Muni wants to keep tax base and halo effect, but maybe also wants an extra cut of the upside. Startup wants to expand, but also establish a base of operations. Everyone wants something and has a backup threat just in case. The dance ensues.
SF has some interesting tax policies. I had a startup in SF lo so many years ago. Our total capitalization was $30K. We spent about $15K (on equipment and rent, no salaries) total before shutting down. A few months later SF City/County tried to collect a /$69K/ payroll tax bill based on... well, I never figured out what. I sent them a letter + documentation and never heard about it again.
For anyone who wants to move a company there, they don't have much amenities. They have a single chinese restaurant, una taqueuria, and have a stellar coffee shop, but its not open long enough for the hacker personality.
Brisbane is a small town that used to be lively during the days of Johnny Cash. Its not a substitute for a city like San Francisco or even a south bay area like Mountain View. Its that mountain town you see up in Tahoe, but 1 mile south of the city. I actually suggest making a daytrip to hike the abandoned railroads through it.
If they were to move into the open buildings in the area, this could make lives of people who use public transit annoyed. The Caltrain stations are 1 mile away on each side away from Brisbane, there is only a single SamTrans running along Bayshore and forget BART, its way too far. Biking is your best bet via caltrain.
Since Brisbane is an economical situation where they are talking about shutting down the elementary and highschools, this could be a very good thing for the city. As for Twitter and other companies alike, its a question about what type of culture they want to grow. As a resident of the area, I prefer living in Brisbane, rather than working.
You hear SF trying to ride the coattails of stratups everywhere. SF the 'heart of silicon valley', 'the epicenter of entrepreneurship', etc, etc. but on the other hand, it s as if they want to do as much as they can to drive job-growing business away and let SF just become the kitchen/dining room to silicon valley.
†This is of course, patently false. Oh sure, the storm was bigger and nastier, but if you do insist on building your city below sea level, then route crucial funds from the Army Corps of Engineers who are supposed to keep the levees strong, to some Blackwater dudes playing 'choose your own adventure' in the Middle East...
Let me help you, since you are being so pointedly blind to your own offensiveness. (Which only hurts your ability to be pithy and forceful, by the way.)
This is a conversation about tax breaks and municipalities, in this case, the subjects involve SF and some startups.
This particular thread was an aside about Australia, because of the name "Brisbane".
You derailed it into a micro-rant about a recent tragedy, and then threw in an even less relevant slam on the US.
I'm not the most popular person here on HN. I've gotten into it with Justin of Justin.tv before because I was calling out some of the more offensive startup hysteria/bullshit.
You are something else entirely. You're not an iconoclast.
You are the 25 year old whose parents died when he was 2 y/o and won't shut up about it at the bar.
Have yourself a coke, a smile, and shut the fuck up.
City hall and the Asian Art Museum are one block north. The opera, symphony and ballet are two blocks northwest. There are two high-rise, luxury condominium buildings directly across the street. Walk 10 minutes west, and you're smack in the middle of one of the city's up-and-coming neighborhoods (Hayes Valley), replete with boutique shopping, gourmet coffee stands and antique stores.
If offering Twitter a sweetheart lease on a gigantic building in a gentrifying urban neighborhood and giving them a tax break is enough to drive them away, then I sincerely wish Twitter luck in trying to retain their employees once they move to Brisbane. What've they got out there? A Taco Bell?