You can test this theory by reading three similar books in a row on an unfamiliar subject. You’ll remember more of the third book than the first.
That's not a very useful scenario when talking about reading X books a month and retaining Y percent. If you don't control for how much of the information is new, then the % retention is pretty arbitrary. You can read the same book 3 times and I'm sure you'll get better retention on the third repetition.
That is just not the case. The brain does not work that perfect way. It tends to remember new info about stuff you already know a lot about.
That is whole reason for reading for retention is to hack the brain so that it remembers what I want to remember.
One of my all time favorite podcasts is about it: https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/episodes/91569...
I’m sure science has progressed but I listened to this many years ago.
You might dig it.
The evolution did not optimized my brain to remember all the things I want to remember, whether from reading or listening. So I gotta hack it.
The evolution did not made us perfect.
I am not aware of any evidence this is true. Can you point me to any evidence to that effect?
> According to Herman Goldstine, the mathematician John von Neumann was able to recall from memory every book he had ever read.
'for a brief period' is key here.
Also from the same wikipedia article:
> Each year at the World Memory Championships, the world's best memorizers compete for prizes. None of the world's best competitive memorizers has a photographic memory, and no one with claimed eidetic or photographic memory has ever won the championship.
...
> According to Herman Goldstine, the mathematician John von Neumann was able to recall from memory every book he had ever read.
That's just what some guy said.
> There are many examples of people with prodigious natural gifts for memory and more who trained it.
For example?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_claimed_to_poss...
> A number of people claim to have eidetic memory, but science has never found a single verifiable case of photographic memory.
I'd assume based on personal experience that higher retention rates occur in subjects the reader is already familiar with. If you're reading into a subject you're not familiar with and rely on "your brain" to optimize what's most relevant for that subject I'd bet you'd come out looking like the stereotypical "know it all" in any related conversation.
In that case only a fraction of the information in the book can really be learned. Yes, you can read a book you already know very well and retain 95% of the information, but then what's the point of even citing any numbers?
> If you're reading into a subject you're not familiar with and rely on "your brain" to optimize what's most relevant for that subject I'd bet you'd come out looking like the stereotypical "know it all" in any related conversation.
Only if you think you retain 90% of what you read.
You might also find spaced repetition cool: https://ncase.me/remember/
It doesn’t invalidate people that read at 2x normal speed, it just depends on the kind of book you’re reading. I’m able to listen to some books at 2.5x but it’s always the same kind of book: non fiction, business related, those books that in the end you think it could be a blog post rather than a 500 pages book.
Don't get me started on those books... They're essentially a result of a market failure - since the readers are not willing to pay for blog posts, but will buy books, the writers are incentivised to dress up their blog posts as books... This is enromously wasteful, as millions of people are wasting their time reading the filler necessary to reach an acceptable book size (typically a minimum of 150 pages).
Reading books and trying to remember the maximum information seems rather pointless unless you're specifically studying for an exam or something. Your brain already optimises and retains the most relevant/interesting information for you. We don't have limitless memory and we need to forget things in order to learn new ones. Reading 3 books per month and retaining 90% seems both highly unlikely and pointless in the long term.