets used to that blurb then Twitter will definitely start misusing it sooner or later. I don't think that companies should have this kind of power to influence public discourse, I might not agree with Trump but I really think that we need to limit the power big tech companies have.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by perl4ever on Thursday May 28, 2020 @10:23PM (#23345669)
Twitter already limits and controls virtually every other user, so is that a problem, and if so, why is this the trigger?
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by rbanffy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:42PM (#23343833)
If you are using my product to harm others, I should have the right to try to minimize the damage you cause.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by username90 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:36PM (#23344419)
This tool is not regulated, they could use it to cause harm. It doesn't matter if it was used for good this one time.

And no, them being a private company doesn't matter. Currently they have a lot of power thanks to them having a lot of important users, and now that they are starting to use that power we need to quickly come up with regulations for it.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by pnw_hazor on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:39PM (#23343795)
The difference is that stores and malls invite the public in for a limited non-protected purpose - shopping or other commercial activity.

Twitter invites the public in to exercise free speech, which in a public space would be protected. This invites an analysis that Twitter may be a quasi-public space that offers some 1st Amd. protections.